Facebook PixelPOPSUGAR Must Have Box January 2017 Review + Coupon | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

POPSUGAR Must Have Box January 2017 Review + Coupon

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanMar 24, 2018 | 287 comments

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0001

POPSUGAR Must Have is a monthly lifestyle subscription box for women. Each month they send a mix of items from categories like beauty, fashion, food, fitness,

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0002

This box was sent to us for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0003

The Subscription Box: POPSUGAR Must Have

The Cost: 39.95 a month

The Products: “Must Have” items for women selected by POPSUGAR editors. (Fitness, Home, Beauty, Food, and more)

Check out all of my POPSUGAR Must Have reviews and the Women’s Subscription Box Directory!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0004

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0005

Each box comes with a fold out card detailing the items included, and what themes inspired the box.

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0006

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0007

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0008

Now, onto the items!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0033

Manduka eQua Mat Towel in Playa - Retail Value $38

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0034

This yoga towel has a soft, suede-like feel and it's very non-slip.

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0035

You can put it over your yoga mat for a sanitary and non-slip surface that is easy to wash. (Machine wash cold.)

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0036

I've been trying to up my workout game lately, and this is a useful addition to my accessories. I've been doing Tracey Anderson videos, and she does a lot of mat work, so this is great. (If you have any YouTube workout instructors you recommend for yoga, let me know!)

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0009

Daily Concepts Your Hair Wrap Towel - Retail Value $18

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0012

I love these hair wrap towels! I first tried one thanks to the Summer Box of Style, and they are great!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0011

To use it, you put it on your head, then wrap up the bottom part to hook onto the button at the top like this:

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0014

It's a soft and absorbent fabric (100% Polyester) that is designed to help your hair dry faster.

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0013

I also like these towels for keeping hair masks/treatments in place. I've slept with this towel on with mixed results, too. (Depending on how much you toss and turn, it may or may not stay on overnight!)

popsugar-spoiler-january-2017-0001

Goldfaden MD Fresh A Peel Multi Acid Resurfacing Peel - Retail Value $85

popsugar-spoiler-january-2017-0002

This was the spoiler item for the January box, and I was thrilled about it because I love the GOLDFADEN brand.

This peel is made with natural ingredients, including Lactic acid and Multi-Fruit Enzymes, designed to "provide exfoliation while reducing the appearance of fine lines, pores, and skin imperfections."

My favorite part of this peel is that you only have to wear it for 1-3 minutes - I love quick and easy beauty products - I'm much more likely to use them regularly!

This left my skin incredibly smooth, and it has a slight cooling effect which was refreshing. (One thing to note - I recommend patch testing this if you have sensitive skin. I have borderline sensitive skin, and I had no issues, but I always want to throw that out there!)

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0027

May Designs Desk Calendar & Notecard - Retail Value $25

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0026

Since POPSUGAR sent a planner in last year's January box, I had a feeling we wouldn't get a planner again, and this is a nice alternative!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0028

I love the ALL the prints in this calendar! Here are all the months:

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0029

And this calendar came with a coupon for 25% off your own custom design:

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0030-1

And on the flip side of every card is a note so you can cut the cards in half and reuse them:

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0031

I like that this is small and simple enough to add to my desk without feeling like I'm adding clutter, too:

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0039

Now, for more office/desk items!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0019

Sourcebooks Inc Instant Happy Notes - Retail Value $8.99

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0021

This is a collection of sticky notes with positive words of encouragement to share with coworkers/friends or yourself!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0022

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0038

This is the one item in the box that isn't a good fit for me, (maybe because I don't work in a traditional office), but I'm guessing these notes will be fun for most subscribers.

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0023

Dean & Deluca Peppermint Loose Leaf Tea - Value $10.75

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0037

I get excited about anything from Dean & Deluca, plus I drink about 8 cups of tea a day, so I was thrilled to see this tea tin in the box! Peppermint tea is my go-to evening tea drink when I want to avoid caffeine, and this is now part of my night-time routine.

And it is made from just 100% peppermint leaves!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0025-1

And this tea came with a coupon for 15% off any purchase from Dean and Deluca! (Expires February 28th 2017.)

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0015

Glade No 3 Coconut and Beach Woods Candle - Retail Value - $4.99

This item is the Special Extra bonus of the month. When I first saw this I was surprised that Glade was in this box! (Even my husband, Eric, saw the box and said, "Glade?")

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0017

This scent is beachy, with coconut as the most fragrant scent. And it's a soy candle!

popsugar-must-have-january-2017-0018

To be honest, if you removed the sticker (that doesn't say Glade on it), and told me this was a $20 name-brand soy candle, I would believe you. I'm pleasantly surprised by this item!

It casts a faint scent when not lit, and the simple glass vessel design should work with any decor. (And we're dealing with COLD weather today, so the beachy scent is nice and aspirational!)

Verdict: This box has a retail value of about $191! I think that's amazing for a $39.95 box, and I think POPSUGAR did a great job for January. You have the calendar for starting off the year, a useful fitness item for any New Year's resolutions, and the other items are useful, too. Plus that peel alone is worth more than double the cost of the box and is seriously amazing!

What do you think of the January POPSUGAR Must Have Box?

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

287 comments

Rosemary

I officially love everything in this box. I’m not allowed to consume peppermint, so I swapped the tea (it smelled heavenly). I am surprised by how good the hair turban is.

Reply ButtonReply

Elle

I caved and bought it at the 40% off price. PSMH had some sort of billing glitch in January, I think, for so many boxes to be left over. They contacted me 3 times about ” updating my billing” and my billing was correct the entire time and the funds were available.

After being a member since 2013, maybe 2012, they cancelled my subscription and I had to re-subscribe. They say I will get MARCH’S box but after asking 3 times to please start with the Feb. box.. crickets.
I’m hurt. My subscription number was less than #550 which means- I was a long time subscriber with a lot of loyalty and money spent with the company.

I’ll use the towel to dry off my two puppies when it rains and they have to go outdoors, maybe the facial peel but I have sensitive skin, and maybe the peppermint tea if I have some chocolate. I like the two together.

I am an older woman and this is an extremely boring box for me, too. I saw where people have said it’s for older aged people. Well, not always. 🙂

I’m going to Godiva.com now and buy myself a great box of chocolates to try to get over the hurt and indifference PSMH showed to my request the middle of January to start a new subscription with February instead of March.
What do they have planned for February?? I definitely should have gotten a Feb. box start date, as they cancelled and told me to resub in less than 15 days total.

Has anyone else had problems with their customer service not being especially responsive and personalized lately? I never have complained about anything regarding PSMH before now but I’m really hurt.
I LOVE Feb. subscription boxes and I dropped all other boxes for a while to make a major travel splurge. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Liz

Disappointed in this box. Based on the previous boxes, I thought it would make a good gift for my 15 year old niece, but it’s more geared toward a middle-aged woman than any of the previous boxes. Hope her mom likes this stuff, cause I have a feeling that’s where it’s going.

Reply ButtonReply

cheryl

I just bought this box with the 40% off deal. The peel I need so wow, really $85! I need a new hair towel. Will use the yoga matt. The calendar I will most likely regift as well as they stick notes (send to my sister who has young kids and is a teacher). I need a new candle. I love PS not for ME but I I break up the box and put items in my “gift” closet so I have something for to grab and give if I need a gift. For the price you can’t beat it. I just can’t do the monthly, so I’m so happy when they run these sales.

Reply ButtonReply

Linda

Has anyone been swept away by the face peel? I got a january box sent to my home in NY but im in texas so i havent had a chance to use anything and now that they are on sale im thinking about snatching up a new one to get sent to texas, but since i dont NEED duplicates of anything, it would only be “worth it” to me if the “consumables” are worth restocking… rsv of the face peel is 85….anyone think its better than say a $20 scrub from marshalls or sephora? I have stubborn combination skin with occasional breakouts, i wouldnt say my skin is sensitive, but i do have some patchyness that i think this might help with…as well as minimizing pores….??? Anyone feel this helped improve their complexion? Thanks!

Reply ButtonReply

Shannon

Loved this box! Now bring on the February spoilers!!!!

Signed: High Expectations

Reply ButtonReply

Jeannie Johnson

Are the boxes still being sent? I haven’t gotten mine yet.

Reply ButtonReply

nana

Just got mine today, though it was scheduled to be delivered tomorrow.

I was happiest about the tea – which is really just fried peppermint leaves. I added some to black tea and brewed it in my Keurig. very nice.

Reply ButtonReply

Crick

For all of you that were having trouble with hair towel like me
I went to their website and got instructions with pictures

P.S. the button goes on back of head not front

http://dailyconcepts.com/shop/your-hair-towel-wrap/

Reply ButtonReply

Heather

Thank you! I have been struggling every day with that thing.

Reply ButtonReply

Crick

lol you’re very welcome 😊

Now onto trying to figure out how to use tea leaves without a diffuser

Would’ve been cool if they included one !

Crick

Am I the only one who can’t figure out the hair towel ??
I hate to sound stupid but I tried it both ways ( the button upfront and in back ) but it just doesn’t work out it feels super awkward , maybe it’s because of my long hair , wish it came with pictures for people like me lol 🤣

Reply ButtonReply

LeanGreenBean

My hair is long enough to sit on, and when I use these types of hair towels (I already have two, but am always happy to have more!) I actually fold my hair in half (just hold it at the tips, and pull it up to the crown with one hand before wrapping the towel with the other hand) so it all fits in the towel before I twist it up. This kind of towel has become indispensable to me, since my hair takes so long to dry on its own. I hope you love it once you get the hang of it!

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle

Is anyone else having trouble putting the head towel on? I can’t seem to get it. Does your hair have to be wet? I can’t get it to stay on …I have a small head too!

Reply ButtonReply

Crick

Yes I was too , go to their website it shows pictures

Your supposed to put the button on back of neck then twist it up and button
I was doing it wrong

But it’s still a challenge because of my long hair lol

Reply ButtonReply

Amy S

Mine just arrived. I can’t believe anybody doesn’t love this box. I think it may be my favorite subscription box of any kind, ever.

Reply ButtonReply

Darcie

I love PopSugar also. I got my box for $20 because of the BF deal. I don’t do yoga and I’m not an exercise person. But PS consistently sends out nice boxes that exceed the amount paid, even if you are paying $40. I have had excellent results selling my items on eBay if there are items in the box that I will never use. When this happens, I end up getting the items I choose to keep for FREE. I have zero complaints.

Reply ButtonReply

Wincha

Maybe Popsugar isn’t my thing. This box is meh for me. I have a thicker yoga mat since my yoga is mostly on the floor and i like cushion under my knees. I have a similar face peel if not the same one from Rachael Zoe last month. The calendar and stickies…..not worth the price and useless for me. Dont’ care for peppermint or tea. A glade candle? seriously? the hair thing might be interesting but i have short hair and am trying to figure out how to keep it on me. I’m glad I only paid $20 for this. Maybe people will want to swap. There is not one thing I love.

Reply ButtonReply

Samantha

I wouldn’t normally pay money for a Glade candle, but this one is surprisingly nice. It has a soft, fresh scent and it’s worth trying.

Reply ButtonReply

Chelsea Small

Any one actually get a stand for the notecards? I didn’t….not sure if it was a mistake or if we have to get our own or something weird like that…..???

Reply ButtonReply

Zo

The stand is clear and lightweight (and flat). I thought I didn’t get mine either but it was hiding in the tissue paper.

Reply ButtonReply

Amie

I got a stand. I would email customer service and have them send one.

Reply ButtonReply

elle

Has anyone had any issues with the hair wrap. there just does not seem to be enough fabric to twist it. seems too skimpy or something for a big twist. has anyone found the same. Any tips?

Reply ButtonReply

Samantha

I’m not sure if anyone posted the ingredients to the candle yet (so many comments on this post!), so here’s what’s on the box:

Ingredients: Wax, fragrance, stabilizer, SCJ Formula
#35*30866 This candle is a blend of soy and paraffin waxes.

Above that, it says “Lead-free wick.”

Hope that helps! I don’t know what those numbers mean. Also, I never got a shipping confirmation and my box showed up today.

Reply ButtonReply

Jen

Did anyone see the e-mail PS just sent out with the hint for January? At the bottom corner, there is a cute bouquet of flowers and a perfume roll-on/mini. I’m confused or maybe it’s a clue for February? Help. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Celi

Does anyone know if there will be a Popsugar February box? I thought this was a monthly subscription. Feeling sad…my birthday is in February and was hoping to get a box.

Also, anyone want to sell their face peel? Mine had a leak and spilled its contents all over. 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

Alicia

Celi, email customer service for a replacement.

Reply ButtonReply

Samantha

Are you on the swap site? I have my peel up for swap. I’ve gotten a couple of requests, but still waiting to see something that catches my eye! You can click my name to get to my swap page.

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

Yes, there will be a February box! Right now if you sign up for a new subscription, your first box will be March since they have sold out of February box inventory, but if you already are a subscriber, you will receive the February box. Hope that helps!

Also, I recommend messaging POPSUGAR customer care to let them know about the face peel. They should take care of it for you!

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa

As much as the subscription cost I hold it to a higher standing. The boxes I hv received hv been duds. I can’t afford to waste my money on something that strikes out as much as they hv.

Reply ButtonReply

Stephanie

Does anyone know when they usually ship? My status has been “processing” for awhile. Wondering how long it takes before it actually gets sent. I had a 6 month membership then upgraded during their Black Friday promotion (I think?? Or maybe Cyber Monday?) Thanks!

Reply ButtonReply

Zo

Mine shipped on 1/6 from NY. FedEx tracking has it arriving on 1/17. I only live 2 states away. I purchased my sub on Black Friday as well.

Reply ButtonReply

faith

hmmm, this box is a total miss for me. I have like three yoga towels, I can’t think of any time I will ever need or want to use the prewritten post its. a total waste for me.

Reply ButtonReply

Mary Beth

I just use my yoga towel as a bath towel. It’s super absorbent.

Reply ButtonReply

Christal

I think this is going to be my FAVORITE box thus far!!! And I’ve been a subscriber for over a year. So excited!!!!! #UpMyAlley

Reply ButtonReply

Sam

My box arrived so nice an early this month … what a nice little pick me up after the cold snowy New York weather. I was actually going to buy this yoga mat towel because I saw someone at my gym using one and I thought it was a great idea considering I usually scrub my mat down with those antibacterial wipes at the gym and who knows how great they even work ..
Anyway the mat is worth the price of the whole box for me. Plus it would be great for hiking and the beach.
I love the pretty desk calendar… maybe it will inspire me to keep my desk neat.
The peel seems great.. I want to do a at home spa day Andrade this will def be used … I dont do peels often but it’s nice to have a nice quality one at my disposal:-)
The tea is a nice little addition and the glade candle is amazing !!!!! I love soy and I love coconut so it’s a total win. It makes me forget it’s 15 degrees today and tricks me into thinking I’m in Mexico On vacay… love this

Reply ButtonReply

J

Just went to sign up for the POPSUGAR subscription but saw that the next box I’ll be able to receive is not until March. I understand January being sold out, but February too? Does anyone know why this might be?

Reply ButtonReply

Leia

I would imagine it is due to all the Black Friday subs. They most likely begin sourcing the items months in advance.

Reply ButtonReply

Lucy

I’m a little disappointed. I gave this as a gift, and the first box was December, which was awesome. Compared to that, this one is not so great. But the fun is in getting it, right?

Reply ButtonReply

Kathleen

So I got the Rue La La box voucher = one-month subscription. The email said I could redeem the Rue La La box through March 10 when I sign up for my subscription. I decided I’d hold off to see if I like the Feb box better for my one-month subscription but now I see the next box to ship is March? Should I sign up for March now so I can be sure I get my Rue La La box? Why wouldn’t I be able to sign up for Feb?

Reply ButtonReply