ModCloth Stylish Surprise – Available Now + Coupon!

Seriously! I got a duplicate and the spiel “well it says in terms and conditions you can get duplicates… but i can give you a 1 time store credit.”

I told them I’ll never shop from them again (I really only jump on SS sales) if this is their policy going forward, so I’d really like a proper refund.

I did get my refund! But I’m sad that they may keep this policy around. We should boycott SS until they get their act together! What’ll they do when they have hundreds of the same dress lying around their warehouses?

At least the lady who worked with me in livechat said she’d pass on my comments…

I can not actually believe I got decent clothes and a few great items!

I asked for 1 top, 1 bottom and 4 dresses.

I got the top, a really pretty deep red formal tank top with a cute travel style print. It’s nice for work.

As for my bottoms, I got a long sleeved butterfly print romper!

1 dress is a gorgeous nude crochet but it’s tight on my bust.

The next dress is a bright blue, sexy formal dress that’s kind of lacy and requires a strapless bra. But it’s so fun. It’s lace up till the neck.

The next dress is everything you imagine when you think 1950’s Good Housekeeping and I love it. It’s high necked with a bow and has a big full skirt. The print is cream overlaid with colored, shimmery flowers.

The last dress I never want to take off. It’s blue and green. The top is green with little straps and the bottom is a blue ocean print.

I’m so delighted with the last dress that it was worth the cost of all 6 items.

Last time I got everything in 2xl and most the dresses were too large. The only thing out of 6 items worth salvaging was a cheap tank and a boring black dress.

This time I tried 1xl and a few dresses were small. The top is snug as well. But I’m still pretty happy. This is a first for me with Stylish Suprise. I wish they had a size 1 1/2 xl 🙂🙃

Huge bust for me. 3 duplicate dresses out of five total, and none are my style. 🙁 All size medium, but of course their sizing is different for each brand.

I got:

– Ritz and Wisdom dress by Lace&Mesh
– 3 of the Promising Polish Shirt dress by English Factory
– Respectfully Retro by Viola M

I chatted the CS rep, and they pointed out the Terms and Conditions and finally gave me a one-time courtesy store credit for the two extras. Yea, I don’t think I’m going to go for the SS ever again.

Well after seeing all the duplicates everybody was getting I was really nervous (because that sucks and I’m sorry that happened to you all). But mine came today and all 5 dresses were different! I got all in size 4x. I love 3 of them! 2 are not my color/style, but might work anyway. Here’s what I got:

-Posh Presence A-Line Dress in Ice – Currently $36.97 ORIG $119.99
https://www.modcloth.com/shop/sale-dresses/posh-presence-a-line-dress/150837.html

-Stay and Sway Midi Dress in Dove (gray) No longer avail ORIG RV $140
https://www.modcloth.com/shop/plus-size-fancy-clothing/stay-and-sway-midi-dress/150578.html

-Yours To Adore Midi Dress in Navy (No longer avail) Orig rV $80
https://www.modcloth.com/shop/hidden/yours-to-adore-midi-dress/151969.html

-Jacquard Darling Mini Dress (purple) (No longer avail) Orig RV $120
https://www.modcloth.com/shop/hidden/jacquard-darling-mini-dress/151257.html

-Sweet Sunday Midi Dress in Violet (no longer avail) Orig RV $80
https://www.modcloth.com/shop/hidden/sweet-sunday-midi-dress/150383.html

I’m pretty happy with these!! (Although I haven’t tried them on yet so fingers crossed)

So….they have no problem canceling a portion of my order (two outerwear), and then I get my box and I get three identical tops?! They couldn’t cancel two of them?! I emailed customer service and haven’t heard back. This is the worst Stylish Surprise I have ever been a part of, and I have done many.

All my accessories were dupes. Did anyone get an accessory other than a gold bag or straw hat? Just curious. I doubt I will ever order multiples again.

I just received my order of 5 of the SAME dress! This sale is a great idea but so badly executed. I understand that duplicates can happen, but 5!!!

I do feel like they used the Outerwear as a bait. I placed my order early – within the first 10-15 minutes of the sale. And it was cancelled. How few did they have? Did anybody get any Outerwear? If not, we are veering into the unethical area.

Both my outerwear orders were cancelled. So heartbroken 😔

Despite being a ModCloth customer for about 8 years now, I’ve never actually purchased a ‘Stylish Surprise’ so I’m pretty excited. While I would have loved to try a dress / pants / skirt, my measurements (32/28/40) would have made those options a hit or miss. I took the safer route and went with a top!

I got an email this morning canceling my order because they apparently got more orders than stock……..Okay.

FYI – I ordered 3 outerwear (2 s, 1 m) and they were all fully “in stock” at least an hour after I ordered.

Man, I wish I had seen that 30% off $100 coupon. I ended up getting $60 worth of stuff, but I could have spent $10 more and got $40 more of stuff. Oh wellll.

I told myself I wouldn’t do these anymore since last time was an all around bust, but I recently discovered Mercari and sold all my items that had been sitting for a profit. This time I snagged a swimsuit, 3 pair of shoes and 1 outerwear item. Fingers crossed I get some goodies I like!

Aaah that’s what I get for not reading; I jumped on the Accessories thinking jewelry was part of it. Well, I was hoping for a new necklace or bracelet but fingers crossed for something fun from Accessories.

I snagged Accessories, Outerwear, a Top, and Shoes. I’ve been burned on the dresses so I’m hoping trying a few new categories works out.

I took the plunge again after receiving 2 wedding dresses and a bridesmaid dress last time. I also got a huge tank top and an itchy sweater.

I can’t help myself! It’s like I’m in Vegas at the slot machines and this stylish surprise is going to be the jackpot!

I can’t wait until we all receive our items and share what we got.

Good luck everyone! May we all get well fitting, wonderful stuff ❤️

With the coupon code I couldn’t resist ordering! Thanks for it!
Wish I could’ve snagged some outerwear, but that’s ok!

I find it interesting that everything BUT the dresses are sold out. I wonder if people have given up on receiving a dress they will like/use, or if their stock in dresses was just through the roof.

Everything I would buy is out of stock, so better for my wallet! 😉

Last time I got three accessory items: sunglasses, blush and a make-up bag set.

And I received the ModCloth App notification for this sale …48 minutes ago. So much for that being useful!

How are shoes already sold out in all sizes??? Oh well:( I know I have too many shoes but still! I love their mystery bags for shoes

If we order swim, does anyone know if it comes with the whole suit? Or would we get just a top or bottom?

I am going to pass. Last time I did it and it was not too bad, but I end up with two coats and wedding dress. I live in CA and even coats are pretty, they are useless to me, so as wedding dress (unless ModCloth knows something that I dont). I got few shoes as well, one pair was very pretty but totally unwearable for me. It has 4 inch heels, but I am 5’11 already. Another pair of shoes was so small, I could not even put it on my feet. The bottom line, yes, you can get very nice pieces, and I did, which I wear, but I would rather take this money and buy 2-3 pieces that I really like then receive 10 pieces that I am forced to wear to make my money worth.

I saw the MSA posting as soon as it went up, and even then I was too late to get in on the jewelry and home surprises. Still, because I usually end up stuck in “sold out” land, I went a little nuts on accessories, dresses and shoes. By the time I applied the coupon code, I was spending something like $14 for a dress and $7 for a pair of shoes. For that price, even if I hate them, I’ll wear them.

Are the items from the current season or clearance from last season?

I clicked right when this post went up and Apartment and Jewelry were already sold out. I think they have like 10 of each. Does anyone know if “Accessories” includes handbags?