Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Feeling a bit frugal but still want some mystery? Here you go! The $5 buck mystery box. Don't worry, it will be worth far more than $5. It may be one item, it may be several, but it WILL be mysterious. You can order up to 10 of these. Yes, we have a flat rate $3.99 shipping charge for these, but that's so most of your $5 for the box isn't used to ship your order. Unfortunately UPS and Fedex still refuse to ship our stuff for free, even though we asked very nicely. The $3.99 is the same if you order 1 or 10, so might as well order 10.
We have been doing mystery boxes for NINE YEARS, and continue to blow people away with the value and variety of our boxes. Our boxes are different than most. They can differ from person to person and we focus on giving you the wow factor for your dollar.
For those of you that like surprises on a r... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Got mine in last week and I received a very nice bathroom mat that’s perfect for my little bathroom, a water filtration system that I’ve already used and some dumb ear muff things. Not bad for 5$!
Reply
Michelle
I got mine the other day and was wishing I hadn’t wasted my money… Oh well, it was like $15 down the drain.. live and learn… My doggie bag this month also sucked. I guess I’ll be cancelling that one.
Reply
Rachel
Yeah, I agree. Finally got mine and it was stuff I’d never buy and have no use for at all. Won’t do that again, glad it was a small amount of money wasted.
Reply
Vicki
Got mine yesterday!!
Reply
Rachel
Did anyone that ordered these ever receive them? I ordered 3 and haven’t gotten anything or any shipping information.
Reply
Vicki
I just sent them an email. I got an order that i placed a week after ordering 3 mystery boxes that I dont have. They left out my added mystery item so I had to request that they send that as well. One Item in my second order is damaged so we will see how their customer service is. I have been reading reviews online and they have a history of being very slow shippers. If I get my boxes soon I will post an additional reply.
Reply
Stacy
I ordered 2 and haven’t gotten any shipping information. I e-mailed them this morning and they said they were waiting on reshipment of a product. They claim to have since received it and will be shipping my order this week.
Reply
LynnDeanne
They don’t always send shipping info, FWIW.
Reply
Rachel
Thanks. I’m going to email them. It said 3-8 days but it’s not been 16 business days. Just wondering if anyone else had issues with getting it. 🙂
cindycb
I really enjoy getting these boxes. You will be happy if you are not holding high expectations. I have gotten some great items that I didn’t know I needed.
This subscription was one of the many that I had to cut when the budget got tight, but I can enjoy treat like this.
Reply
Michelle
I didn’t get this but got the small dog box the other day and was my Bamy happy!!
Reply
Dianne
I got one yesterday. I’ve got some of their deals before and usually ok. Sometimes weird stuff. Their mystery Urban outfitters grab bag was bad and also the hard candy grab bag was bad. I’ve gotten the mystery box of Awesome and mini box of Awesome once they were good. Their larabars expired by Best Good date still editable want buy again. Other stuff I bought was good.
Reply
SRG
Gosh I just got the email about this and there is a $500 box as well. Definitely not in my budget but so curious just what that could be!!! How big would that box be….refrigerator size? I imagine so many funny things. I hope someone buys and reviews it 🙂
Reply
Missy
That would be awesome! They also do 2 39.99$ boxes everyday that I’ve been curious about !
Reply
Melody
This company sends out nothing but 99 cent garbage. NEVER AGAIN
Reply
Betty
I’ve had literally the direct opposite experience. I’ve ordered every single box they’ve offered and never once been disappointed.
Reply
Brittany
SOLD OUT
Reply
Beth
They must have added more stock because it’s not sold out anymore.
Reply
SMZ
Whoever writes the text for this company is hilarious!
Reply
Starla
I got 3. I’m a sucker for a mystery.
Reply
michelle
I’m also such a sucker for mystery boxes and have had good luck for the most part. I bought 2 for fun!! *fingers crossed*
Reply
Missy
🤞
Missy
Me too! I got 2 and added a mystery item for .98 cents I also joined the Jammin Butter club for 4.99$ and that gave me a free shipping coupon so I basically paid 1$ to join because I was gonna get the 5$ mystery box with 3.99$ shipping anyways so I was able to use the free shipping coupon & they add extra items to your orders & gave me a discount off the 5$ price!! Hope I get a good one!!!
Reply
Missy
Yeah I’m so in on this might get a few! Do you know when they’ll ship??
Reply
michelle
Whenever I order from them it seems like it takes about 2 weeks or so to get my order. So I wouldn’t expect it to be a few days.
Reply
Missy
Well it says 3-8 business days for shipping time but I wonder if they ship asap? Guess I’ll find out!!
Reply
Jessica
Yeah, ok I’ll give this a try. I’ve seen some stuff from Daily deal that is ok. If nothing else they can end up as stocking gifts or go for swap…
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.