Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more. (And sign up asap if you want November's box - there's a waitlist!)
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I love boxycharm. I have loved every single item I have received. I love this blog, makes me look forward to my box even more.
Reply
Keri
Loving my box this month!
Reply
Julie
Has anyone seen the MADNESS going on about the LE box?? Wow! I knew it would be in high demand,nothing like this?! I ordered 1 right before they sold out..
Reply
Amy
I thankfully picked up a LE box right before it sold out. I had to wait patiently for over 30 minutes on my one box since the site was so slow. Once I told some of my friends about it, they were shocked since they hadn’t heard about it and were going to get in on the restock. So its going to be very popular and I imagine the restock will sell out fast too..I had no idea though it was going to be crazy. Now I want to see some sneak peaks!!
Reply
Jessica
Do you know when the restock will be??
Virginia
I know! It was sold before I even got my email. Hope they do another one soon! I’d love a holiday/Christmas themed one. 🙂
Reply
Rita Hughett
I never got any type of notification about the LE so when I discovered it by accident they were sold out. I am so mad!
Jessica
I’m so sad that I didn’t get it in time!!!! 🙁
I got the deep wine color of lippie in this boxycharm. I like everything I got. One of my brushes was shedding horribly though.
Reply
Sue Basile
My daughter also got the dark wine lippie in her box, I received the lighter color one that was pictured. Love Boxycharm …..IMO, best monthly beauty box for the money. We also get Ipsy, BB, Sephora Play, and Allure. Birchbox has been really skimpy lately, at least mine has been. But hey, it’s 10 bucks 😎
Julie
Has
Has anyone seen the MADNESS going on about the LE box?? Wow! I knew it would be in high demand,nothing like this?! I ordered 1 right before they sold out..
Reply
Julie
Not sure why that posted twice..oops?
Reply
ReviewStuffz
So have there not actually been any other variants?
Reply
IV
I just saw a post of this on ig and the laqa lipstick looked like a nude color, maybe one of those variations.
Reply
IV
Ohh just found out the lipstick deep wine
Reply
IV
*is deep wine.
Tanya
I got some nerve being super anxious for the shipping notice so I can get a sneak peek at that limited edition box…. not too mention I want to get my paws on that palette. I left my Pur palette at my sisters in Ohio and now she’s begging to keep it…. I am so geeked for this box… I feel pretty !!!!
Reply
Brooke
CRIES because I want to get this subscription box so bad but can’t ever get one until they start shipping to AUSTRALIA 🙁
Reply
Sheila C
I have a question: I am not a subscriber to this box…yet. But I’ve been thinking about it ever since I saw the November spoilers. I see there’s a wait list, so if I subscribe this month, but I’m put on the waiting list, will I still get NOVEMBER’S box when I am taken off the wait list??? Does anyone know???
Thanks!
Reply
Darlene
Probably not. I was on the waitlist for 2 months until I got off. You receive the box from the month they charge your card.
Reply
Jazmin
You’ll most likely be take off at the begining of next month and recieve the december box. Thats what happened to me when i subscribed in october
Reply
dakota
ive been on a wait list since october, i just got off the wait list and im getting the november box.
Reply
em
How early in october did you sign up? I signed up mid-october because of the spoilers for this box and really hope to get it.
thanks!
Arlana
U will be on the waitlist, basically whenever they get to u they would bill ur card, probably not til Dec or jan
Reply
Taylor
If you can get off the waitlist sometime in November, then yes. But if they take you off in say, December or even January, then no, you’ll get the box for whatever month you become a full fledged subscriber.
Reply
Zsuzsana
Only if you get charged in November will you get the November box
Reply
Kayla
This is box number 973
Reply
Kayla
Wrong page for this post – lol sorry
Reply
Brit
I signed up REALLY hoping to get this box, but from everything I’m reading it looks like I’ll be stuck on the waitlist a while. Ugh so disappointed
Reply
Mindy klein
Most of the time you are on the waitlist but I was too in the beginning and then ended up with the same months box I signed up with. So don’t loose hope. Each month is just as amazing!
Reply
Jessica
I was on the waitlist for 2 full months. JUST got off 😀
Ashley
So sign up for three, six, or twelve months! I signed up for twelve and I’m definitely stoked that I did. It’s so friggin worth it!
Reply
tracy
Whats a lip mask ? I love the 1st 3 but I am not sure I would like the Variants . Shall wait and see !
Reply
Marion
I love the LAQA & Co lip lube! I’ll be looking to swap for the Cloud Lips!
Reply
Ginger
Looks good to me! I don’t bother with lip masks, so I will give them to my daughter if I get them. I also checked the four colors for the lipstick, and I would be happy with two of the four. I might even be okay with the darkest if I can find a way to tame it with something else in my collection, but the pink would be way too childlike on me. I’m hoping for the mauve-nude or the red. I’d enjoy the red a lot.
Reply
Traci
For the lipstick, I’d prefer either the lightest or the darkest shade. But I’ll probably get red…. again. 😑
Overall, not a bad box. Never get tired of brushes, lippies, and palettes, but it’s fun to get something new from time to time, too. 😉
Reply
Geena
I would actually be totally happy with this variation! Like, whole box happy – and there’s almost ALWAYS something I’m swapping out of my box. FINALLY a lipstick that isn’t a liquid – so much easier to touch up.
Reply
heather
ok, so this month, there will be 4 items total? eye palette, setting spray, brushes, and either a lippie or lip mask? boxycharm always releases all the items in the box each month, so this is the whole box, right?
Reply
Katie
The 5th product is the tarte mascara. If you look at the previous spoiler it has a picture of the mascara. 😊
Reply
Melissa
I was looking forward to the mascara. 😞
Katie
Nevermind… I went back to check and I misunderstood when I previously read the 4th spoiler… I guess the tarte mascara was a guess and not yet a confirmed product for Novembers box. Hopefully the mascara will be in December’s box??! 😕
Jackie
Pretty sure we get the lip mask and the lipstick. But there are variants of those 2 items but we will get 5 products.
Reply
Bonnie
Even though red is by far my least favorite lip color, this box once again delivers. I will of course try, and probably hate, the red, but sometimes these things surprise me and I get a good one. Or maybe I’ll get a better shade, but ’tis the season for red lippies – I’m sure we’ll all get a ton of them if we have multiple beauty subs. This will be my 16th Boxy and only once was I disappointed in the box. A lipstick/gloss just makes the box more fun, and I think there was one month where we didn’t have one.
Reply
Brittany
So I have only had Boxy for three months (this being my third month) and I am kind of confused by the the variants for November. Does this mean we will only have 4 items and we will get the lip masks OR the lippie and liner set? Please someone help lol Not complaining if it’s only 4 items, just want to make sure I understand.
Reply
Michelle
Love Boxycharm and will never ever let this sub go but I can’t pull that lippie color off so I hope I get a different one but will definitely be swapping the spray.
Reply
Jackie
Loving these spoilers! Cant wait to get my box!! I’ve been with boxy for over a year and I’ve never been disappointed.
Reply
justmissjamey
Sure hope get the red lip colo..love, love, love red lipsticks, but never seem to luck out and get them. Haha
Reply
tanya.jones43
I got the red but ordered the storm online ….
Reply
Ashley
Do they ever take people off of the wait list in the middle of the month or is it normally just the first of the month? I’ve been on the list since Oct 12th. Just wondering if I still have a chance to get taken off this month.
Reply
Dylan
I got taken off on the 26th of September, and got my September box. So yes it does happen. I missed the August box only.
Reply
Allison
When I was on the wait list I got off in a month. I signed up the beginning of September and received an email on October 1st saying I was off the wait list and would be getting October’s box. From what I’ve seen people generally get off the wait list the month after they sign up.
Reply
Storm
That’s strange, I signed up the 3rd of September and was automatically charged for a box
Susan
There is more info about the waitlist in another post here from yesterday. It references a Facebook post from the CEO of Boxy Charm addressing the wait list. It was posted yesterday morning.
Reply
Hildol
Not sure actually. I’ve been on it well over a month. I’m frustrated only because my credit card was lost and I updated it online and THEN sent an email alerting them. Somehow, in their email response, that was the day they attempted to charge…my old card, not the new updated card that I alerted them to, so it RESTARTED my wait time on the wait list which I do not feel is awesome.
Reply
JuJu
Not bad! The setting spray is the only thing in this box I won’t use.
Reply
bmcd3713
While I generally adore Boxycharm this month is split and I suppose the final judgement will come when I finally get the variants in my box. BTW, I hate the idea of “variants”…
Reply
Julie
If I’m right variants is what makes such a large selection of makeup every month possible. Few companies can afford to practically give away if not actually do so that large amount of product so variants might be where they make up the difference. The post from the owner of boxycharm did try to explain that it takes almost 6 months per product negotiations and such and that’s also a really great reason for the waitlist to make sure everyone gets something vs certain other boxes that will throw in leftovers from previous seasons. I generally don’t like variants but in this box they tend to be pretty great no matter what you get.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.