Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I was thinking of canceling just because I’m on eyeshadow palette overload but the link to the palette shows a model with swatches and they look gorgeous! Now I can’t wait to play with it!
Reply
bmcd3713
This looks GREAT! Mattes are the best choice for me (being a 60+) as shimmers and (god forbid) glitter makes the wrinkles on my eyelids look far more exaggerated than I would like. So, this palette is just my style…Hallelujah!
Reply
kk
Oh…not the PUR again…
Reply
Irene A
I finished a three month sub to Boxycharm in August, and I actually cancelled. I LOVE it, don’t get me wrong (and I’m really glad I canceled before I had the August box in hand or I would have chickened out because it’s fantastic) but I’m on makeup overload at the moment! I just don’t have room for another neutral eye palette. So I’ll take a break, and probably resubscribe in a few months!
Reply
Jess Balliet
I have the PÜR DreamWorks Trolls palette and the My Little Pony palette, and a AWESOME!! The pigment amazing and does fade throughout the day. This is my favorite Boxycharm palette EVER
Reply
April
I was on the waiting list since Feb and recieved my first box in June. I like the subscription, but I seem to be on the third tier and get the items that aren’t as good.
I will keep it another month or so, but if I don’t start getting the first mailing box, I’m going to cancel.
Reply
Katie
I finally subscribed to boxycharm after hearing the hype for months and I’m pretty stoked about it. I was waitlisted but I’m hoping that I won’t be on that list for very long.
Reply
Nicole
I’m so excited to get beautiful high end eyeshadow pallets two boxes in a row. BOXYCHARM definitely know how to keep me happy. I wish i got to me sooner in the month than it does but other than that I am loving this box every month.
Reply
yvonne
I am so happy to be getting this box again. I am in desperate need of some full size products since I have not bought myself any makeup in months! this palette looks great for fall and I love to wear these colors. so excited to see what else will be in the Sept box. yay!
Reply
Tracy
I’m excited too. Have always steered clear of these colors. I didn’t think I could wear them. I finally tried them and love it.
Plus 4 mattes, 4 velvet, 4 simmer is perfect. I think a palette with a bunch of mattes is more versatile.
I can’t wait to see what the other items are!
Reply
Melissa Stephens
This is my first box 💓 Excited I got off the waitlist pretty quickly about a week
Reply
Penny
I wonder how long it takes to get off the waitlist? I would love to have the August box too!
Reply
Tracy
There’s no wait list!
Reply
Sky
Wait, did people get taken off the waitlist again?!
Debbi
I was only on it a couple of days. I Signed up on August 2 and will be receiving the August box.
Reply
des
it took me about 3 weeks
Reply
Susanne
I am honestly very disappointed in Body Charm and the whole waitlist. I received a email from them, saying I could skip the waitlist and receive August’ s box, so I caved and subbed. Of course, as soon as I put in my payment info, i was waitlisted! The only reason I subbed again was because of that email and I really wanted that box. I have reached out to Boxy Charm through email and Facebook and still no response. I am cancelling. Hopefully, they take you off the waitlist soon.
Reply
Valerie
email their support. they are very responsive. had the same issue and they corrected it. they put me back with no issues and the august box is shipped! try that. good luck!!
mmaureenn
The same thing happened to me! I emailed them, but no reply since thr auto one sayinfg I’d hear from them in 48-72 hours. It’s been more hours than that. But, I don’t want to cancel because this is a pretty palette… although I would have preferred their My Little Pony palette, this will pair nicely with it.
Korey
Happy dance! I understand people may be getting tired of warm tones, but as I have blue eyes and LOVE the autumn colors (and this is the first palette of the fall) I am super excited. I don’t think I can ever have too many palettes. And, yes, I do use them all but not daily. in fact, I probably use them more than I do ‘new’ black eyeliners, lol.
Reply
tracy
I love pallets !! Bring it on !
Reply
Jaycee
I think I’ll hold on another month, but if you look at the this and the last two palettes, it’s just warms. I’m over these colors, there has to be another option!
Reply
Chris c
Neutral colors are flattering for all..and are more than the box alone…i love them because I could never afford this high end make up ..but you can always gift to some one and make their day..i always share what I don’t like because I do get a couple other sub boxes but boxycharm by far is my fave…js
Reply
Mandy
The electric pallet was warm but some of the shades were pretty intense. The Tarte pallet is cool toned though, so naturally it will be followed by a warm…..
Reply
Alita
Im we are getting into fall ? So it might be the season for these colors ??
Reply
Jaycee
It’s been these colors all year. Spring, summer, now fall. All the palettes that came out are pretty much all warm. How many variations of gold and spicy colors does one need?
Regina
Yay! Mine shipped finally. I am so excited. I love my boxycharm. Palettes are the bomb. Anything FULL size….hehe
Reply
Emily
Can someone please help me? I tried to join the Boxycharm Beauties group on Facebook, but I completely forgot how everything works because I haven’t been on it in ages. I requested to enter the group but now I can’t even see it when I click the link from this post or when I search it 🙁
Reply
Yvette Cavazos
There was a falling out with the admins, so the page was deleted. However, Brooke and Jordan made a new group called Boxy babes
Boxy seems to be including a lot of Pur products. Within the last six months, we have had the Pur beauty blender trio (which were as hard as rocks), the Pur false eyelashes (with an uncomfortable band based on early reviews) this month and now a Pur eyeshadow palette next month.
I hope this palette is better than the past Pur items we received. Not sure why we are getting Pur stuff this often.
Reply
Molly
I own this palette already and it is absolutely amazing. You can create so many looks with it. I love it!
Reply
Olivia
See I was SO excited to recieve the PUR brushes over the sponges! The concealer brush is so freaking nice and performs so well! The eyelashes are meh but with my blonde hair, blue eyes, and virtually translucent skin, I virtually only use neutrals for eyeshadow! I am probably going to get rid of the Tarte Palette & hold out for this instead ☺️
Reply
Siren
Well, they probably have a sponsor agreement.
Reply
Karen
I have a Pur bronzer that came with a foundation I bought a few years ago. It’s too dark for me to use as a bronzer but I sometimes use it as a crease color when I want a more natural eye look. It blends really nicely. Hopefully these shadows will be just as good. I’m excited to try them.
Reply
Siren
I’m super excited about this!! 😍
Reply
cm
I’m so overwhelmed with eyeshadows. More Neutrals? Bye.
Reply
Alyce
I love any PUR item they put in my box! 😍😍
Reply
Penny
If you’re put on the waiting list, do you pay right away or when your first box is shipped?
Reply
Cristina
The month when your box is shipped. I got charged the same day I got the email saying I was off the waitlist.
Reply
Penny
Thank you!!
Emily
Is this palette in every charmers box or a possible variant item?
Reply
JuJu
In every box. The first couple of items they spoil are non-variant.
Reply
Emily
Oh okay, thank you! I’m a new subscriber so I’m not too familiar with how things go 🙂
Joyce
I’m super excited for this palette. I watched a video with a bunch of looks from this palette. If any one is interested it’s Kristen Gehm channel. She is AMAZING. Beautiful looks. I’m so Happy I signed up for this box. I just did this month of Aug. I’m hoping I will get Aug box. Already chord me for it so I’m hoping.
Reply
Kimber
I just checked KG’s video out, so thanks for posting about it. She got some gorgeous looks from this palette, and she even achieved some great cool toned ones too! I’m now excited about this! I also just subbed to her, and I’m going to binge on her 4 Looks 1 Palette series lol!
Reply
Liz
I’ve had it for a year and almost ALMOST every box has been amazing
Reply
Raquel
I would like to see some different colors the point is to try different stuff not the same colors all the time right!
Reply
Denise
i look at it this way, getting palettes is better than sending out one eye color that i may or may not like. it ups the chance that there will be a color i can wear and hopefully more than that. most of them are at least worth the price of boxycharm also so then the rest is icing on the cake. it helps that i’m a palette addict besides, so that’s where they got me.now if i can just get more lipsticks i’d be in heaven
Reply
Denise
ps i have subbed to almost all of them at one point or another and held off on this for a long time but now i’m kicking myself
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.