Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
Remember how we had some brand spoilers for the rest of 2017 for BoxyCharm? Well, now we have the item reveals thanks to iluvsarahii! (Thank you, Rebecca, for the heads up!)
Are you ready? Here are products that will be featured in Boxycharm now through December:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
October 6, and so far…
September: MAC eyebrow pencil
October: Becca Highlight, Tarteist lip paint
So all we have left are the Cover FX spray, and the Tarteist mascara!
Reply
Julia
The October box is confirmed to have the Becca Shimmering skin perfector OR liquid highlighter in Prosecco Pop.
Reply
clusby
Does anyone know if I sign up now will I receive the September box, or is it too late? Really want this box, I have a ton of other boxes that I can swap also if anyone has past boxycharm boxes you’d like to swap? ❤️😬😍
Reply
Elyska Winstead
I believe the waitlist is still lifted for a couple days but I would go sign up asap
Reply
Jess Balliet
Sooooo excited for the tarteist mascara. It’s one of only a few on the market that I haven’t tried and/or own #mascarafiendsickness I’m also super stoked to get the PÜR palette this month! PÜR is one of my favorite brands. I have a few off their palettes, and the pigmentation just can’t be topped. Happy Boxy girl for life. If I had to drop all my beauty boxes but one, that one I kept would be Boxycharm!
Reply
Toni
Boxycharm I’ll never quit you
Reply
DIAMOND
I hope I get off the waiting list quick!
Reply
Susie
I just unsubbed after the whole August debacle, still havent received my August box. So hopefully you will get my spot! Good luck!
Reply
vcole
They cancelled my box for no reason without telling me and when I tried to find out why I cant get a response. I think maybe they didnt have enough for the August boxes. That really stinks because I have been a member for years and I really enjoy their boxes. I think the brand is growing too fast and they can’t keep up with their inquiries. Sad to be treated this way by my favorite box. I hope they reactivate me soon!
Reply
Cecilia Gamboa
All of these spoilers look amazing. I’ve cancelled my Ipsy and I’m thinking of canceling my Sephora Play! box because the BoxyCharm boxes are so much better
Reply
Michel
That’s exactly what I did! I cancelled Ipsy and my Sephora Play, both of which I had been subbed to for months and months, and got on the Boxycharm train!!! Have not regretted it in the least! I also just subbed to Macy’s Beauty Box and will get my first box in just a few days. Anxious to check that one out!
Reply
Cherese
Yep, I cancelled both my Ipsy, and Play Box. I’ll take better, full sized products over sample sized ones.
Reply
Christine
I wouldn’t cancel Play. I find of all the beauty subscription boxes I try or have tried, I am most likely to buy the full-size versions of the sample sized items that come in Play.
Whereas with Boxycharm, because the items are full-size already, I don’t ever run out of the item and have to buy the full size.
Reply
Madison
I canceled Ipsy and Sephora play to get boxycharm and don’t regret it at all. Boxycharm is by far the best.
Reply
Liz
Yup, I cancelled my Play sub after subbing to Boxycharm 😀, for what I’m looking for, makeup, it’s much better. I’m still amazed by the Tarte Rainforest shadow from this month’s box!
Reply
Mary
I might have to sign up for the month that has the lash paint. That’s my favorite mascara and I should replace mine soonish, so I might as well get a bunch of other stuff for the same price as just the mascara.
Reply
Nouf
I’m excited since I’ve tried it as sample in ipsy and loved it ! Boxycharm this year is awesome !
Reply
Alex
The CoverFX and a Becca!!!! Yessssss!
Reply
Ava
I was thinking about buying that CoverFX spray anyway so I’m pumped for that!!!
Reply
Korey
I want the tarteist quick dry matte lip paint in Acid Wash, so badly!
Reply
Jay
There will also be a Colourpop item in the September box.
I just cancelled my Boxycharm sub (I don’t need or want another neutral brown palette or eyebrow pencil), and one of the “Confirm cancellation” pages told me some of the things I’d miss out on in September by canceling – Pur, MAC, and Colourpop.
I do hope people enjoy their September boxes- it’s just not for me!
Reply
Ashley Jean
I’m so excited about the cover fx setting spray and the Becca highlighter!! Not excited about the eyebrow pencil at all I never get colors light enough for my blonde hair. The ones that are supposed to be universal are always too dark. even with the lightest hand it is still tricky to make em work.
Reply
Georgia
I was so excited for the brand spoilers but now I’m just disappointed. Non waterproof mascara doesn’t work for me, the highlighter (prosecco pop) looks too dark, I like to be matte rather than illuminated… 💔 Love the brands, but these don’t look like they’ll work for me. Maybe I’ll be proved wrong
Reply
Margot
I just signed up and really want to get this box but I’m on the waitlist. How long did it take all of you to get off it? Is there any way to get off it quicker?
Reply
Josseline Rojas
I signed up 8/18 and I just received an email today from Boxycharm telling me that I am off the waitlist and they already charged my card. Good luck! I hope you get the box this month, it looks awesome.
Reply
maria
Oh my goodness well I’ll be on the waitlist forever then,lol.
But I def thank you for the information so much! Hagd/n!
Ashley Jean
I signed up on July 22nd 2017 and they emailed me on Aug 2nd 2017 and said I was off the wait list. But I think it can take anywhere from a month or two.
Reply
bmcd3713
LOL, I think I am going to have a blasted heart attack! Can you actually fall in love with inanimate objects?
Reply
Mary Ann
Yes! Yes you can…lol
Reply
Kim
When you click the becca link it goes to champagne pop…not sure if that means anything but I’ll be super happy as long as it’s not opal. I love becca super excited for that!!! I only got a 3 month sub originally but I’ll totally be staying now
Reply
Deanne
I’m SO amazed. Boxycharm and Beauty Fix are seriously amazing for the prices.
Reply
Sara
I don’t need more makeup I don’t need more makeup I don’t need more makeup. Trying to stay strong and use up my stockpile.
Reply
Naomi
I say that every month! My makeup collection just keeps getting bigger though.
Reply
TatooedBabygirl
Yes you do, yes you do, yes you do!
Reply
Jessica Hapak
I’m so happy I have a six month subscription through February. All of these look amazing. I’ve tried samples of both tarte products and love them, and I love that my makeup stash will be growing with these amazing products.
Reply
CJ
Yasssssss!
Reply
Michelle Wilhelm
I guess it just depends on what are you expecting. For $21, that many FULL SIZE products is GREAT. This will be their second month (that I know of) wherein we will receive a full size higher-end palette (that would’ve cost more than the sun price in and of itself) in our boxes. I am genuinely curious, what in the world WOULD it take to ‘wow’ you?
Reply
vanessa
It’s OK. Am I the only one not wowed? 🙂
Reply
Jena
No, I’m with you. Lol
Considered cancelling already because I wasn’t impressed with the September spoilers. I don’t need another eye brow pencil or brown/neutral eyeshadow palette….
I probably won’t tho. It really is such a great value and the only subscription box I get so it’s a fun monthly treat. I can always give as Christmas/Birthday presents!
Reply
Kc
BOxycharm cannot be beat! Their team must have amazing negotiators to get such fantastic deals for us. Could not be happier! They knock all competition out of the water!
Reply
Julie
Boxycharm August knocked it out of the park!! Looking forward to seeing more in 2017!
Reply
Betsy Wetsy
BOXYTIZED!! #BOXYCHARM4LIFE <3
Reply
Cynthia
Woot! I love that Boxycharm is including really well known brands! I am on a tight budget so I can not afford to buy these full sized on their own but Boxycharm allows me to try all these wonderful brands and products for only $21. Plus I am more likely to go buy these products again since I know where to get them and they are good brands then some of the obscure brands they have been sending months before. Keep it up Boxy!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.