Facebook PixelBoxyCharm October 2017 Theme Reveal! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm October 2017 Theme Reveal!

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanOct 1, 2017 | 84 comments

Boxy-charm-march-2017-0002

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We're still waiting on more October spoilers, but today we have the theme for the October 2017 BoxyCharm!

Spellbound! (Very appropriate for October, no?)

And in case you missed the spoilers, each box will include:

Tarte Tarteist™ Quick Dry Matte Lip Paint

Subscribers will receive 1 of 8 shades: Homeslice, Delish, Front Row, Bestie, Get It, Salty, Pillowtalk, or Xoxo

Dr. Brandt PoreDermabrasion - Value $58

Subscribers will receive one of the following:

Becca Liquid Highlighter Prosecco Pop - Value $41

Becca Shimmering Skin Perfector Pressed Highlighter in Prosecco Pop - Value $38

What do you think of the October 2017 Boxycharm theme and spoilers? 

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Sign up here! Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers for future updates!

Starting at $32.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

84 comments

Erin

I am disappointed in this box so far and I wish all the spoilers were reveled while I could still cancel. The highlighter is likely too dark for my paleness, I cant use the Dr. Brant because I already have dry skin, and my last three boxes all have sent my lip color way to dark/wrong undertone for me so I expect the same for this. Might think about switching to Sephora Play. At least their boxes are tailored to skin color.

Reply ButtonReply

Ginger

Sephora Play isn’t that great at all. I tried to give them a chance, and in the span of a year, I got tons of repeats and terrible colors when they did send cosmetics, which was rare. I never got a usable lip product. At least with Boxycharm, 3 out of 5 products have been great or better than great. To me, that’s worth getting a silly looking lipstick.

Reply ButtonReply

Jada

I had Sephora Play! and never got a lippie that matched my skin tone. Im not even sure why Sephora does a profile to be honest . I cancelled them for that very reason. I did like quite a bit of the samples from Sephora but id rather get full size items . To each their own tho .

Reply ButtonReply

Yvette

I Love me some Boxycharm! 😊😻👌💜❤️ please appreciate it that you are receiving name brand products all for 21 bucks. No complains here

Reply ButtonReply

sferry79

Same here!! Couldn’t be happier!!! I joined 6 more monthly subscriptions after joining this website and only 2 are close to worth the money. Boxycharm is the 1st and Fabfitfun is a close 2nd. Glossybox, Scent Trunk, Love Purely and Emma and Chloe are cancelled or being cancelled today. Wish they were all like Boxycharm!!

Reply ButtonReply

Lori

Couldn’t agree more about Boxycharm 😁😁😁 I was wondering about scent trunk & scent bird… I love perfume but I’m kinda picky about it too 🤔🙄🤔 what’s your experience with them if you don’t mind me asking?

Jenna

I can’t wait for the 4th spoiler! So far this box is awesome!

Reply ButtonReply

Chris

I have had boxy for 4 years. As well as every other beauty box. The owner of boxy NEVER SAID we were getting a palette every month. He said it would be raining palettes. It’s amazing, we already know we are getting $120 worth of product with just the 3 spoilers & people are still complaining. There is NOT another subscription out there that comes close to the value & high end product we receive from boxy. I have loved every box for 4 years and have been wowed by the $ amount we receive for just $21.00! That Is why there is a huge waitlist! But listen, if you are that upset that there is no palette in October even though we are getting a 30$ becca highlighter, 60$ skin exfoliant, & tarte lippie $26… (and 2 more items to go!!) then by all means cancel the subscription and allow someone who is more appreciative to receive it!! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Ginger

Couldn’t agree more! We could be getting just the exfoliator this month, and I’d be happy. Boxy kills it every time.

Reply ButtonReply

disneyjoy1970

I completely agree with you. I for one am super grateful to receive such high quality items, each and every month.

Reply ButtonReply

vero

Well said! I totally agree! I am a new subscriber to Boxycharm, my first box was in July . Let me tell you that the value is amazing. This is way better than Ipsy and Allure. All the products are FULL SIZED!

Reply ButtonReply

Verenisse

I couldn’t have said it better myself!!! <3 =)

Reply ButtonReply

Anna

Hear, hear! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

I’m dying to be off the waitlist!

Reply ButtonReply

Lori

😉👍👊 totally agree! I love my Boxycharm! Every month I’m amazed at what they send & if it doesn’t work for me personally? I have friends 😉👍

Reply ButtonReply

Jada

Id like to be off the wait list , lol….

Reply ButtonReply

Nyesha

I subscribed to boxycharm because I drooled over the august and september boxes and now that my first box will be october, there won’t be a cool palette? Nothing against Dr. Brandt but I have too much skincare like that and I don’t care for the highlighter either. Good thing I can swap 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle Ford-Copley

We are moving halfway across the country this month, I made SURE to have this month’s box go to my exes address – we are moving back close to family for the (adult) kids. But, I was NOT gonna take a chance on my box getting lost because of a mail snafu OR my klepto sister coming and filching it from my porch or mailbox.

Reply ButtonReply

Carmen

Hi guys, if I can get the September box, does it mean that I can get October as well? I subscribed it monthly :-p

Reply ButtonReply

Bashley

As long as your card info is up to date your subscription will automatically renew unless you cancel.

Reply ButtonReply

Sav

I’m off the waitlist! When do orders typically ship?

Reply ButtonReply

SDune

They have not shipped on time in months. Expect October’s box between late-Oct to mid-November. I’m still waiting on July’s replacement, August’s box, and September’s box.

Reply ButtonReply

Erin

I have never been more than a week or two behind. I usually expect it to come the third week of the month. Tracking is a joke though. Received my tracking email the day I got my box the last few months. If you havent received your box by the end of the month, I would think your box was lost/stolen.

Sav

Ugh, that does not make me feel good about signing up!

MissP

They start shipping around the 10th of the month

Reply ButtonReply

Misty

I get the box and barely use anything. I keep the box for the meaning of the box. To find little hems. Its only $21 a month. I pay more for a lip liner. I found like 5 things in the past 3 years i cant live withput and that i didnt already have. I get tired of people complaining on aocial media. I say of yoy dont like the color you got, go to the brands page and buy it. If you lile the formula and not the color, go buy it. People are so cheap and greedy. Tjeu expect way to much for $21. I think people need to stop expecting a sub box to fulfill tjeir maleup needs and wants. Take what you get. I see people go crazy over $21. Lol. I order makeuo at least 3 times week from Ulta, Sephira, etc i dont need the stuff to be perfect and personalized. Most of the time, I already jave the things they send. Stop whining. I hope they raise the price because of all the complaining.

Reply ButtonReply

Diana

If your were on the Waitlist check your email. YOu should have confirmation of October billing and gettin off the waitlist.

Reply ButtonReply

Lenya

Got my confirmation yesterday – thank you for the heads up, I had to search my junk folder for “boxycharm” and it was right there 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

amy

i dont think we are getting a pallett this month …

Reply ButtonReply

Randi

Man I really wanted a pallet again this month I thought we were supposed to get a pallet all the way up till December??

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

We are not. The CEO confirmed in a Facebook group that there will not be a pallet this month.

Reply ButtonReply

Toni

Weird considering he is the one that months ago said we would be getting a palette every month for the rest of the year , kind of dishonest but we’ll have to see what else is coming, I personally don’t really care for the over priced dr Brandt. Or maybe it’s that I’ve received six or seven of the smaller samples and they were basically empty! But I would never pay full price for it

jennifer

do you know what group? I would like to be updated on these announcements 🙂

Valerie

I signed up for the pallets this month. Did BOXYCHARM not state pallets through December?

Shek

Totally subscribed just to get Prosecco Pop haha. I am actually in need of an exfoliator as well so I’m excited about the Dr. Brandt product. So curious to see what else is in the box.

Reply ButtonReply

torres_alexia

Awww man the exfoliate item I got if from fabfitfun add on item for $19.00 I didn’t know we were getting a full size sample☹️. Oh well maybe I can swap it for something here. If anyone wants it I am more than willing to swap 😃

Reply ButtonReply

Lori

I love my Boxycharm! I’m so excited for this box and keeping my fingers crossed for the pressed highlighter cuz I have oily skin and can’t use liquid highlighters… I’m also happy about the Dr Brandt cuz I’ve only been with this or any sub for a few months now so I don’t have a lot of extra stuff built up (yet lol)

I dropped Birchbox this month and still have Ipsy & allure along with Boxycharm….I can always give anything I don’t use to my BFF 😊

Reply ButtonReply

Marilyn

I love boxycharm… all full size products… even if you only like one – you still save money…

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

I had to cancel didn’t fit into my budget miss Boxycharm. But I get Ipsy and birchbox for September this month. If their is a great palette I’ll have to fit it into my budget

Reply ButtonReply

torres_alexia

You know ebay and poshmark sometimes sell completely e boxes you can try to bargain with the seller or if you like a certain item of the box they have that to.

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

I had to cancel until my hours at work pick up or I find another job I’ll resubcribe when this happens. If the palette is incredible I’ll just stop buying something like junk food. I cancelled after I got September. I’ve been subscribed for years. I still get 2 Ipsy bags. I also went mad for a minute and I’m getting Birchbox October 2 box promo. I have cut back on Dollar Tree, Shop Miss A, Five Below And even Wish. I already miss Boxycharm. I’ll have to get my fix at Dollar Tree with a 5 dollar limit. My budget only always 45 dollars a month on misc spending.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

I am so excited!!! This is going to be a great box!

Reply ButtonReply

Gabby

If we sign up now, would we get the October box?

Reply ButtonReply

Jada

I just signed up and was put on the waitlist 😭😭😭

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

I signed up 2 days ago but am still on waitlist.
Was hoping I’d be taken off today…but alas, no.

Reply ButtonReply

Wendy B

That depends on whether or not the waitlist is open.

Reply ButtonReply

Sav

I signed up mid September and got off the waitlist today.

Chrystal

I’ve been with Boxycharm for almost 3 years, they never disappoint! I’m honestly not sure how they do it, somehow their boxes keep getting better 🖤

Reply ButtonReply

Bella01

Love you BoxyCharm…forever my queen of Boxes

Reply ButtonReply

Korey

So excited! Loving my BC!

Reply ButtonReply

sara

Im so excited for this month too! I just pray i get the becca powder highlight and not the liquid!

Reply ButtonReply

Deirdea

Me too!!!

Korey

Same. I am most excited to see if we get a palette, if maybe it’s one from Storybook Cosmetics. This theme will be amazing if it’s done right. I have been so excited for October- December!!!!

Jenai Rothnie

I might just subscribe this month 🙂 Tarte colors seem to go well with my skin tone, and I have a sample size of the lip paint stuff I got with a Sephora birthday present that I like. Plus I could use a good highlighter as the only one I have is too dark for my skin. The pore dermabrasion looks like a nice skincare product I would use as well.

Reply ButtonReply

Nicole Crawford

There is a wait list for Boxycharm. If you sign up now ot will probably be a few months before your off the list.

Reply ButtonReply

Sarah

Once again, disgustingly excited about this

Reply ButtonReply

Taylor

I cannot for the life of me understand some people. These are three HIGH end makeup names in a 21 dollar box and they’re “not impressed”????

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

I’m thinking of cancelling boxycharm. I’m never disappointed by the value in boxycharm but I haven’t been getting items that are useful for me. The value isn’t always there for me if I only use 1-2 items from every box. September was a good box for me. I’m happy with the lippie and became product spoilers and I think those two alone make it worth it to me. Not excited for the dr Brandt product as it has already made rounds in other boxes and I already have one I haven’t gotten around to using.

I’m also very concerned about the shipping problems with boxycharm. It has benne going on for months. Customer service has taken a nosedive. I’m worried every month that I will be one of the subscribers who doesn’t get my box.

Reply ButtonReply

Bella01

well stop worrying for one. Their still in business for two. just cancel if its not to your par. your one in a trillion

Christine

It isn’t that I’m “not impressed”, but just personally I was debating between buying brand-released holiday collections from September to December vs Boxycharm and decided on the former and cancelled Boxycharm after the August box. I just have a soft spot for holiday collections (especially since it will be just for the season) and if I got those and Boxycharm on top of all the makeup I already own, then I would really have no place to put all my makeup and it would just end up being product waste.

Reply ButtonReply

vanessa

I’m not impressed.

Those are products I wouldn’t use. October is why I canceled BC.

Not spending $5, much less $21 on stuff I can’t/won’t use regardless of brands. #NotSorry

P.S. They’re laden with chemicals. Just FYI

Reply ButtonReply

Bonnie

Try Vegan Cuts if you want a natural beauty sub. They have their monthly beauty box and their seasonal makeup box. I’ve discovered some lovely products from them.

Cat

I’m sorry, but when did Boxycharm become an organic beauty box? Or make promises of such? If that’s what you want, why subscribe to this sub?

Jackie

Everything you can breathe, see, ingest or touch is made up of chemicals. All matter, including us, is made of chemicals.

Wendy B

Unfortunately, some people are unpleasable.

Reply ButtonReply

Taylor

To clarify, I meant to mention, these were people on sub pages and facebook.

Reply ButtonReply

Roxy

Yeah. Seems a little weird that both Boxy and Ipsy have the EXACT SAME THEME word for word.

Reply ButtonReply

MissP

Right!

Reply ButtonReply

Bonnie

It’s October, and it’s a Halloween theme that still implies beauty…a witchy beauty.

Reply ButtonReply

Bella01

and….lol whats weird about it. I think its a cool theme.

Reply ButtonReply