POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Reveals + GIVEAWAY!

How long are these on sale for?

I got my extras today: Middle Kingdom plum vase, Lemon tea towel, and briogeo leave in conditioner. very happy with the extras- I had received 4 boxes of #7 and had given away several items before the offer to exchange boxes was extended. But based on the lack of variety in the boxes, I am happy I got the extras.

For those that mailed duplicate boxes back to be replaced, did you receive a shipping notice and tracking number for the new box(s)?

Did anyone hear that their extra gift has shipped? I’m just waiting and I was one of the earliest to contact them.

Maybe I just got someone that cares too much about their job, but I tried to drop my returning box off at a FedEx, and the woman refused to accept my shipment. She tried to charge me $5 for packaging, saying it “can’t slide around like that,” even though I’m returning the shipment exactly how it was shipped to me. So just FYI if you’re dropping off a returning box to FedEx, either add some packaging inside to keep everything from shifting inside, or just drop it at a dropbox where there’s no one around to talk back. Grr…. (Yeah like I’m going to pay $5 for FLUFF on a box I didn’t want in the first place.)

Would anyone like to swap for the earrings in #9? I have received a #8, and have three more to come next week. I also have other items listed in the swap area (I_like_big_swaps!).
Thanks! Rosemary.

Just received box #5. So happy I got the necklace and the lipstick charger! This is amazing value for only $25 and makes Christmas shopping much easier for me this year.

I had to comment that, while its super annoying to have gotten five of the same box, it’s very sweet to see all of these addicts coming together and working collectively to make each other happy! May you all find something you love through swap, lol.

Mine came today from Gilroy, 3.5lbs, 11 inch cubed and was box 1.

From all the posts, was not expecting this box so this process is totally random!

It seems I’m right there with you all in the duplicate situation… I wound up with FIVE of the unspoiled box ( spongology body wash buffer, chalkboard candle, gold cheers bottle opener, skinny scarf, swing design jewelry box in blue mist, sriracha pressels and powerGloss charger.) seeing as how I already owned all of these things I’m not so excited 🙁 A little nervous about the mystery item they’re sending out but also to send them all back only to wind up with four more of Marie kondos books… Sigh. If anyone is interested in a full box trade I’d be thrilled- I’d LOVE box 6 but also would be happy with 3, 7, or 9.

Well my boxes just arrived. I got two of the unspoiled boxes our of CA.

Swing design jewelry box
body wash infused body scrubber
Chalkboard candle
Power Gloss charger
Skinny Scarf
Sriracha Pressels

I got the jewelry box and Chalkboard candle last time around so I really don’t want those again. The charger is okay but not exciting. I don’t care for the smell of the body scrubber. I think I’ll list the stuff on the swap site and hope someone who got the heartbeat necklace something I got.

Sooo I got two different boxes (Gilroy), #2 and #3 and they arrived one day early (for those who are anxiously waiting). I’m okay with them – not super enthused but it could be worse. I’d be open to swapping something for those govino glasses … I was kinda hoping for those 🙂

I received two of box #6 lol I’m not too disappointed as I’m not a subscriber and the contents will make great stocking stuffers or gift basket fillers.

Did anyone get a 6.3 lb 13x13x13 cube from NY? If so, what did you get? Mine shows as delivered (I’m at work) but the weight and box dimensions have remained the same all through the shipping process.

I just received my 2 boxes. I ordered them about 5 days apart. They came from CA. They are both box # 9, the ones with the earrings. One said it was 1.7 lbs and the other one is 3.5 lbs. They are both identical in size and products. One had a protective cardboard over the pretzels and the other one didn’t. So one box weighs 29 oz and the other one was 31 oz. The dimensions are 4 x 8 x 11.5

I also ordered 2 and got 2 of the same box (8) that I also ordered several days apart.

Really wish that PopSugar would acknowledge that something went wrong at their warehouses (if that is what happend) – as it seems like the opposite of what they said has occurred (attempt to not duplicate). I know that there are a handful of posters that did not get duplicates, but really sees that the majority got duplicates. I almost would have more respect if they just acknowledged the error so that I had reassurance next time. Just my 2 cents

So I finally got my 2 boxes. I ordered them days apart from each other and ended up getting #6 (the box I wanted the least) and #8. #8 isn’t too bad, I’m happy with 4 of the 7 items. The one thing I really don’t like from #8 is the candle because I generally don’t use candles and that particular scent is not for me. If anyone wants it, I’m happy to give it away!

Ugh, two of the dreaded #6. I’ll have some up for swaps after I figure out what I can’t gift. I hope PS comes through with some kind of bonus gift!

Fedex must be delivering mine by covered wagon to Houston… has anyone received a 2.1 (11x7x4) from Watsonville, CA yet?

I ordered two boxes and both boxes were #8. Not thrilled I hate phone chargers! I got a bunch of free ones already laying around and two ugly white scarves that are flooding ebay. How many of you tat bought numerous boxes got al the same ones?

You would think that a mystery box wouldn’t have the same set variations instead it would just be employees throwing random things from certain categories to make sure theres always some variation even if there are repeats. Like a random cheap food item, something from the cosmetics, etc…

I’m glad it was only $27 each but there is not a thing I would buy.

I got 2 boxes, both box 5 if anyone wants to trade anything.

Ugh. I got 2 of box #10 – the worst of all of them. I highly doubt anyone is interested but – would love to swap a #3 for a #10. 🙂 Otherwise, I’ll email them and ask for a return label and see what happens when the replacement comes… I wonder if I could request a certain box? hmmmm

My two boxes won’t arrive until Saturday. Both listed as 3.5 lbs, 11x11x11 from Gilroy – which seems to mean they can be any box that doesn’t have the bingo game. :p boxes always take forever to get to me! Aaaagh. I’m in Portland and the shipping routes around here seem really inefficient. i.e. Package arrives in Corvallis, OR on Wednesday morning where it sits all day, then Thursday night it’s sent up to Kent, WA, and then it will be sent back down to Portland today. Dumb.

Box #2 just arrived from Gilroy and I’m actually pretty happy. All I really wanted were the post-it’s so this one works for me. I already have the book (it’s currently sitting on a stack on my bookshelf) but it can be gifted for Christmas. The hubby actually likes those GF treats so he’s happy. And I was wanting to try the blush. Overall this is a win!

I was emailed two prepaid shipping labels this afternoon. I’m shipping the duplicates back. They will send me two different ones when tracking kicks in.
My boxes came from ny but shipping to Gilroy.