Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I love you boxycharm – please don’t ever leave me.
Reply
cheyenneskaggs15
Does this mean we may not be getting a eye shadow palette? I’m not a fan of highlighters but I will try it.. I don’t use a lot of foundation as my skin is really nice with very few imperfections. Pressed would be best with me I suppose. Willing to trade if I get the liquid.
Reply
lilies2u
yay!! I’m so excited for this October sneak peek! Hoping I get the liquid one , will happily swap a powder for the liquid with anyone who wants powder. Bring it on Boxy!
Reply
Michelle Ford-Copley
Every single month Boxy blows me away. Always so excited for it to come in!
Reply
Siren
No. More. Highlighters!
Reply
MzBev
I have more highlighters than I’ll ever be able to use. They have sent so many this year, I thought (hoped?!) it was over. Lol
Reply
aisha
Just because you don’t want a certain product doesn’t mean that other people don’t either. I’m really excited to get one actually! I notice that a lot of people complain on here rather than being thankful that you’re getting beauty boxes with such amazing products for just 21 a month. Great deal!
Reply
Jaclyn
I agree too! I have a lot of highlighters too, but come on, it’s BECCA! I LIVE FOR THIS LOL. I have her highlighter in Champagne Pop and it’s my holy grail. If you don’t want it, you can just sell it or give it away to friends/family. Or, if you’re that disappointed, then unsubscribe. Honestly, the way they pack over $100 worth of products into a $21 box is amazing. You really shouldn’t be complaining.
Karrick
I completely agree with you! Some ppl act like its all about them….well its not. Im grateful we have the sub. Im not always 100% satisfied but I dont complain unless something is broken. Stop with the complaining ppl. Its exhausting.
Sunshine Syndrome
If i sign up.for the box now would I get September’s box or next mths? Anybody??
Reply
clusby
I’m wondering the same thing, I just signed up like 5 minutes ago and they did charge my credit card, no email saying I’m on a waitlist, so hoping hoping hoping I get the September box 😬😬😬🙏🏻
Reply
Jennifer Dunlop-Gierok
If they charged your card you’re not on any waitlist. They only charge it for the month you get a box in.
cheyenneskaggs15
If BC billed you will get the box of the month you were billed for.
Jane
Whatever month they charge your card is the the box you receive. So if you sign up now and are charged, then you will receive September’s box. Sometimes there is a wait list, but I believe they lifted it for a short period
karenkk
YAAAAAY! I’m very glad that the highlighter will be in October’s box cuz then I can just cancel boxycharm for that month! The shade is the DARKEST in Becca and I have pale skin. I hope that boxycharm can consider color variations.
Reply
Nicole
Why would you cancel just because you don’t like one item? There will be several others in the box, you can just donate it or something.
Reply
Cindy
So sick of highlighters. I try to avoid boxes that spoil them as a feature but I still could coat my whole body in them for several days…..
Hope the next item is great for me.
Reply
Cynthia
Ooo! I definitely want the pressed version and I will gladly swap the liquid with someone if I get it! Please universe give me the pressed one!
Reply
Bec
I have the pressed one in the LE Becca palette so I would also gladly swap with someone for the liquid version if I get the pressed 😬
Reply
Lissy
Same here!
Reply
Katie
I know highlighter is a little “hello, look at my pores” but I think it’s my favorite part of my makeup. I can never have enough. The liquid would be fantastic under my bb creams. 🙂
Reply
Korey
Question: If I get the liquid highlight, when do I put it on? I use liquid foundation and every thing else is powder. I would assume I would use it before powder, but then powdering over the top would dull the highlight, right?
Reply
Jessica m Blalock
Before you apply powder apply a little to the areas you want and then try not to put powder over those areas. 🙂
Reply
Yuliia Borzylo
I have a pressed one in a palette, i hope that i will get a liquid one
wish we could request 🙂
Reply
Olivia
LIZ CHECK YOUR FACEBOOK MESSENGER! ILUVSARAHII posted her FULL BOXYCHARM BOX for September!!! Sent you pictures 💋💋💋
Reply
Lissy
Where can we find it if you don’t mind?
Reply
Korey
I haven’t seen them on her instagram or youtube. Somewhere else I should be checking?
Reply
Jos
I saw it on her Instagram story, she does a few unboxings and Boxycharm. The products she received were the Pur palette, the Bare Minerals brush, a colourpop lip product, a Studio Makeup loose powder blush and a Briogeo hair mask. I didn’t see the MAC pencil but she did a really fast unboxing. Also, she did not say the shade names for anything. The CP was a brownish neutral colour and the blush was pinky-gold. Hope this helps!
Jen
I can’t the pics? Can you post the product names?
Reply
Korey
I don’t see them on her instagram or youtube. Are they buried somewhere?
Reply
Ann
I find that my pearly highlighters give me a shine, while this warm gold subtle shimmer gives me a glow, if that makes sense. Both are nice. I have light skin with neutral undertones. Becca highlighters work with most skin tones, as they are subtle natural looking shimmer and not super glitter disco ball sweaty face. A concentrated swatch is not what it looks like blended. Great for any age!
This is not at all the darkest highlighter they make. I think the gold will work well mixed with foundation for a glow, so I’d prefer the liquid slightly. I’d be happy with the powder as well, though. I’m thrilled with this spoiler!
How is Boxycharm able to do this every month? Amazing. I’m gonna ride it out while it lasts!
Reply
Alex
OMG I’ll be thrilled with either! I can’t pick!
Reply
Jennybean
Love the October spoiler! I’ve got a few of the Becca highlighters and they’re awesome. I prefer the poured over pressed, and haven’t tried the liquid, so I’m hoping I get that. If you rub it on your fingers first and tap it on, I imagine you can get it pretty sheer for those worried about it being too dark. Boxycharm is easily turning into my new fav beauty box. It’s the best value by far.
Reply
vonvon
Love becca and I dont mind getting either one but I hope this highlighter works on my fair skin🙏🏼
Reply
Toni
Yay 😍 Another killer sneak peak.October is my birthday month so bring on the presents Boxycharm
Reply
Dorian
I really want to be pumped for this, I love highlighter can’t ever have enough. And I’ve heard great things about Becca but never gotten to try it. But I wish there were variations or something because this is way too dark and yellow for me
Reply
Amber
Same 🙁 I’m just hoping it somehow works anyway lol
Reply
bmcd3713
Prosecco Pop is THE darkest of all Beca’s highlighters and while I am curious to use one of their highlighters, I don’t think I will be able to actually use them. Oh well…
Reply
Jen
Yea! I’m hoping for the liquid bc I think I would get more use out of it, mixing it with my foundation or primer.
Reply
Pingping
My first reaction when I saw the images was: no Opal please! I love Opal but I already have a life-time supply thanks to Sephora. I would be happy to receive either version! Can’t wait to see full spoilers for September.
Reply
BONNY ADAMS
Isn’t this 5 out of 6 spoilers? Ive been a subscriber for 4 years…no breaks, no cancellations, no hesitation. I never doubt that they will send me at least two items ( way over the box cost value) that I can use. I do believe that at least 5/6 items…I will be able to use. What I dont use, my younder version of me( 24 yr old daughter) will definitely use( different skin tone.) Boxycharm is the ” No Brainer” of All makeup subscriptions! If youbcant use an item…you can sell it, give it, gift it or swap it for something you will use, you can not do this with all boxes( at least not as easily.) The value makes this equal to my Beautyfix( mostly skin care and hair care) and these two boxes alone are amazing( unfortunately I have an addiction to sub boxes and have waaayy mor subs, Thanks to Liz!) There is no other ” Makeup lover’s” box that will compare!
Reply
Korey
No, this is a spoiler for October. We still have (sort of) 4 out of 6 for September. They just combined the two posts on here.
Reply
Korey
I’m not big on highlight, but I do hope I get the pressed version as I am no fan of liquid highlighter. I can’t wait to see October’s palette :D. I LIVE for October-December and hope all the makeup is ready for Autumn then Holiday parties !!!
Reply
Jackie
Hoping for powder! Hopefully if I get the liquid one, someone will trade me!
Reply
Ashley
I would be interested in trading if I get the powder one. I think I want the liquid one just a tad more…
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
bareMinerals Perfecting Face Brush ($28)
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.