Facebook PixelOur Subscription Box Favorites for September! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Our Subscription Box Favorites for September!

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanOct 1, 2017 | 6 comments

2017_01_Subscription-box-favorites

We're starting a new monthly post highlighting our favorite discoveries from subscription boxes! Here are our favorite items from the past month:

Jess's Favorite:

Morphe Me September 2017

Morphe Me September 2017

The Item: Morphe E6 Premium Flat Buffer

The Cost: $15.00

From: LiveGlam MorpheMe Brush Club (Coupon: No coupon required – just use this link to activate the deals:

  • Monthly Subscription – FREE brush with your first month + free shipping to the US
  • 6-Month Subscription – 10% Off and a Free Brush + free shipping to the US
  • Annual Subscription – Get 1 Month Free and a Free Brush+ free shipping to the US)

Why I love it: I've been reaching for this soft bristled brush daily since receiving it! It's great for buffing in tinted moisturizer or foundation, and I also love it for cream blush and highlighter.

Read more reviews by Jess!

Ragan's Favorite:

Cat Lady Box September 2017 Cat Subscription Box

Cat Lady Box September 2017 Cat Subscription Box

The Item: Boinks Bamboozler

The Cost: $5.99

From: Cat Lady Box

Why I Love It: My cats had a lot of fun with this and I got some pretty good pictures. Good cat pictures are basically all it takes to make an item my new favorite thing.

Read more reviews by Ragan!

Nich's Favorite:

Onyxbox September 2017 Women of Color Subscription Box

Onyxbox September 2017 Women of Color Subscription Box

The Item: Honey & The Moon No. 10 Parfum

The Cost: $30.00

From: We Are Onyx (Coupon: Save $9 off a 3-month subscription (ONYXBOXH320)! (Regularly $69) or save $12 off a 6-month subscription (ONYXBOXH619)! (Regularly $126))

Why I Love It: I have been wearing this fragrance since I received it in my September box and I love it! The scent is lightweight, it reminds me of fall, and the aroma of sandalwood stands out more than the other notes of sweet honey, sugared violet, and jasmine. This has become my signature scent for the season.

Read more reviews by Nich!

Rob's Favorite:

Dollar Shave Club September

Dollar Shave Club September

The Item: Wanderer Calming Body Cleanser

The Cost: $9.50

From: Dollar Shave Club (Coupon: Get your first Starter Set for $5 plus free shipping!, no coupon required, just use this link)

Why I love it: This is my new go-to body wash after a long day; the amber and lavender scent is very soothing and my skin doesn’t feel dry or over-exfoliated, just clean and moisturized. A little bit also goes a long way in the shower; so even though this is a little more expensive than I’m used to, I don’t need to use a lot and I shouldn’t have to reorder anytime too soon.

Read more reviews by Rob!

Taryn's Favorite:

Bluum August 2017 Mom and Kid Subscription Box

The Item: Moluk Plui Rain Ball

The Cost: Value $13.99

From: Bluum (Coupon: For a limited time only, save 30% off your first box with a 6 or 12-month Bluum subscription. Just use this link to create your account and the deal should auto apply, if not use coupon code Share30 to get the deal!)

Why I love it: This bath toy was designed in Switzerland and is made from a durable vinyl that is BPA and latex free. While this might seem like just another bath time toy, it is meant to demonstrate basic physical principles by filling it up, covering the nozzle, and then removing your finger from the nozzle to see the water rush out. When I first received this item, I didn’t think my son would really understand or enjoy this item. I was wrong though! This is a toy that he plays with nightly during bath time, and we have even started working with him more on how it works. To see the enjoyment and understanding in his eyes is amazing! I am so happy we received this little learning item!

Read more reviews by Taryn!

Jessica's Favorite:

Hoot for Kids September 2017 Activities Subscription Box

The Item: Petit Collage Ice Pops Memory Game

The Cost: $14.00

From: Hoot for Kids

Why I Love It: We love playing matching games in our family. No difficult rules to remember, easy enough for my three-year-old and still engaging for my six-year-old. This version with beautiful glittery popsicles is just so bright and cheery that we all love it!

Read more reviews by Jessica!

Lacey's Favorite:

Amazon STEM Kids Subscription Box September 2017 Review - Magformers

Amazon STEM Kids Subscription Box September 2017 Review - Magformers

Amazon STEM Kids Subscription Box September 2017 Review - Magformers Squares

The Subscription Box: Magformers Basic 30 Piece Set

The Cost: Value $32.83 (MSRP: $49.99)

From: Amazon Stem Toy Club

Why I love it: This toy has quite simply become one of my 2.5-year-old son's favorite things to play with since we received it! I honestly thought it might quickly get demoted to a desk toy for mom, but it seems to be a toy he turns to often when he wants some quiet play time. He sticks the pieces on the fridge, he builds little houses, he uses his toy crane to pick up the pieces. And: it's not messy, it's easy to clean up and stores in a small amount of space, and if one does get left out on the floor, it doesn't hurt if you step on it. 😉 Probably my favorite thing we've received from Amazon STEM so far!

Read more reviews by Lacey!

Désirée's Favorite:

Sew Sampler Farmers Market September 2017 Craft and DIY Subscription Box

Sew Sampler Farmers Market September 2017 Craft and DIY Subscription Box

The Item: Moda Fabrics Matchbox Quilt Kit #7

The Cost: $13.98

From: Sew Sampler

Why I love it: This tiny quilt was my favorite project this month. I've never made a full quilt before, so I enjoyed working through the process and seeing what techniques are involved for each stage. This was a fun project to complete in one evening and I learnt a lot about quilting by making it. I'd love to try the other variations in their line of matchbox quilts. 

Read more reviews by Désirée!

Nicole's Favorite:

Nordstrom Trunk Club September 2017 Women's Plus Clothing Subscription Box

Nordstrom Trunk Club September 2017 Women's Plus Clothing Subscription Box

The Item: Bell Sleeve Shift with Flounce by Eliza J

The Cost: $158 ($133 after $25 stylist fee discount is applied)

From: Nordstrom Trunk Club

Why I love it: This dress evokes witchy Stevie Nicks meets late 60’s go-go dancer vibes. I usually don’t like bell sleeves, but these flouncy sleeves drape in such a dramatically gorgeous way. I just wanted to twirl in it with “Gold Dust Woman” blaring on repeat. The cost is a bit high, but the dress is so stunning and well-made that you will want to pencil in special occasions for an excuse to wear it! It is a real investment piece.

Read more reviews by Nicole!

Liz's Favorite:

The Item: Slow North Rosemary Lemon Soy Candle – 2 oz

The Cost: Value $9

From: Inspired Book Club Box (Coupon: Use coupon code FREEGIFT to get a free gift with your first box!)

Why I love it: I sample so many candles thanks to subscription boxes, and I like most of them, but I LOVE this one! It’s made with soy wax and it is scented only with natural essential oils! No artificial fragrance!

And the lemon scent is so incredibly fresh! The hint of rosemary is a perfect addition, too. (I've already bought more candles from Slow North after sampling this!)

Read more reviews by Liz!

What do you think of our favorites for September? And what were your favorite discoveries?

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

6 comments

KimberlyB

This sure was a month for kids toys, including the fur kids!

My fave was the ipsy x Colourpop Lippie Stix. I loved the product already, and this one is so womderfully pink!

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

Holy crap Nicole, that dress is perfection!

Reply ButtonReply

A.Gail Owens

I have issues with getting some monthly started regardìng. I am just a small time gal, looking for someone that might notice me & my sparklers. With her style, I bet she is a BareMinial gal.

Reply ButtonReply

Cristina

I am so confused…

Reply ButtonReply

JA

What the????

Reply ButtonReply

Brandy

Hahahhah – thanks for the laugh! 🙂