Facebook PixelPOPSUGAR Must Have Box October 2017 Box Spoiler #2 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

POPSUGAR Must Have Summer 2020 Box Full Spoilers!

POPSUGAR Must Have Box October 2017 Box Spoiler #2

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanOct 5, 2017 | 92 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have
3.9 overall rating
530 Ratings | 71 Reviews

We have the another spoiler for the October 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have box!

Each box will include:

Perpetual Shade Dream On Sleep Mask - Value $39

Having trouble sleeping? The Perpetual Shade Dream On Cotton Lux Sleep Mask can help! Made from soft cotton fabric and a wide comfortable elastic band, the Dream On Cotton Lux Sleep Mask will help you catch some z's!

This mask is oversized which helps block out light from hindering your sleep. The wide elastic band creates a snug fit without suffocating your head. You may not even realized you're wearing it at all! Each sleep mask comes with a clear plastic travel case.

I'm SO pumped about this spoiler! I wear a sleep mask almost every night, and this is such an upgrade. It is so comfortable!

Check out POPSUGAR's Tips for starting your morning feeling more refreshed and awake for additional insight on both spoiler items, too.

What do you think of the newest spoiler?

And in case you missed our earlier spoiler from today:

FlashPatch Restoring Night Eye Gels 5-Pack - Value $20

POPSUGAR sent me this spoiler item early so I can answer any questions you might have!

Prepare for dreamland with some pre-bedtime pampering. These under eye patches feature a powerful combination of retinol and peptides to nourish the delicate area. Let the cooling gels sit under your eyes for five minutes and wake up to brightened and refreshed skin.

At first when I saw these I thought I'd have to wear them overnight but fortunately, that is not the case! You just need to wear them 5 minutes before bed, let the excess serum absorb once you remove them, and you are good to go! I love a nice relaxing bedtime routine, and these were a perfect addition. They left my skin feeling hydrated and I had no issues of the eye gels slipping off like I have had with some other brands.

What do you think of the first spoiler? 

Here are the themes in case you missed them:

  • Dreamer
  • Relaxation
  • Cozy

If you haven't signed up yet, use coupon code MUSTHAVE5 to save $5 off of your first box!

Check out all of our POPSUGAR Must Have reviews to see what you can expect from this subscription!

Starting at $75.00
Active Deal
Get $20 off your first box!
Use Coupon Code MSA20
Subscribe Now
POPSUGAR Must Have is a quartely lifestyle subscription box curated by the editors at POPSUGAR. Each box features their "must have" products for beauty, fashion, home, food, fitness and more. Every box has a value of $250 +!
Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

92 comments

Kc

Full spoilers w pics on the forum.

Reply ButtonReply

Kelli

Couldn’t find them….

Reply ButtonReply

Robin

I couldn’t find them either.

Anna

Not impressed with the spoilers although they are both items I use. I cancelled my sub before the Sept box and didn’t regret missing that box and so far don’t regret not getting this one. That said, like pretty much everyone else…. if that throws pop up in a spoiler I’m 100% about it!

Reply ButtonReply

Sandi Baete

Totally hoping for the blanket that’s in the pic! That would definitely fit the theme!!

Reply ButtonReply

Mattie

My Box came today and it does have a small travel blanket in it but not the one pictured. It’s a small travel sized matching black & white striped pillow and blanket set from the company Jack + Lucy.

Reply ButtonReply

Kelli

Can you let us know all the contents of the box Please……

Margaret

my box finally shipped and it seems that they upgraded their shipping stuff! and now they go thru usps so it doesn’t take a year and a half to arrive! hopefully!

Reply ButtonReply

Tanya

I don’t use a sleep mask, but I’m willing to try one. I DO know how much I love the eye patches. I have purchased them the last 2 add-ons for FFF, and I have 3 boxes in my cabinet. I use them when I need a freshen-up (they leave my eye area looking a bit plumped temporarily) or at night, when my eyes are tired and I still want to play on the computer. It makes my eyes feel cool and nice, and feels like a little pick-me-up.

Reply ButtonReply

AmyM

I’m always amazed at how the simplest-seeming items can generate so much controversy. That said, I’m excited about both spoilers. My skin has loved all the Patchology masks I’ve tried so far, and I have some major dark circles, so I’m looking forward to trying these. I’ve only ever occasionally used a sleep mask, but I’m willing to give it a go again; probably for naps. I have no issues sleeping through the night but I can’t nap to save my life! Maybe this will help.

Reply ButtonReply

Veronica H

Blast it. I have a great sleep mask, the kind that doesn’t sit on your eyes so it doesn’t potentially tug on them. This is just meh for me.
Oh and my anti-aging, no tugging, sleep mask was less than $20.

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

Glad you agree with me!

Reply ButtonReply

Dawner44

Hope the cozy is the blanket!

Reply ButtonReply

Nich

How is this worth $39.00 that seems a bit high.

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

I’ve only slept on silk pillowcases since I was 25..my mom told me to. LOL
I can’t sleep on anything else..and yes, it makes your hair look great.

Reply ButtonReply

x

YES!! Home run on both items for me! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Kelli

It looks like this box is going to sell out….I got an email saying only 500 left

Decisions…decisions

Reply ButtonReply

Wendy B

They said there were only 500 LE boxes left too. That was like two weeks ago and they’re still available.

Mattie

This amuses me because everyone said that it wouldn’t be in the box since it was in the photo. PSMH keeping everyone on their toes and switching it up (insert AndyD mic drop here)

Reply ButtonReply

Wendy B

To those of you who’ve used these eye gels, are they good? And how do they compare to the Babor gels that were in the August Glossybox? I bought them during the FFF ads on sale but haven’t tried them yet. Was debating on putting them up for swap but if they’re good and I like the other items yet to be revealed I might grab this box.

Reply ButtonReply

Luna

I agree with amyr… they’re very nice, but extremely delicate. When adjusting, I think it’s best done by pushing them around until you find the perfect fit rather than grabbing an edge and pulling them like I did, which kept ripping them.

Reply ButtonReply

amyr

OMG I LOVE these gels! I am addicted to them. I keep them in my fridge and always stop up at Fab Fit Fun’s add on sale. They feel amazing. They are very easy to tear but if you handle them carefully you will love these. I like these better than my Estee Lauder eye patches.

Reply ButtonReply

Wendy B

Thank you! I think I’ll give them a try tonight.

Lauren

I love the eye gels!!! I will swap for all of them!!!

Can you buy a second box to the same home? I think this would make a great gift. I love the spoilers!!!!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Taren

Loving both spoilers so far! Keep up the good work PS!

Reply ButtonReply

Danielle

I think this is the first time I’ve ever seen one of the items from the box actually end up being one of the items that they show in the Theme picture. Sooooo hopefully that means that chunky knit throw is item #3??? Wishful thinking, I know. 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

KM

I hope you are right….

Reply ButtonReply

Nicole

Considering these first two spoilers are pretty small in size and weight, there’s plenty room for that throw! Fingers crossed lol

Reply ButtonReply

Jacki

I’ll have to try the block out mask on an airplane and for migraines. Although one I can blink in would be better for migraines. I passed on buying the eyegels from fff because I don’t have bags or dark circles ( no haters 😂 I have plenty of other problem areas), but I still really want to try them. I think I have a mask addiction. I can’t stop using the FAB bouncy mask.

Reply ButtonReply

Anna

Is haters still a word people use? I’m obsessed with that FAB mask too 😍

Reply ButtonReply

Sarah

Bouncy mask is my favorite too!

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

I love that mask! I’m addicted to it…I make myself use it only twice a week…its great..!!!
Glad to hear others like it too!

Kelli

Woo hoo….I am liking this box! May have to splurge…..will be so freaking awesome if the next spoiler is a lux throw or satin pillow case:-) Pretty please PS

Reply ButtonReply

Max

Well, a $40 sleep mask! I can put it in my $40 pink pineapple case 🙂

Seriously I love eye masks, and use one when I travel with my mom – she likes to sleep with a light on and I need total darkness. I tested a few that didn’t quite work for me, until I found one that has a wee bit of space (it contours/bumps out on the inside) so your eyes can open with the mask on. Otherwise, it is very uncomfortable. I look forward to testing this one, but I don’t see any kind of contour in the pics. Fingers crossed it’s a good one though!

Reply ButtonReply

Ariana

I am not interested in this item. I am a person who sometimes uses a sleep mask (my husband works a different schedule). I use a Bucky Eye mask that leaves a gap for your eyes to properly blink. It costs less than $15, and works really well. I use it so much that I actually have had to replace it a few times…and it’s totally worth it.

That being said, there are people who will want or like this item. But this isn’t making me want to buy the box.

Reply ButtonReply

Estalyn

I totally agree with you, Ariana. I love Bucky eye masks. And I can find them at TJMaxx or Marshall’s for $5 or less. I have eyelash extensions so I need eye masks that are molded so my lashes don’t get smooshed.

I also am not digging this box. If anyone wants to buy the eye mask or under eye patches, hit me up! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Donna

The Bucky Eye Mask is the best!

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

Bucky eye mask? Where would I find it if you don’t mind ..sounds good to me.

Bella01

wow, great box…I love the eye Mask for sleeping. Great idea!

Reply ButtonReply

Jerilynn

perpetual shade masks are great! I got one in the Arianna Huffington quarterly box several years ago. It was silk and I love it! I managed to trade for another but would happily swap if someone wants to trade their mask. I wish Luxor would do a silk mask from perpetual shade in their box.

Reply ButtonReply

Bella01

Exactly,I love them..I;m still using my Silk Pillow cases From PS. My hair has never been healthier. Now when I get compliments on how healthy my hair looks, I swear it’s the Silk Pillow case.

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

Bella..its the silk pillow case..!!!
It is good for skin and hair..I.wake up with shiny silky hair and I know its the dry conditioner every night.💜

Pandora

I will trade!
Damn.
I’d love those PJs and blankie!

Reply ButtonReply

JAnn

This sleep mask will be perfect for when we camp. Our camper has a skylight above the master BR and the sun usually wakes me up really early even with a filter over it.

Reply ButtonReply

Stefanie

Not sure if you have a Camping World near you, but you can even order online from them, skylight cushions. They look like square,thick pillows that fit perfectly in the skylight and they are sorta fuzzy. They completely block the light out and are easlily removable. http://www.campingworld.com/shopping/item/vent-cushion-with-strap/106744
I have them on all 5 of my skylights in my camper…love em!

Reply ButtonReply

Nancy L

These sleep mask are the worse. First they give me headaches so I wouldn’t buy it for a penny let alone $39. Is Popsugar out of their minds? They must be and as far as these eye pads I don’t use as I’ve must have used every kind out there and they don’t work. I have to say I’ve been a member since 2013 and this is the worse box so far. The other items better be a lot better or they are going to start losing customers again!!!

Reply ButtonReply

amyr

Have you tried these patches??????

They are the best I’ve ever used!!!!!

And we have not even seen the rest of the box so I am passing judgement until I see more.

Reply ButtonReply

Renee

I assume you mean the worst box for you, not in general, right? You must really hate those two items! I happen to love Patchology and don’t hate the sleep mask, so it is shaping up as a better than average box for me. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

Absolutely!

Reply ButtonReply

Notaprincess

ALMOST joined PSMH this month. SO SO glad I didn’t!

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

I know!! I don’t like this box..but why not windchimes….led fairy lights. Etc..
Last 2 boxes were good…but really? A sleep mask? I’m glad Liz does good reviews.. I’ll try the gel thingies.. But I have sensitive eyes and I don’t need bags under them.

Reply ButtonReply

amyr

Windchimes in October and fairy lights???????

I am glad PS is keeping this one with the October theme!

amyr

Pandora these do not leave you with bags under your eyes! They are great! I am 63 years old and I have NEVER had a problem with bags under my eyes from this brand of eye gels.

Why do you even sub to PopSugar? You seem to hate everything!