Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
What do you think of the latest Boxycharm spoiler?
If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more. (And sign up asap if you want November's box - there's a waitlist!)
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
This holiday season when we’re complaining about our makeup palettes and overpriced face paint toys… someone is going without far more. So be kind to a stranger save the salty comments for next year. And if you are high on the karmic reader for salty brat of the year…. do a little extra this holiday season to balance things out. Go through the drawers of face paint and face masks and closets of accessories and clothes and find your towns local domestic violence shelter ~ go bring some happy to someone who could use the pick me up.
Be kind to one another – tomorrow’s never promised…
Reply
Jraewebb
I just saw that spoiler #3 is a full size Tarte Tarteist mascara!! I’ve been wanting to try it! Yay😉
Reply
Kellyerin Conley
Check out Tartes Birthday!!!!! Awesome
Reply
Kellyerin Conley
It’s Tartes birthday… Check out the mascara promo.
Reply
Jennifer Dunlop-Gierok
So excited about Novembers box already! At first I wasn’t thrilled about the setting spray but I read a few tips on it and tried it again at sephora and I think I love it now! And this pallet is for my daughter for Xmas! She LIVES kitties and even tho I really want it I HAVE to give it to her! I’m still gonna borrow it tho 😆. Love my Boxycharm! Even the things I don’t really want ate always quality products and even if I can’t use them someone else is always happy to have it. Wish I could get a box a week. Sigh…
Reply
Bella01
I received my box yesterday and I was so thrilled when I saw the liquid Becca Box and I also received my absolute favorite color Tarte lipstick in PillowTalk. Yayyy and I got the nail kit. But my scisssors already broke. But it’s ok. I’m still impressed. My lipliner in in Spice and matches well with PillowTalk. It’s funny because all my make up on today is from Boxycharm. I’m loving the blue eccentric eye liner from last month. I used in on my whole bottom lid and applied a metallic blue on top and blended some browns on crease line. Looks fabulous. Did a Smokey eye and have on my PillowTalk and I love, love, love.
Reply
Korey
FYI, confirmed spoiler in BC stories on instagram is we’re getting a Tartiest mascara in November’s box. I need to see if it’s well rated because I’ve never used it. Way for them to keep bringing the brands, though!
Reply
Vanessa
It’s a great mascara for people with non-oily eyelids. Lots of transfer if you are oily, but if you put a clear waterproof gel on top it’s great!
Reply
Virgie
I got my Oct box yesterday and the tart liquid lip is NOT my color. I don’t wear red lipstick but everything else was pretty good I do wish I would’ve got the pressed highlight an not the liquid but it’s still pretty.
I am liking next month spoilers so far.
Reply
Mariela Pinela
Im so excited can”t wait for the palette and spray. I have plenty of palettes but this one looks so pretty.
Reply
Catharine Clarenbach
I am such a sucker for palettes. I LOVE Boxycharm for just this reason. Having lots of options makes me really happy.
Reply
Eeyore
The only thing I want to say is to the people who use this box for more than what it’s supposed to be. It’s supposed to be a box to show you products, brands, formulas, etc. Not to give you your makeup wants and needs. Try going and buying something retail, then complain when you don’t get the color you ordered or the product you actually paid for comes broken. I see nothing but complaints and demands. It’s a box, it’s basically one twenty dollar bill and people still complain.
Reply
Denise
I’m starting to think the tarte lipsticks they sent must be the ones that weren’t selling well bucause they don’t seem very popular. Other than delish which is a great color for a lot of people
Reply
Catharine Clarenbach
People will whine. You know. Human nature. I try to treat every box as an experiment. I mean, if something comes broken, I might be grumpy, but the wrong color? I can almost always give to my bestie. 🙂
Reply
Denise
Hopefully I won’t be yelled at for stating my opinion lol. Yikes
Reply
Ppzhang
I just got my October Boxy, and I received “Delish” (the only color that I can wear among the variations) and the powder highlighter (the one I prefer)!! I’m literally crying right now. The makeup god finally heard my prayer!!
Reply
Susan Riley
Is anyone else having trouble with the pump on the liquid highlighter in October’s box? The liquid is so thick that absolutely nothing is coming out. I had to open the bottle and use it that way. What can I put in it to thin it out? Also, the lipstick is the palest color I’ve ever seen! I can’t imagine it being a flattering shade on anyone, and then a dark brown lipliner. Not sure I can even gift those two items. I’m generally very happy with my Boxycharm box, but this makes three very iffy items.
Reply
Bella01
Try running the nozzle under hot water. I read some reviews that the pump was getting clogged.
I want the lightest color in the lipstick. I’m really hoping i get that one.
Reply
Danielle
Yay! I am so excited I can’t wait to try the pallet and the spray. This is only my third month of boxycharm and it is my favorite box I get every month. I can’t believe I didn’t know about it earlier!
Reply
Katie S
Boxycharm is Killin it!! Can’t wait for next month! 💛❤️💜💙💚
Reply
Katie
I think this palette is gorgeous, but I’ll most likely gift it to someone for Christmas since I’ve got my eye on the cats pajamas palette. A person only needs so many palettes and I already get great use out of my Soiree Diaries palette. Now the hardest part will be deciding who the lucky duckling getting this will be.
Reply
Jessica
Katie: I hope you love your new palette. I’m sure the recipient of the Winky Lux palette will be delighted. Looks like some people need a refresher on that age old lesson that if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all.
Reply
Catharine Clarenbach
but there’s always the Olympia Dukakis quotation from _Steel Magnolias_ — If you don’t have anything nice to say, come sit by me. 🙂
Jamie
I wouldn’t recommend that pallette, all the reviews on it are really bad and cringey!
Reply
Bella01
Your wrong Jaime. Don’t try to trick us. This palette has the excellent reviews…Check out Ciao Bella review. Why you would say any thing negative about an excellent product is beyond me.
Pigment is on fire too.
Tamara Deneweth
So pretty ! Another amazing boxy, so excited to try this Palette, i live for eyeshadow!
Reply
Tanya
Got my October box today. So excited about dr. Brandt since got beautyfix so covered for 2018 sub shutdown. Have no idea of what to do with a liquid highlighter and xoxo oranges out on my dark brown skin… my two friends are loving this box but I am happy with dr Brandt… funny dr b tube beauty fix came in a box so no box cuts down weight for boxy. Jonteblu rich red went orange too but I’ve always had to really stick with ester launder, Chanel and urban decay for shadows and lips. My mac pencil is amazing no problems there! And love Briogeo hair mask so cost of box covered two months in a row two full sized products covered box. Let’s see what next month brings. Palettes make amazing gifts if not your color!!!
Reply
Tracie
I got my box today and LOVE LOVE LOVE Dr. Brant. However, everything else was something I can’t wear. I got the liquid highlighter, the eye pencil crayon and a lipstick that is my skin tone, I will not wear as it will look like I have no lips! Eye pencil is the same color, could be used as a concealer. No nail kit, so sad! I was looking forward to that. 🙁 November looks great though. I also got BeautyFix and was so happy with that! Have a great day!
Reply
Zsuzsana
I got a lip color that completely washed me out too (pillowtalk). I recommend layering it over a creamy lip liner in a darker color. It mixes pretty well with the liner color and creates a lighter matte shade. I just woke off the applicator before putting it back in the tube!
Maliyah Safranski
I would love to trade the nail kit for the lipstick if you’re interested!!
Amy
I am very excited about the Cover FX spray, not so much the eyeshadow palette. I might gift it to my mom, she would look better with those eyeshadows. I could always go for another eyeshadow palette, but I know this would not look good on me. Still subscribing though to get that spray!
Reply
chelsea
Boy, that pallette sure does look like Laura Lee’s cat’s pajamas, which also looks like colorpop. I am assuming it’s teh same lab and packaging facility – at least it’s a cruelty free brand. Please correct me if it’s not. woo.hoo. Bring on the eye shadow!
Reply
beautywiththedinoess
Colourpop has their own facility in California where they make their items. 😁
Reply
Mallory
OMG that’s adorable. Which is good, because I’m a little disappointed with my October box that just arrived yesterday. Seriously I was hoping that the “nail kit” would be something a little more impressive than a logo slapped on a dollar store item.
Reply
cynthia
I got the matte lip instead of the nail kit. They should have called it flesh, because it is the color of my skin. NOT flattering at all. 🙁
Reply
Bella01
Thats the color lippie i want
vvaz32
Everyone received the Tarte lip color. To my knowledge it wasn’t one of the variable items.
Mary K
See? I told y’all to calm down the other day bc a palette could still be included. 😀 They sure have improved their brands from the year I subbed. Not tempted though, I am on beauty product overload. I’m happy for you guys, though.
Reply
Bella01
lol Mary, you sure did tell them. Very excited
Reply
Misty Telling
I seen the palette and thought it looked like the Laura Lee Cats Pajamas palette that’s about to be released. Then, i see the name the name of this one has to do with cats. I guess a good knock off isn’t bad.
Reply
Heidi
I agree 🐱dupe
Reply
Geena
This palette has been out and for sale for months now – Winky Lux is actually a really good indie brand. I own their Diamond powder, a couple of lipsticks, and the brow pencil we got in boxy a few months back. If anything this is the palette being copied…
Reply
Ginger
Actually, according to the several reviews I’ve read on it, this palette was released at the beginning of October, so only a couple weeks now. I’m surprised it will be included, given that all of the other palettes I’ve received have been out for at least a year. But Winky Lux isn’t as well known, so the publicity will be good for them. I also have a couple liquid lips from them, and one of the colors is a fave of mine. I wasn’t sure I would like it. It went on pasty peach-rose, but it dried down a nice medium rosy nude and was perfect.
Bella01
They actually have their own brand and products. I have a lipstick in this brand and it’s excellent. And the packaging is adorable too.
Reply
Mary Davis
I love all the palettes but I wish they’d do different colors. There’s only so many nude shadows a person needs.
Reply
Ginger
The shades are not really well represented in the photo above. The reviews I’ve read show more plum, pink, smoky, and duochrome effects than nude. It’s similar to Cat’s pajamas, except that “holographic” color is pretty unique.
Reply
RoguesEn3D
Agreed! Why are so many palettes nude-heavy this year? Lips, eyes, even blushes. I can’t even give away all that I have.
Nudes aside, I like the richer colors in this palettes. It looks autumnal, which I am lacking.
Now.. if some richly colored lippies were involved too, that would seal the fun for me. I haven’t received my October box yet, so I don’t know if I’ll be receiving a Tarte nude or some nicer color.
Reply
Jessica
I really love Winky Lux ever since that pill-shaped lipstick. So I’m excited to try their eye shadow. Though mostly I’m excited about cats. Take note beauty boxes: more cats.
Reply
Bonnie
Yes! Whether I like these shadows or not, I’m just excited for the package!
Reply
Bella01
Right, remember Jessica? I love the Winky Lux pill-shaped lipstick. It’s my favorite. I only use it for special occasions and the formula is to die for. Excellent
Reply
AmandaT
Can you imagine a cat-themed beauty box? I’d never unsub!
Reply
Siren
Oh my gosh, yes! A cat themed beauty box!
karen
Ooooooh I’m excited. Was sad that there wasn’t a palette on Octobers boxycharm buuuuuut I’ve loved everything in it so far soooo YES!!! Now i’m definitely thinking about unsubbing to Ipsy’s mediocre bags.
Reply
Mary
Super excited for this one! Love eyeshadow palettes!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.