Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Just got my box and received the Amplilash serum – looks awesome.
However, the shadow stick ($19) was subbed with a Pure & Glam Spiced Amber lip liner pencil ($8.99). Not even in the same color as the lipgloss. :/
Reply
KarenG
Just got my box. It’s much much much better in person when you can really see the colors and read the insert on how to use the product. Coastal scents, I can do without but the serum, mascara, etc are pretty useful. I’m wondering why they thought coastal scents would be the hook with the spoilers. Even if they took that out, I wouldn’t miss it.
Still a win
Reply
Beckie
Not all that impressed with this box and will be putting everything up for swap.
Reply
Karen
How do you do that?
Reply
Brittany
Not really excited about the hair serum but the rest of the box looks awesome!!
Reply
Wendy
squee! I can’t wait to get this box!!!
Reply
Natasha
I’m happy with this box. Boxycharm continues to be my favorite sub.
Reply
Angela
So glad I canceled! Boxycharm hasn’t been really charming me much and I won’t even get in to the mess with Glossybox! Hate all the switch bait BS!
Reply
lala
I am not amazed by this month’s box at all. The previous two boxes where much better. I don’t really care about none of the items this month has!…… that moment when you wish you could skip a month but u can’t because you are on a 6 box subscription! ugh!
Reply
Amy
I’m excited!! Boxycharm never disappoints me. I feel so lucky to get all this for only $21.
Reply
Toni
Red,are we back to all red lip products there’s only a couple shades of red that I can wear, nothing with orange in it.I kind of wished I had cancelled I didn’t know I could cancel resub and on and on
Reply
Gaby
I just cancelled my subscription. I don’t like any of the products in this months bag. I loved the July bag, but this moth was such a disappointment. I cancelled today, I hope I don’t get charged since they moved their billing date to 8/2.
Reply
Annie
Happy I canceled. Not a fan of Coastal Scents chinese products, extreme cheap stuff We just got a gloss last month, and besides, it is a red color (that I do not use) this month. Have loads of sample mascaras, just waiting for me. Don’t need that shadow stick. Never heard of that brand serum, and a bit sceptical that someone would actually pay $72 for that serum, reading the ingredient list, don’t see any magical ingredient that I can not find at the drugstore for a whole lot less. But i will say last month’s Boxycharm was great! I am using the magnetic palette, which I was needing and wanting to buy anyway. The Ofra Shadows happen to be very nice and blended well, albeit they are a bit pricier than Mac Shadows. If they want to compete then they need to bring their prices down to Macs $6.00 .
Reply
Melissa
I’ll definitely pay the difference to avoid the animal testing.
Reply
lrgh
I love Boxycharm! but i’m so overwhelmed with product, took this month off…..looks like a nice box, but the only thing i feel i’m missing is the anti-age serum. Don’t care about blush, have enough mascara…..like trying shadows and lip stuff but don’t really need any more….soon, though!
Reply
Lara
I’m pretty excited about this because while there are a couple of things I could do without (like the coastal scents set, it just doesn’t look like that good of quality to me) but here is what makes me happy about those things I don’t want! I am going to save them for birthday gifts/Christmas gifts for the younger girls in my family!! I have a few that are just getting into high school that would love stuff like the blush/bronzer palette and so it’s not going to waste!
Reply
Sherry
Wow looks amazing
Reply
Elisa Conceicao
This is only my second box, loved last months box, but not at all excited for this one. The serum is actually the only thing I look forward to. I did a 3 month subscription, but going forward, I will subscribe month to month, so that I am able to skip boxes like this one.
Reply
Peaches
Glad I cancelled. The box has all the things we just recently got in recent boxes blush,brush, mascara and lipstick. Goodness we just got lipgloss and a brush in July. The only thing that looks great is the serum. The June box was fabulous. My September will be more eliciting
Reply
Yvette
This Box is Great!! I can’t wait to show it off! Another great hair product to help me repair my color damaged hair. I Love #Boxycharm
No complaints!??
Reply
MzBev
The serum is for your face/skin. Not hair. At least that’s how I read it…anti wrinkle serum.
Reply
Barbara
I hope the lipstick is Red instead of the same neutral colors i have too many of.. Getting loaded up on mascara also and I won’t use the palette.. Hoping the other items will be ok for me. I think I have 3 boxes, and theres too much repetition.. Fun but I need an organizer. lol.
Reply
Sarah
I’ve been wanting to try a matte lip product…but red? I can’t pull that off. The only thing I want here is the serum, so I want to cancel this month…but some of my ofra shadow in the last box arrived damaged and they said they would send a replacement in the next box…so now idk what to do. Agh
Reply
Tiffany
I’m in the same boat. My Ofra eyeshadow came broken, and they said they’d send a replacement in my next box, but I cancelled after I saw the coastal scents palette. I’m contacting them about sending the replacement on its own.
Reply
Stephanie
That’s an awesome box!!
Reply
Lauren
This box honestly just looks ehhh to me. I’m sure it’s nice, but am I really the only one not a fan of costal scents? The serum is the only thing I’m excited about, but hoping the red lI quid lipstick is good because I love red.
Reply
MzBev
i have 3 of the coastal scents palettes from Boxy. They are sure not all made equal. I liked 1 of them, really. We can hope this is one of their better items. I’m good with 3 of the items in this spoiler. The palette isn’t one of them.
Reply
Donna H.
Hard to see if they are backed with metal so that I can use with them with the magnetic palette from last month or if they are cheaper cardboard backed. Does anyone know? Hate it if they are the cheaper cardboard as it would be so much easier to deal with them separated on the palette.
Kayla
The revealed palette was my first palette ever, and I think they are okay. They are not amazing, but they aren’t horrible either. I’m excited for the face serum, the brush, the mascara, and the eyeshadow stick. I do love red lipsticks, but I don’t know if it contains any wheat, barley, or rye in it, and if it does then I can’t use it, but if it does not then I’m excited for it.
Reply
Cassie
I wonder if there will be different lipstick colors sent out or if everyone will get the same. It’s not the most exciting box, but I love blush palettes so I’m looking forward to that.
Reply
Tiffany
I clicked on the Repair Serum and it’s 72 dollars on the website and what we are getting in our boxes is the same size 1oz. So I don’t know why the price is listed wrong on the card but it is 72 dollars on their website!!! The mascara is listed as 23 dollars on their website not 22. So with that being said that Serum makes what we pay worth it. I’m excited. I love BoxyCharm. They are the best Beauty Box.
Reply
Donna H.
I know that I get different prices than they list when I search for “how to use” on the web as well. Never sure which is correct. Sometimes huge variations, sometimes just a few dollars off. Confusing not to know, but bottom line is whether I will like it/love it/use it, eh?
Reply
Linda
That’s the price for 2, bogo
Reply
Sabrina
Glad I canceled for this month!
The colors won’t work for me!
Still love boxycharm though!! ❤️
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.