Facebook PixelFrench Box Subscription Review - September 2014 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

French Box Subscription Review – September 2014

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanSep 15, 2014 | 92 comments

French Box Subscription Review - September

Finally - the first French Box has arrived! (I think this is one of the most anticipated subscription box launches this year!)

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Unboxing

I took a lot of unboxing photos because the packaging is just gorgeous!

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Ribbon

My Subscription Addiction pays for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Items

The Subscription Box: French Box

The Cost: $24 a month (First box special – $14!)

The Products: Each box contains 5 products from French brands: fashion, cosmetics, gourmet and others surprises! FrenchBox is the best way to discover or share the latest products from France.

Ships to: US only.

Delivered via: USPS

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Box Info

This month is grape harvesting season in France, and they included a wine inspired recipe:

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Pear

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Card

Each box comes with a card detailing the items included.

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Postcard

The box also came with this cute postcard.

Now on to the actual items!

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Lip Liner

Sothys Lip Pencil in #3 Naturel - FULL SIZE! Value $16

This is the one item not listed on the card, so I'm guessing it may vary box-to-box.

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Lipstick

Sothys Hydra-Glide Liptsick in #20 Brun chaud - FULL SIZE! Value $25

Caudalie Makeup Remover Cleansing Water - 30 ml Value $4

This lipstick is a little on the dark side (and orange side) for me, but I'll definitely use the makeup remover.

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Gummies

BuddyFruits Fruit Bites - Value $1.50

Missiu Eiffel Tower Bracelet - Value $12

I get way too excited about gummies made with natural ingredients - these were gone in a minute!

Here's a better look at the bracelet:

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Bracelet

This is the only item in the box that doesn't feel Paris chic to me.

French Box Subscription Review - September 2014 Tote

Whispering Angel Wine Bag - Value $15

I love this wine tote! Now if only I could order Whispering Angel wine online!

Verdict: I paid $17 for this box (I bought a year subscription at the discount they were offering upfront). I received over $70 worth of items - a great value for a first box! I was pretty nervous about buying a full year subscription without seeing a box first, but now I can relax! Plus the packaging of this box is so fantastic - it feels like opening a gift.

What do you think of the first French Box? Did you get different variations than my box?

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

92 comments

Melissa

My October box was delivered today. I’m on my way home from a business trip and can’t wait to tear into it!

Loved the style and value of the first box, even though the makeup items were not good options/ colors for me (got the eye pencil and dark polish; would have preferred the lipstick/lip pencil). The contents of the second box will determine whether this sub is a keeper or not.

Reply ButtonReply

Melissa

October FrenchBox Spoiler Alert!!!

An interesting mix in my October Box and I personally really like the curation on this one. Almost everything is full-size.
The theme is The Warmth of Provence.
My box includes:
– A colorful card containing a Provencal proverb
– Full-size bag (3.5 oz.)of delicious-smelling Herbs de Provence
– A recipe card with recipes for provencal dips
– Full-size Matis powder brush.
– Full-size Durance Savon de Marseille soap in lovely packaging plus a coupon code for 15% off any Durance purchase
– Sample bag with an assortment of 4 mini Calissons (a type of sweet treat)
= A package filled with 3 individually wrapped Oshibori refreshing towels, infused with green tea extract. Love these – perfect for tucking in my purse or briefcase
– Sample vial of Atelier cologne

The items above were all pictured and described on the insert that discusses the theme of the box. The listed values total $41.39
But there’s more! My box also contained:
– a small notebook with a fashion sketch by Christian LaCroix on the cover and
– A full-size Sothy’s mascara

The mascara is worth approx $18-20, so the total value of this box was more than $60.

Reply ButtonReply

Cindy

I got what you did except for the mascara. I got a cream eye shadow in some very dark color.

WWP

Please share deets!!!

Reply ButtonReply

PA Anna

Received my tracking number for my October box!!!

Reply ButtonReply

PA Anna

They posted on Facebook they are aiming to ship on the 13th and tracking emails will be in our inbox on Monday! I wonder if my tracking will update on this box because it did not on the first box causing me to wonder if I will receive one until it showed up right on time.

Reply ButtonReply

PA Anna

I checked their Facebook page and it says that the boxes are shipping soon. The spoiler is “a warm region of France”. Can’t wait.

Reply ButtonReply

Vianny

Got my box yesterday love everything, the only thing is that I had the yellow bracelet and yellow is my least fave color, so if anyone want to swap or switch please let me know :

I got the orange fruits, delicious. Fushia nail color plain beautiful. The anti-wrinkle cream, my pencil is a dark brown, love as I didnt have one 🙂

Cant wait for the next one. My birthday month.

Reply ButtonReply

Dany

I liked my box, I received a lip liner and lipstick and thankfully they work for my skin tone. I put the bracelet (ugh, neon yellow) and wine tote (nice but I just won’t use it) up for swap. I think they did well considering it was the first box, I’ll give it three months total before a make up my mind.

Reply ButtonReply

lily

I got my box and I don’t like it. It seems like most people like this box. So maybe my tastes are just odd. The values are great, the curration is great. Yet I’m not thrilled with more makeup in colors I won’t be using, nail polish, a wine bag, I have no use for. A bracelet in a color I won’t wear. They did a great job for their first box. Yet I was not expecting 3 makeup related items ( I got: lip liner, nail polish, makeup remover ). I’ll might sign up again in the future, if I see less makeup. – I’ll be adding most the items I got up for swap. — Some of what I was hoping for: A french note pad, maybe a post card, a mini eifel tower sovenier or keychain, something different then what I got.

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle S

I don’t like the box either. I don’t think your tastes are odd.

Reply ButtonReply

Barbie

So on the fence about this box! For $14.00 I was very happy. I got the dark nail polish, a brown eye liner w/ smudger, orange snack, and blue bracelet. I’m going to find a way to re-purpose the bracelet. Maybe I will cut off the ends and paste the eifel towers to the top of a picture frame or something like that.

This reminded me very much of Glossybox.. just the french version of it. I had hoped for more touristy kind of things that you can only get in France but I will try one more month. For $24.00 I think I would have been disappointed in this box. I’m not even sure what to use the wine tote for either.

Reply ButtonReply

saffy

I really thought they did a great job for a first box. I hope they are able to acquire more brand partnerships for the future. Ditto everyone else on the fantastic packaging 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Amy B-B

Maybe the universe was trying to tell me something….my choices were almost the exact opposite of what I would have picked :(. My bracelet is hot pink, I don’t wear eyeliner and I hate banana flavored anything. I don’t use wrinkle cream. I won’t use the wine bag. I did get a very nice Sothys nailpolish in a deep red which I do like. This doesn’t mean this wasn’t a good bag (although what woman who uses wrinkle cream would want a hot pink bracelet!) just that the choices were not my taste. I’m going to give it one more month and see what a full priced box will hold.

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa Dion

Where do I need to go on their website to unsubscribe? I’ve been searching their site and am not seeing any sort of unsubscribe button (I’m on mobile). It was an okay box but didn’t seem to have anything all that unique. I was hoping for something more special, that I wouldn’t be able to get easily here.

Reply ButtonReply

tara B

You need to log in and then you can cancel. Took me a little bit to figure it out but you can do it. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Vanessa

Lovely box, just not for me. I put my entire box on the swap site, if anyone is interested. The only thing I didn’t include was the gummies (my four year old immediately ate them 🙂 He loves when I get treats in sub boxes.

Reply ButtonReply

Sue

I was so excited to get my subscription and I’d read about limited times to get a box so once I got on the site I hurried and bought one month. But alas….in my haste, I mistyped my address and now my box has been marked undeliverable-Return to sender.

So so sooooooooo sad.

Reply ButtonReply

Brandy

I got mine today too. Same as most everyone else. I absolutely love the packaging! The little Eiffel Tower lining inside the box is just too cute!

I did a monthly sub and used the coupon to get this first box for $14. For $24 a month, I hope they step up future months. This box was fine for $14, but if I had paid $24, I think I would have been disappointed. I’m going to give it a go for one more month to see how a full-priced box is though. This box has so much potential as there’s some great French items they could include. I almost want to keep it just for the packaging, but I suppose that would be kinda goofy! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

chris

“I almost want to keep it just for the packaging”. I hear you on that one, Brandy! It is beautiful. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Connie

I loved the packaging as it felt very special. Received the polish, eye pencil and lotion with a hot pink bracelet and banana for the treat. Had hoped for the lipstick as I do not use eye products but felt for the first box it was very nice and looking forward to next months. Appreciated the emails, tracking and priority shipping. Hoping going forward more unique french products.

Reply ButtonReply

anna

I am not on spam side yet… But if anybody would like to swap brown eyeliner for a black one or even for a blue bracelet, let me know! My mail is [email protected]

Reply ButtonReply

Vee

I just received mine. First, I love the packaging! I almost want to keep subbing just to get the packaging. I received the Caudalie Anti-Wrinkle Protect Fluid, Sothys Lip Gloss, Sothys Nail Polish in a bright pink (which I love), Blue Missiu bracelet, Wine Bag, and Orange Buddy Fruits. Overall, I think this box is worth it. I’m excited for next month!

Reply ButtonReply

Senny

OK…I love love love this box! I had terrible day…and was just feeling down and I opened it and saw the postcard and I swear I almost cried…pathetic but true! So I knew instantly I would love it! I got of course the cute wine tote (LOVE THIS) and my gummies are banana which I wanna hate but I’ll probably love. My bracelet was gold and its kinda cute! I got Sothys sun lip balm in the prettiest color and Sothys protective nail enamel! The Caudalie product I got was the Polyphenol C15 SPF20 anti-wrinkle protect fluid. I even love the little recipe card! I don’t know if all of these are my “favorite” products but I can’t bring myself to part with any of them because I just really liked this box! I didn’t need another box but I love it and this will be a keeper! Thank you so much for finding this box…it really made my day!

Reply ButtonReply

Senny

update…i was right i totally love the banana! it apparently did not take me long to bust into the gummies!

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

Haha – sounds like it was the perfect box for you then! 🙂

Nancy in TX

I’m very happy with the first French Box. My box was very similar to Liz’s. I received the Caudelie Makeup Remover Water which I’ve been wanting to try, the Sothys Lipstick in Rose Indien which is beautiful light pink color, perfect for my coloring. Also the Lip pencil in Nudite. My bracelet is in the Mandarin color. Not my first choice but I’m really starting to like it. I hope they seal the boxes better in future shipments.

Reply ButtonReply

eme

I was disappointed with my box. The packaging is really cute and I got eyeliner in smoky fort and Caudelie anti-wrinkle cream which I’m interested in trying. The rest is just kind of “meh”. The nail polish is the color of a shimmery band-aid and the bracelet is fluorescent orange — both which look totally yuck with my skin tone. The wine bag would be a great gift if it didn’t have the brand name on it, but as is feels like a giveaway. I got banana fruit snacks, which is my least favorite fruit.

The main thing is that overall, the box doesn’t feel authentically French to me. Having been to France many times, I was really excited about this box, hoping it would have distinct products and flavors of France. The items in my box are things I could find locally for the most part. I’m sure it’s difficult to launch a new box, and obviously a lot of detail went into the design, I just think I’ll stick with my PopSugar box and wait till my next visit to Paris to buy products.

Reply ButtonReply

Emily

I got everything you did and in the same colors, minus the nail polish, which I got in a dark brownish red. I love the eyeliner and will try the wrinkle cream, but the rest of my box left me feeling pretty ambivalent. I was in France last spring and was hoping for something that would take me back, but this sadly was not that for me.

Reply ButtonReply

eme

I agree with you completely on that “taking you back” feeling. I was hoping for that and felt exactly the same way when I saw what was inside. This box has great potential, but just didn’t hit the mark for me.

I would have loved to have seen a French postcard (there are so many great ones). Maybe a chocolate or pastilles or nougat (I don’t think macarons would hold up), or a perfume sample or French milled soap. Maybe this will come as they add more brands.

LizM

I got my box today!

I received the blue bracelet, brown eyeliner, beige shimmer polish, banana gummies, and the SPF anti-anging cream.

I just LOVE the packaging, especially the little Eiffel Towers printed on the box.

Reply ButtonReply

lisad

I really liked this box, I got a brown shimmer eye liner, raisin nail polish, the anti wrinkle, banana gummies and an orange bracelet. I think ill use the bracelet as a bookmark or see if one of my girls wants it. Beautiful box and presentation. I cant wait to see whats in store for next month.

Reply ButtonReply

Kat

I received my box today and I really like it! I got a brown eyeliner, the beige shimmery nail polish, the banana gummies, bright pink bracelet. I really like everything in one bag I’m not too crazy about the wine bag. And yes, the packaging is stunning!

Reply ButtonReply

jennyjenny

ok heres my box:

1. Got the bracelet in red(YAY)
2.Caudalie wrinkle cream
3.Fushia nail polish(beautiful color)
4. Sothys lipgloss in Parme-a pinky/mauvey gloss with shimmer(will probably swap since i don’t really wear gloss) but the formula isn’t sticky at all so I might try it!
5. Banana gummies(GROSS! would have liked any other flavor).

This is a great sub. I had to cancel for budget reasons before I received my first box. But this is the correct was that you start a subscription service. The packaging is great, the shipping was quick and the actual products feel very curated. On the user end, I didn’t feel any kinds or growing pains a lot of the other subs incur(lip monthly anyone?).

Reply ButtonReply

Gina G

Really happy with the first box and that I subbed for a whole year at the great promo price. I got the bracelet in black and Caudalie serum, which are what I would have chosen for myself – thrilled! Love the postcard, banana snack and wine tote as well. Only (very slight) disappointment is that my Sothys products were 2 nail polishes. Would have preferred to get one lipstick and/or the pretty lip pencil Liz got. Overall, huge win, though!

Reply ButtonReply