Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Birchbox sample/box selection opens on the 27th (you'll receive an email from Birchbox with your unique link). But Birchbox Aces will receive their email on the 26th. Also - if you share your box page by the 25th, you'll also get early access to the sample choice.
What are you picking this month? There are so many great options! I know I must have that tote - it will the first time I try a Birchbox Plus add-on!
FYI - if you haven't signed up for Birchbox yet, use coupon code GAP10 to get $10 (100 points) to spend in the Birchbox shop!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
If anyone bought that tote and wants to swap it or sale it plz let me know!! Thanks
Reply
chellersm
Hi, I would sell or trade! I just got mine yesterday, and although it’s really pretty in person, I realized that I absolutely don’t need another canvas tote. I’d sell it for what I paid, plus shipping, or would swap for something. I hadn’t put it on the swap site yet because I wasn’t sure if I was supposed to as I bought it rather than it being part of the box? Anyway, my email is mtyler @ alumni dot nd dot edu
Thanks!
Reply
Blessedmommi
Hi Chellersm!
I tried to email you but the email came back as delivery failure for invalid email.
Can you email me. Blessedmommi at hotmail.
Thanks
Yogamom67
Did anyone who signed up for the subscription upgrade receive an email from Birchbox with the opportunity to purchase either of the Rifle Paper Company Add-On items? I know I didn’t and I definitely was considering adding on one or both of them. I just clicked the link from MSA site and they are both sold out, of course.
So far, this feels like more of a subscription downgrade than anything else. Hopefully, this is going to be one amazing box, but $20 more for just 2 full size products – I’m not sure what I was thinking! I’ve been wrong before, though, and so far I’ve gotten excellent customer service from Birchbox, so I guess I’ll just have to be patient and hope for the best.
Reply
Emily Alvarez
I just went to select my sample, and this message is at the bottom of the page.
“If you’re testing out our latest subscription upgrade that includes our two full-size makeup or luxury nail add-ons, unfortunately we are unable to honor guest editor box selections; however, you are still eligible to choose a sample!”
I’m so upset! I wanted a mad men box sooo bad! =( I feel like they’re punishing me for buying more stuff from them.
Reply
Yogamom67
Ditto!
Reply
Kate
I got my email! NY box!
Reply
Tara
anyone get their email yet ? its almost noon on east coast and nothing yet for me. i shared my box so i should be getting it today. i havent received the email for months and have contacted customer service all to never get my selection. last month i got an email from customer service stating that due to all my issues i would get the email early. we shall see !
Reply
Lauren
If you can message them through their Facebook page, tell them what sample pick or box you want and they will sign you up for it quickly. I didn’t get an email but got a response from my Facebook message in 30 min.
Reply
Lori
I just called BB and they said there was a glitch with the email going out this morning but they expect it to go out within in the hour.
Reply
Ashley
I just got mine!
Mary
I am so excited about this month! I bought an extra box so I can get a Madmen box and the regular box. I love the Rifle paper designs!
Reply
PA Anna
I decided to order the tote which I did yesterday when they were still available. I’m going to select the Jane Iredale item.
Reply
Sonnie
I think I’m going to go for : Jane Iredale Just Kissed Lip & Cheek Stain ! This lips stick seems amazing ! I love the fact that it look natural ! And the ingredients seems great ! The curated boxes are not for me this month ! Well, the March curated box was so great that now I’m difficult 😉
Reply
Sarah
So after having issues with their site all day, I finally am able to view the Plus options, they are all sold out! I am so pissed! Not exactly sure what the point of being an Ace is if they give the option to reserve BEFORE Aces. Although, their new presence in CA may explain part of the glitches their site seems to be having. Although I am bummed that I am going to be charged sales tax, I am hopeful that their presence in CA may result in quicker turnaround time to receive my monthly box.
Reply
Denise
Birchbox bummer, Just got this email
I’m Emily, the Director of Customer Operations at Birchbox, and I wanted to share an update regarding your account.
Due to our new business operations in California state, we are required to charge a sales tax for your Birchboxes and full-sized orders shipped to California, effective April 1, 2015.
I hope this helps clarify the difference you may notice in any upcoming charge.
Thank you for your business!
Reply
Adeline
I live in Washington and have been charged sales tax for at least half a year now. I get my boxes 2 weeks after Liz.
Reply
Adele
Birchbox just sent me an email that said due to new business operations in California they are required to charge a sales tax for my Birchboxes and full sized orders shipped to California effective April 1, 2015.
Reply
Cassie
I just got that too – does that mean they’re opening up a store/office in California? Because I would be so excited for that!
Reply
SARAH
I have a feeling it’s just a shipping facility, as any sort of presence in the state requires they charge sales tax, but I could be wrong. Either way, I am hoping it results in quicker turnaround times for those on the left coast and makes it worth the sales tax.
Beth
Does anyone know what the Cynthia Rowley illuminator is? I can’t seem to find it on the Birchbox page, and it may help me to decide which Mad Men box to choose.
Reply
Liz Cadman
From what I can tell it hasn’t been released yet – and I believe the line is exclusive to Birchbox so I couldn’t find it anywhere else.
Reply
Sarah
So after finally receiving my e-mail, I tried to reserve the items and it says there are “No Items Available.” >:(
Reply
Charell
Which item did you try to reserve? When I click through my email it certainly looks like both are still available–unless it only says not available after you click on the ‘reserve now’ button…
Reply
Sarah
All are now sold out. You have to click them to see their unavailability.
Lauren M
How long does it usually take to receive your email to pick after you share your box on Facebook?
Reply
Kate
It sounds to me like there are two categories of people:
Aces, people that shared on FB or Twitter – will get the selection email on 3/26
OR
Everyone else – will get the selection email on 3/27
Reply
Lauren
Thanks !! That helps me out a ton!
Kate
Okay, I’m new to the add-ons (and I already impulsively reserved the tote), but I’m not sure I get it. When it says “Value = $35,” what is it talking about when it’s being sold in the store for $28 – the same price it costs to add on??
Is the only difference that you can’t use points to buy the add-ons? I’m not sure I get the benefit to members to adding items on.
Reply
CJ
From my understanding: You get points for buying add ons but the way the reservation process is set up, you can’t use points to buy add ons. I think the main benefits are that you get first dibs on an item (which in this case is probably good because the bag will likely sell out quickly) and you get the add on at a price that’s a little less than if you were to go somewhere else and buy it at the full retail value.
Reply
Tara
love the MM-NY. im going to try for that. hope i like the blush color. i was able to share via twitter. clicked on this months box and there was a tiny facebook and twitter box under. lets see if i get the email cuz in the past 4 months i’ve never once gotten my choice.
Reply
Faye
I want 3 items out of each of the mad men boxes. Wish I had 2 accounts but I guess I’ll have to choose one and swap for the other items I want to try right? I do tend to like the curated boxes better. When I was just picking 1 sample I kept getting eyeliner every month.
Reply
Sarah
I just shared it this morning because when I first read this post last night, the box tab wasn’t there. I am an Ace but it seems like many have already reserved, so I am hoping I still get my e-mail today to get to make a selection. What is the point of being an Ace if I can’t reserve early? Did anyone else share today (the 25th) and get an e-mail?
Reply
Ashley
I think what people are reserving are the Birchbox Plus items. I don’t believe anyone, even Aces, has received the Sample Choice selection email yet. I think the early access emails will go out tomorrow.
Reply
Whitney // Beauty With Whitney
I’m definitely going to go for the New York box! Excited about the Cargo blush and the Anastasia!
Reply
Charell
I can’t decide! I wish I could get the Mad Men NY items in that adorable Rifle box. Oh well, I suppose that they might be out of the items I want by the time I get to pick–at least that would make the choice easier? Right?
Reply
Chillybeans
Me too , love the rifle paper box but am pining for a curated box…..
Reply
Mary
Haha, I could have written that. My thoughts–and thought process–exactly.
Reply
Katherine
Where do I go to reserve the Rifle add-on? I don’t see that option.
Reply
CJ
If you click the link underneath the bag or the tumbler set, it will take you to the corresponding page for that item to reserve it.
Reply
Laurie
This was the push I needed to get a second subscription (this, plus the 100 extra points) – I wanted to get one of the Mad Med boxes, but I just had to have that gorgeous Riffle box as well. And I reserved the tote, even though I need another tote bag like I need a hole in the head. I rationalized that I might give it to my mother for her birthday…notice the term “might” there! :p
Reply
Kate
Random question – I’m hoping to get the NY box, which has the Whish shave cream. I also got a sample of that (and reviewed it) in March 2013. Will I be able to review it again?
Reply
TryStuff
I’ve gotten the same sample before too, because one was in a regular box and one in a curated box, and for the second one I wasn’t able to review it again. 🙁 On the page it said already reviewed.
Reply
Kate
Bummer. Oh well – still want that NY box! At least I won’t be the only one…haven’t we ALL gotten that blueberry shave cream by now?
Megan
Has anyone been able to share their page?? This is so frustrating!
Reply
Twommy
it didn’t work on the phone – get on a computer and you should be able to do it- I tried on my phone and saw no option but when you click on my box there is a twitter and facebook link right on that page so you can click and share. GL
Reply
JoyW
All the boxes and Rifle Plus items are GORGEOUS! Glad Sneaky Burrito (Ragan) talked me into two accounts (hee hee)! Best month!!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.