Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I just got my box, it was delayed. Is there anyone left that wanted the Ofra Z palette and blush instead of the highlighter palette. Still in sealed package, blush says Winter Rose Glow.
I can send on Monday in the original Boxycharm box so it won’t be damaged. Crossing my fingers….I was afraid it would arrive too late.
Reply
Victoria
Can anyone tell me how to check your box decisions ! I got off the waitlist today!!!!! I’m so excited to get the February box!!! Hoping for the naked pallets
Reply
Flora
Hi all, I have the Ofra and would like the highlighter instead, any trades?
Reply
Rhiannon
Oh, I had the .06 and 6x6x6…so, my hopes were high. 🙁
Reply
Rhiannon
SUPER ticked off. All I was excited for was a gosh darn lip scrub and I got the “shimmer powder”, smh!!! I did get the highlighting palette, though. So, that’s going up for swap to anyone who’s interested.
Reply
Lisa
Do you still have the highlighting palette? I just got my box and am looking to trade the Ofra palette and blush.
Reply
Tanya
Is anyone else having a problem with the promo code for CoverFx?
Reply
Sara
I got variation #1 :
Crown Pro Trio Brush Set – Retail value $29.99
CoverFX Shimmer Veil Amethyst – Retail Value $28
Ofra Cosmetics Pop-Up Palette with Blush
PUR Lips Plumping Lip Exfoliator – Retail Value $17
Vintage Cosmetics Smokey Eye Pencil – Retail Value $21
— Keeping the eye pencil, Orfa, and brush set. I don’t use any plumping lip anything and won’t use the CoverFX, so those will go into the donate bin.
Still – those 3 products are worth the cost of the box, although it seems like such a little amount of blush for the palette (this will probably go in my suitcase for travel).
Reply
Redhed36
Ok… So according to the card in the box I got variation 2 but according to this article I got variation 3. Naked palette, cover fx, brushes, eyeliner, pur lip exfoliant. I am happy. Somethings I won’t use and some I will. I have a 21yr old daughter so it will get used
Reply
SunnyT
I’m pretty sure it was listed wrong on here. I thought I had variation 2 because of what I saw on here, but went back to look at my card and it says variation 3, which included the Seraphine lip buffer.
For anyone interested in buying the box for the Naked pallet plus the Seraphine, you’re looking for Variation 3.
Reply
Toni
My box came and my card says it’s V-3 but mine has the seraphine lip butter in it. And let me say it’s wonderful! It smells like hubba bubble gum lol most of you won’t know what that is but it was yummy gum
Reply
Cheryl Beato
I would love to trade my Ofra AND the z-palette for the Naked highlighter palette if anyone is interested 🙂
Reply
Jessica Agee
I’m pretty sure I’m getting the Ofra palette & I really want the naked palette and purle glitter. Mine weight is 0.8. Everyone so far got it with that weight. I hope I can get someone to trade.
Reply
Jessica Agee
*purple
Reply
Taylor Lynn
My box is the 0.8 lb and 8x5x2.
I really hope it’s not the Ofra! If it is the ofra and anyone wants to trade boxes, let me know! I really want the lemon scrub, but I’m willing to trade my box for any beside the Ofra!
Reply
Taylor Lynn
8x5x2 box, weighing .8
I really hope I don’t get the Ofra box. If I do get the Ofra box and anyone wants to trade whole boxes, I’d love to have box 2 or 3!
Reply
Julie
I got variatiin 1, bummer, so disappointing. The coverfx is a glitter bomb with tons of fallout. I had glitter halfway down my face within an hour of putting it on. Having a crappy day so I went for a walk and saw my ex with his new gf. Ugh, just had to vent.
Reply
Jessica Agee
Ugh really! So disappointing. Sorry hun, it sux seeing an X let alone with new girlfriend. Hope tomorrow is a better day sweetie!
Reply
Julie
Thank you kind stranger, my favorite part of this sub is people like you 🙂
Redhed36
When it rains it poors.
Reply
Rebecca McChesney
I got the worst variation, got the Ofra pallete, which comes with 1 small pan of blush, yet another black eyeliner, the lip exfoliant, which I will use, and the shimmer veil, which is very pretty. Am very disappointed, really wanted the highlighter palette, will happily trade the Ofra palette and the eyeliner.
Reply
Christine H.
Does anyone want to swap your Naked Highlighter Palette for my Ofra Magnetic thingie? I have absolutely no use for the Ofra thing 🙁
Reply
kat
I am extremely happy with this month’s Boxycharm! I received variation #2 and this was my 5th Boxycharm- and it’s the first box where I kept everything! I honestly would not have been happy with box #1 because I don’t use single shadows, definitely was crossing my fingers there!
Reply
MicheleDeG
I received variation #4. I was hoping for the Ofra palette as I can never seem to get one in swaps. I’m going to list my eyeliner and glitter. Still a great deal for the price as always.
Reply
Em
Girl, you got a great box! Im crossing my fingers for that variation.
Reply
Alyssa
I would love to trade you the OFRA palette for your highlighter palette!
Reply
Jannati
I just unsubscribed after seeing next month’s spoiler. Don’t want anymore eyeshadow palettes.
Reply
Crystal
If anyone gets box variation 2 and plans on getting rid of/ selling it all let me know. I’d rather get everything from one person if I can.
Reply
Lesli
If anyone wants to trade and get the naked highlighter palette let me know, I got the naked set and I won’t use it. Even if you have something from a past box… hit me up lesligresholdt @ scbglobal . net.
Reply
Rebecca McChesney
I’ll trade you the Ofra thing and the eyeliner.
Reply
Sue
Anyone else just now get notice that their box’s shipping label has finally been created? I usually have my box by this time of month, and they haven’t even actually put it on the mail yet, which means I won’t have it till sometime late next week. No explanation as to the delay or anything.
Reply
SunnyT
I received my box today variation 2 which included the Naked pallet and Seraphine botanicals lip buffer. My box measurements were 6x6x6 and weighed 0.6. This was the box variation I had hoped for although the Z pallet wouldn’t have broken my heart. I really do feel bad for those who didn’t get what they wished for. I have felt that disappointment before so I understand. By the way I was billed on the 4th and received variation 2.
Reply
Chrystal
I’m hoping for the same variation. My box has these exact dimensions and is currently out for delivery today 🤗
Reply
SunnyT
Yay Crystal! My box was bulging a bit with two clear stickers. The Seraphine Bontanicals lip scrub comes in a bigger than I expected package. I think they could have used a larger box for variation 2.
Good luck!
Jackie S
I was one of the ones hoping for the Highlighter palette, but ended up with the OFRA. I guess you win some, you lose some. If anyone reading this would like to swap, find me on IG Jackiesinger89 🙂
Reply
Drucilla
I will trade with somebody I want the glitter!
Reply
Summer
Me, I will.
Reply
Sandra
Oh, here we go again. As usual, as soon as there are several variations- I get the awful, cheap, unusable one. That’s why I canceled ipsy (people got it cosmetics and urban decay and I got the balm. barf) and Glossy box ( the fiasco) and now boxy charm. I am going to cancel.
Who, in the love of god, would want glitter??? body glitter? like we used in the 90’s when we were dressing up to go clubbing. If I wanted glitter I could buy it at a dollar store! I cant believe some people get the Seraphine lip scrub while I got the glitter. It makes me so mad! that is a HUGE variation! unacceptable!!
From 5 products, I will only use the brushes. I have no use for that naked palate, or the cover Fx, or the glitter. What a waste. Only 3 months in and already so dissapointed. I joined the wait-list after boxy sent out the 90$ full size Dr. Brandt scrub. And I get dollar store glitter. SMH.
Reply
Em
I totally agree with you. Glitter? I mean, Come on!! Imo, because they are not a personalized service, it would be in boxycharm’s best interest to send out One amazing box, one variation for everyone who subs. I know some months they have done just that and people seemed happier.
Reply
RoguesEn3D
Sandra, did you receive the Naked palette? I will gladly trade the z palette and even the blush for the Naked palette. I have them listed together. I’d throw in the PUR plumping exfoliator too, if you’d like it.
Reply
Kimberly A King
I will trade if she wont :O) Mess me Mavacan @ comcast.net
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.