Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
POPSUGAR Must Have is a quartely lifestyle subscription box curated by the editors at POPSUGAR. Each box features their "must have" products for beauty, fashion, home, food, fitness and more. Every box has a value of $250 +!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Happy with mine! The KS bracelet alone makes it so worth it. I have the bracelet but it will make a fabulous grad gift! I was so pumped to get the rose gold polish too!!! Would’ve purchased it alone if it wasn’t sold out, so I made out great on this deal!
Reply
Mel
I just received my Girls Night Out box and the nail polish was broken and had leaked all over! I’ve never seen a bottle of nail polish break like that. It’s a really pretty color too 🙁
I just emailed Popsugar about it, did this happen to anyone else? Has anyone else dealt with their customer service in a situation like this?
Reply
Kc
My nail polish cap was dented and my mirror case was cracked. I emailed them, let’s see if they do anything.
Reply
Lunalee
They have great customer service. I had something leak all over everything and they sent me a new box.
I sent them an email with pictures.
Reply
LunaLee
Good morning everyone! I myself am still looking to swap the Lalicious Body oil and nail polish. They could be together or separate.
OR, of someone has the voucher and has not redeemed it and is willing to sell or swap it for the Gilt price. I missed out 3 times on the GNO box, lol. And I only have about one ounce left of the body oil. 😓 I love it that much.
Reply
llopez1121
I’ll swap! I just got it today, and the oil is not for me – I will say I removed about 1/3 of the seal to smell it but it’s still untouched. And the nail polish is sealed, unopened.
I’m not on the swap board yet though (waitlist) but feel free to email me at my name above @ gmail . com
Reply
Shaun
Anyone interested in swapping the makeup eraser, nail polish and bath oil? I’ve been trying to get those three items together!
Reply
Shaun
Ugh wish I would have gotten this now! Anyone interested in swapping/selling for close to what they paid?
Reply
matilda
I got this box and justified it in my head as “I need an umbrella anyway, everything else is free” and really liked some of this other stuff but the umbrella is bad. Not only is it manual (no auto-open or close) but the actual structure is so flimsy. I am pretty sure it will not last past the first NYC rain. I don’t get how this could have been sold for $50+ ever.
Reply
Sam
I agree and I live in California! I was initially excited about the umbrella until I used it in our last rain season and realize it was manual and flimsy! Had to give my elementary school daughter another umbrella to use because I didn’t want her to be trying to open this in the rain. Definitely not worth the RV.
Reply
Lunalee
Hello Matilda, if there is anything you would like to swap let me know. I am interested in the body oil and nail polish, maybe blush. Not the umbrella though I have two extra ones, lol. Thank you!
Reply
Jenn
All repeats for me with the Ultimate Box but I do not mind because I will find homes for everything. I did not get the sarong in my box though so I emailed customer service.
Reply
Nicole
This was my first purchase with PS so everything is new to me. I bought the GnO, entertaining and ultimate boxes. I received my GNO box last night but didn’t receive the make up eraser. Does Ps have prompt customer service to resolve missing items like this?
Reply
Angie
It’s interesting. I wondered if this box had an additional item. The original description notes only 8 items. How many items do you have total?
Reply
Blane428
My GNO box had 8 items as well: umbrella, blush, Body wash, mirror, bracelet, lipstick, eyeshadow palette, & nail polish.
Nicole
That’s interesting. My box has 8 items total, not including the missing make up eraser.
Blane428
No makeup eraser in mine either! I was really looking forward to it too. 🙁 I emailed them yesterday, but haven’t gotten a response yet other than their generic “we received your email.”
Reply
Jennifer
Anyone else irritated that the summer box is basically the same as the ultimate box?? I ordered all the boxes thinking they were different since they are called different things and am irritated that there is so many repeat products. 5 out of 8 products between the summer and ultimate is ridiculous. One of the non-repeat items is a sticker. A sticker. :-I… I can’t even.. Get it together Popsugar..
Reply
Meghan
Anyone order and redeem first day but tracking still shows as “processing”? I already received my November and ultimate box but this one has not moved at all. 🙁
Reply
Erin617
Yes, my Ultimate is still processing and my Girl’s Night Out shipped yesterday.
Reply
Victoria
Mine is moving but I haven’t received tracking for the ultimate box
Reply
Meghan
Hopefully it just shows up sooner than later 🙂
Anna
I am so excited and can’t wait to get my box! Awesome deal 🙂
Reply
Mindy
I wish I would have got 2 of these instead of the Ultimate. $20 well spent!
Reply
jammiemnaylor1978
I bought all 4 but would of preferred two of girls night out boxes also.
Reply
Kimberly
I’ve never ordered from PS and the Ultimate Must Have Box was my first. So disappointed. Nothing that I was hoping would be in there was. Never again.
Reply
Judy
If there’s anyone out there who actually prefers the ultimate box to the girls night out…. (Not holding breath) 😉 ….. I will swap box for box….even Steven… Unopened, shipped to you…. (It could happen) …. 👊🏼🙃 😋
Reply
Marissa
Judy I’m down lol! I was just opening my summer fun thinking how this was the perfect box for me but I’m not looking forward too my girls night other than MAYBE the umbrella and polish. Click on my name for my swap profile!
Reply
judy
Mine arrives Tuesday and can do turnaround shipping same day… I tried to sign up for swap but am aware it takes time… You can find me on FB or Pinterest if that helps… Judy Hartt … Black and white photos… There’s always more than one of us… 😋😋
Judy
Marissa…. I am not on the swap page and could not find you…. I am even including shipping on a swap…. My email is m s 2 s p y d e r @ h o t m a I l . c o m or j u d y . h a r t t @ t o y o t a . c o m … I usually just gift but I really like GNO!! Judy Hartt on FB 😊 I don’t know if I am presenting email correctly …. As I’ve seen others do…
Kelli
I will do the same….swap Ultimate for the girls night out box. If anyone is also interested.
Reply
Judy
…. ok, lets hope this can happen twice!! … calling all beach girls in need of a sarong, SWAN, and cool beach hat!! 🙏🏻😇😊
Teresa
I would love to swap for the polish is anyone is looking to swap it.
Reply
KarenG
I feel like this is the same Girls Night Out box from Christmas time. Does anyone remember that one?
It was Girls Night Out and then Girls Night In
Reply
Laura R
It was Valentine’s (galentine’s). Yes, same box.
Reply
Renee
I. love. this. box. Especially for $17.50. I was one of the few who had never received the umbrella, so was happy with that. I am happy with the bath gel, bracelet (traded all the others), and lipstick (great color!). But if anyone wants a few Stowaway palettes, let me know. 🙂
Reply
Nat
I do!!! Natt26 at ME.com
Reply
Renee
Nat, are you on swaps?
Candice
Love the contents of the ultimate, entertaining, and summer boxes. Bought all three after reveals. Thankful for the great deal!!!!! This one was sold out.
Reply
LunaLee
I am looking to swap for the Lalicious Body Wash and nail polish if these are dupes or you don’t care for them. You should be able to click on my name to view my swaps profile. Thanks!
Reply
Victoria
I have 5 of the shower oils listed. I can’t find your swap profile
Reply
LunaLee
Ok, I was able to find you and made a request. Thanks so much! 🤗
LunaLee
I will look for you, if you are under the same name. Thanks Victoria!
SJB
So annoyed. The ultimate box sucks!! Should have gotten the girls box instead. 😡
Reply
Elle
The Ultimate was a complete bust. Waste of money 🙁
Reply
Hannah
I wish I would have picked ANYTHING but the ultimate. Oh well, I guess I should learn not to pull the trigger so quickly. Anyone want a free swan?
Candice
It does not “suck” for those who are not over saturated with products. It is an amazing box for the price!
Reply
judy
By far the best of all…. And half the price of the ultimate!!! For those who lucked out, enjoy!!!!! 😎👍🏻
Reply
Kelli
I totally agree:-) If they could be consistent with these it sure would be great!
Reply
Annabella
Hahaha – I opened my Girls Night Out box, was very pleased with all the beauty stuff, then looked at the spoilers. Umbrella! I didn’t get an umbrella! It’s missing! I have to contact them and deal with it and follow up and get all stressed out!
Or, I could look under the paper squigglies and find the umbrella there. Yup, it was not missing. I almost threw it out with the ’empty’ box.
Reply
Kc
Yay! I’m so pleased the girls night out includes the bubble bath/shower gel. Can’t wait for the summer limited edition full spoilers to come out!
Reply
Michelle
Oh, it’s the same as the last girls night out box they had, right? I bought it last time, so I’m pretty sure…
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.