Facebook PixelSubscriber Survey: If You Could Only Subscribe to One Box, Which One? | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Subscriber Survey: If You Could Only Subscribe to One Box, Which One?

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanAug 27, 2017 | 162 comments

Sunday Subscriber Survey time! If you are a subscription addict, this may be the toughest question ever...

If you could only subscribe to one subscription box, which box would you pick?

I'm seriously having an impossible time with this one! My first thought is that I'd go for a lifestyle/more expensive box if I can only have one. So, FabFitFun, POPSUGAR Must Have, Robb Vices, and Box of Style came to mind. Then I thought, well if I can only have one box, it better be monthly! So I've narrowed it down to POPSUGAR or Robb Vices. And that's as far as I got!

Which box would you pick?

P.S. If you have an idea for a future Subscriber Survey question, let me know in the comments!

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

162 comments

Deionna

FabFitFun! I would be adding more add ons for sure and I would buy mystery boxes whenever I see them. Also I would really miss Boxycharm, sad face!

Reply ButtonReply

Valene

Therabox.

Reply ButtonReply

Connie

FabFitFun is my quarterly choice, but hands down for me for makeup- I love Julep! So I have had to cut down and I tried to knock out Julep and just keep putting it back!

Reply ButtonReply

Patricia

Say it With a Sock! Love their socks and so comfortable!!!

Reply ButtonReply

cindycb

The only one that I am now currently subscribed to. FabFitFun.

LOL after I find a job I am going to go back to The Box of Awesomeness. Because it is just so much un!

Reply ButtonReply

cindycb

Fun

Reply ButtonReply

Tammy Brunette

My fave right now is Degustabox, although there’s too many ethnic offerings!

Reply ButtonReply

Sonia

Pop sugar

Reply ButtonReply

Tracy

Simply Earth!

Reply ButtonReply

Alanna

Beautyfix for me. Boxy is great but I’m more skin oriented than makeup!

Reply ButtonReply

Karol

Robb Vices

Reply ButtonReply

Stephanie W

I love Boxycharm for the value but my absolute favorite has to be Glowing Beets! I love natural products especially skincare and the items they send are high quality. They have amazing customer service, too! I had a broken pump on a serum & they quickly replaced it. A differect brand sent a mislabeled cleanser and they got me in contact with the company and had and replacement out to me with a free gift in a few days. Lastly, there was a variation of a product and I commented on IG which one I was hoping to get in my box. I didn’t get it in that particular box but they sent me the item for free this month which was a pleasant surprise. I’ll continue to support them as long as I can!

Reply ButtonReply

KimberlyB

Pusheen! This month, the only item I didn’t squee over was the popsicle mold. In fact, every box they’ve knocked it out of the park for me except for Spring 2016 and Spring 2017.

Beauty: ipsy
Snacks: Graze
Lifestyle ??? I’m still searching for one that matches my weird taste even a little.

Reply ButtonReply

JoEtta

Box of style. Nice items and it doesn’t feel like a bunch of filler items I will never use like some boxes do. Right behind that would be Vine Oh! and popsugar though 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Maria

Pop Sugar Must Have because of their customer service and quality items!

Reply ButtonReply

Jill Lowry

BeautyFix for sure

But runners up:
Cairn
Cratechef
Boxycharm

Hoping Passport to Beauty will steal a spot!

Survey ideas:
1. Which box has lost its appeal, and why?
2. If you could change one thing about your favorite box, what would it be?
3. Boxes destined to be holiday gifts this year?
4. You should have a signup for your readers who want to do a secret santa, the exchange being a box item, MSA matches people, and we get to meet new people! Most of us have box items we could easily gift!

Reply ButtonReply

Jane

Pusheen!

Pusheen box makes me happier than any other box. I love how thoughtful and useful the items in it are as well as being completely adorable.

Reply ButtonReply

Heather S

My girls would say 100% the Pusheen Box, though their shipping dates tend to be erratic (says it will ship on this date but it ends up shipping 8-9 days later) but you get no less than 6 items and it includes a wearable item. We have all enjoyed every single item in each box.

Me: I am waiting for Boxy Charm….but I do love my Ipsy box each month. Though from all the sneak peeks Boxy Charm looks amazing!!! I am getting Owlcrate for September and that looks so good, I won their box for July and loved it! Ugh so many boxes!

Reply ButtonReply

Dani

Elizabeth & Clarke!!!!!! The tops they’ve sent me have been in regular rotation in my wardrobe for years. I’m wearing one right now!

Reply ButtonReply

Toni

Boxycharm all the way ,I love my box every month

Reply ButtonReply

TK

That’s a really hard question because I like them for different reasons. FFF is my fav lifestyle box mainly because I love add ons and I’ve had amazing experience with CS. Beautyfix is my fav beauty box because I’m a skincare junkie. Robb Vices can’t be beat for an indulgent treat. I have at least 8 other boxes so I hope I never have to pick just one.

Reply ButtonReply

Shannon

Boxy!

Reply ButtonReply

Paula G

BOXYCHARM all the way! I have loved every box!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

Breo Box for sure.

Reply ButtonReply

Bonnie

You have got to be kidding with this one. One sub? Not even sure if I could narrow it down to five. First to mind are Fruit for Thought and Look Incredible (but even that I get the standard AND deluxe boxes). But I also really love So Susan Liplove and Ipsy. I love Box of Style, but I think I would cut that one because I feel it skews toward smaller people – the OS straight size kimono with those narrow shoulders and that tiny necklace in the Summer box.

Reply ButtonReply

Jennifer Morgan

BOXYCHARM🙋🏼🙋🏼🙋🏼🙋🏼🙋🏼

Reply ButtonReply