Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
And now it is giveaway time! We're going to put a lot of these items together for a SuperPOPSUGAR Must Have Box Mystery Box!
Enter the giveaway below and good luck! (Winner will be contacted by email – make sure to enter with an email account you check frequently).
If you do the refer-a-friend entry option in this giveaway, you’ll get the entries for that once the friend has entered the giveaway. Giveaway is open only to US residents 18 and over.
POPSUGAR Must Have is a quartely lifestyle subscription box curated by the editors at POPSUGAR. Each box features their "must have" products for beauty, fashion, home, food, fitness and more. Every box has a value of $250 +!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I have the Briogeo hair mask that I would be willing to swap for most anything if anyone is interested.
Reply
Jessica
I received 3 #4 boxes and a #2 box so I returned 2 of the #4s and they sent me another 2 #4 boxes!! So frustrating. They are now out of stock, so they are sending me additional items I guess.
Anyone want to swap for my #4 or #2 boxes?
Reply
Rosemary
Does anyone have a box #9 that they would like to swap for a box #8?
Reply
Colleen
Just got my replacement box – number 8 – I was hoping for the box that wasn’t pictured. The one with the jewelry box. Anyone have the Capri blue rectangular candle with wood lid and wants to swap for this holiday candle? I got ‘Cinnamon beignet’.
I’m happy to swap this entire box if someone wants it. I’d love things from the November Popsugar box – the table runner and bowl. Open to lots of things really.
I haven’t seen my reply post yet, trying this again. I would love to swap!!! I just got this box today so haven’t listed yet either. Here’s my profile link, I couldn’t get to you with you with yours, says I’m not authorized to view it. ?
Colleen
Yay! Yes, lets swap! I’m on the swaps but haven’t listed this box as it just arrived today. I was hoping I would find someone like you!
I’ll have 2 Cargo blushes in case that’s something you use. Thanks again, I can’t wait!
I have two extra boxes #6… I returned my duplicates and they returned to me the exact same boxes… So pissed at psmh customer service… If somebody wants to swap with me I’ll be so happy … You can contact me at sophie.valenciana at gmail 🙂
Reply
Jessica Ferrell
I have 3 #4 boxes and a #2 box if you or anyone wants to swap. 🙂
Reply
Rebecca J
Hi Jessica! I have box #7, would you be interested in swapping for your #4? I’m at beccajrichardson at gmail. ?
Zo
they did the same to me. I could only laugh.
Reply
Sophie
And they are laughing of us for sure 😛 I sent an email and they said I will get some extra items, you should do the same
Diane
I have extras of box 8. Let me know if you want to swap.
Reply
Sophie
Hi Diane:
Yes, definitely we can do it. Email me so we arrange the details and swap the boxes 🙂
NJS
I just received Box #1 from Gilroy. Glad I got the scarf – it’s super cute – not thrilled with anything else – would have like Govino or charger. There was some huge delay and it magically shipped after I asked f it was too late to cancel. It came really quick after that, LOL. Actually, I’ve been reading the minimalism blogs, and that combined with this latest waste of space and money, I think I am finally over the FOMO. Thank you Popsugar! Not only will I not resubscribe to you – but I’ll probably be immune to the others
Reply
Adeline
I have an extra box #9, will swap for a November box…. email me at chewsulin at Gmail if interested
Reply
Diane Rogala
Yes, I got the post it’s. I am not on swaps, but I would trade something.
Reply
jenn
I got my “bonus” item today – full size Briogeo Rosarco Milk™ Reparative Leave-In Conditioning Spray. I was just glad it wasn’t a tea towel!
Reply
Rosemary
I receive three “extra” items…none of which I would ever use. To add insult to injury, the body scrub leaked all over the contents of the box, and now I can’t even gift this stuff.
Waiting to hear from customer service.
All I wanted was a pair of earrings…no, I got sent totally useless stuff. I won’t be wasting my money on this mystery box again. I am upset with PopSugar, and will not be renewing my sub. They have lost my trust.
Reply
Teresa
My body scrub was open and they sent me a replacement item. Unfortunately it was Victoria secret body lotion. I’m also unhappy with them and will not buy from them again.
Reply
Kristin
I received an open body scrub too! Just send them an email.
Amy
I checked in with customer support today about my replacement box and got a tracking number in reply. The new box should be here next Monday.
Reply
Colleen
Are you the Amy in Colorado? I emailed about my replacement on Monday and have yet to receive a response. A little frustrating since their offer was to ship the replacement as soon as they verified our return box was en route back to them. Not sure I’ll be purchasing these in the future. That Llb home edition is looking enticing. I can do without the makeup so could be a better fit for me. ?
Reply
Amy
Yes, I am! The replacement box was just sent yesterday and I sent mine back and notified them on October 24th. I won’t purchase a mystery box again either. I don’t subscribe to Popsugar but I received two items in these boxes that I also got in the previous mystery box. I was able to to swap some things, waiting to see what is in the replacement box before going ahead with more swaps.
Deb
I had gotten 2 # 10 boxes and received my replacement box today…….sigh…… It is a box # 1…..I really wanted that charger and perhaps a different scent candle……oh well…..that’s how it goes sometimes….
Reply
Kate N.
I received my “Bonus” gift today, since I chose not to replace my duplicate box. I got one of the tea towels that was in the April 2016 Must Have box. I liked it the first time, so now I have a matching set!
Reply
carey
I received TWO tea towels as my “gift”. they aren’t the ones from before though, they are a single color with a word on them, one says “awesome”. I am mostly satisfied, then again I only ordered two boxes. Would still order and/or sub to them, just not going to buy multiples again most likely.
Reply
Jenny
I got leave-in conditioner, honest scrub and the red base as my three replacement items. Not great but I find more useful than tea towels at least. Stinks they sent you two identical items.
Kerri
I received the tea towel as well. I hate it. What a waste of money, I will never do business with Popsugar again.
Reply
Diane Rogala
Well, I guess that I am going to ask for new boxes. I bought so many of them (10), I do not know what they will do. I have far too many of each item to use them as gifts, my intended purpose.
Jenn
If anyone wants to trade the necklace for the scarf or the gloss charger, let me know. 🙂 imacjenn with gmail.
Reply
jenn
I’ve had a few questions – I WANT the necklace. I CAN TRADE either the scarf or the charger for the necklace.
Reply
Annamarie
I’m anxiously awaiting my box (first one got lost somewhere in GA…I’m in DE…). It should be here on Saturday. It weights 2.9 lbs and is 10x10x10 in shipped from California. Which box will it be?!
Reply
Annamarie
I’m anxiously awaiting my box (first one got lost somewhere in GA…I’m in DE…). It should be here on Saturday. It weights 2.9 lbs and is 10x10x10 in shipped from California. Which box will it be?!
Reply
Colleen
Has anyone received a replacement box yet? I’m super curious if they’ll be items that weren’t in the original mystery boxes because they said they’d ship as soon as the return package started its travels back to them.
Reply
Kim
I returned 2 of box #6 which I received 3 of. I only got one box in return – Box number 9 minus the earrings. And the note cards were opened as all seals were broken. Not happy. Back again to customer service I go.
it weighed 1.7 lbs and was in an 8X8 out of the San Francisco HQ.
Reply
Mattie
Originally I received 2 #6 boxes and my replacement box was delivered today. It’s #4 and showed in tracking as 3.1 lbs coming from Watsonville, CA
Reply
Rosemary
Is there anyone who wants to swap box my box #8 for a box #9?
Reply
Diane
I have a box 8 that I would be glad to trade for a box 9.
I could provide a tracking number from Post office.
Reply
Diane
We both gave box 8. Sorry, I thought you wanted box 8.
Alyssa
Last round of mystery boxes, I received the box I wanted, which was a great box (wine glasses, bubble bath, mustard!!). I decided to order two boxes this time and ended up with Box 2 and Box 4.. same things other than the book and pixi palette. I’m a little disappointed and will be putting all of these items into my “stuff to gift other people” box I have for all of my unwanted sub items. Oh well. I probably will skip the next mystery box sale.
Reply
Chantel
Is the giveaway contest over for the super popsugar mystery box? I don’t see a link or anywhere to enter for it.
Reply
Rosemary
Damn. Got four Box #8.
Reply
Joann
Rosemary, if you email Popsugar must have customer support, they’ll give you two options
1. return the 2nd, 3rd, 4th boxes (they email you return labels) and they’ll send you different boxes.
2. They’ll send you an additional item for each duplicate box (2nd, 3rd and 4th)
Good luck
Reply
Rosemary
Thanks Joan! I have emailed them.
Leea Bristow
So I just received box 6. The PROBLEM is not the normal items in the box but the additional “gift”. The chips opened up and a colony of small ants took up residence in the box. Of course I opened on my counter. YUCK!
Reply
Karol
Ordered 2 boxes n a week later caved for another. Got a #4, meh. Just got the other other 2. SAME FREAKING BOXES!
So disappointed.
Reply
Jenn
Well, I got Box #1 and Box #5, finally, today. I’m happy with what I got and surprised they were different since they both shipped at 3.5 lbs and 11x11x11 from Gilroy. There are only a few things I won’t use. I intended to give some things as gifts, so I was actually hoping for some dupes, but now I might end up keeping most of this for myself. >.< except for the scarf. 😀
Reply
Rceli
A ha ha ha! I got box #9! The one box where in my mind I said, “Oh please don’t send me that box with the ugly stationary.” It also has the earrings, but I don’t wear earrings.
I really hate this box. I anybody want to trade for anything, please let me know.
Reply
Diane
I have multiples of box # 8.. I would love to trade for box # 6, 7, or 9.
I also have Sept, Oct boxes which I could part with.
Would be willing to add something to get one of the # 6, 7 or 9.
Reply
jennifer ohara
I received box 6. what items were you looking for? johara3574 at msn
Liz
I would love to trade. I have box 4 two of them plus other items as well email me liztx13 at gmail
I would swap generously for the package 🙂
Reply
Rceli
Thanks Liz, but but Theresa and I already traded.
I hope you are able to get everythign you want. 🙂
Theresa
Rceli!
Me me me! I have a #4 and I would even add something else to that!!
I was desperately hoping for #9 – but no such luck!!
The.Si (At) Live.De
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.