Boxycharm vs GlossyBox vs BeautyFix – February 2018

How are you calculating the value of the Glossybox? How are there 4 full size items? The tweezers and the pencil, sure. But the lotion and body wash? When did you ever buy a body lotion that small? no, no, no. They sent out samples. GB has been declining in value and quality, and you know that..

Related comment: I love the cost breakdown, but I think MSA doesn’t have a good way of calculating the value breakdown when boxes send out samples like this (it looks like you calculate it as if it was a full size item). Happy to help with that math if you want!

I like boxycharm and beauty fix more than glossy, i wish next month you include lola box too as it is almost the same level with boxycharm now. Thanks for your efforts so we can know which the best

Boxycharm❤❤❤

I love that Pur lip exfoliater. I put it on before I start my makeup routine, rub it in, let it sit until last and when I wipe it off I get some decent, natural looking plumping. It’s also hella hydrating. Let me say, if you’re looking to get Kylie Jenner lips out of this, you will be disappointed but if you’re looking for natural looking enhancement this is a good product for that. The effect lasted about 3 hrs on me and I really liked it. The best part is that it doesn’t hurt like other plumping products can.

I also loved the eyeliner from vintage. It’s the first pencil I’ve found that works for itchy, watery allergy eyes. I put in an order for 50. 10 for my kits and the other 40 as giveaway products for clients looking for what this formula offers.

The shimmer veil is pretty. Bought the rest of the collection and will probably go through it all during prom season. Glitter is always, always a big deal when it comes to prom looks. I already know these girls are going to be over the moon for it.

I’ve always liked Crown brushes so those were nice to get. You can never have too many brushes. Always love it when boxy sends more. I will definitely use them. It saves me from having to wash brushes. My shoebox for dirty brushes is getting full so it’s getting close to time for a wash day. I’m dreading it. It’s going to take at least 4 hours…maybe I’ll use it as a teachable moment in brush care for my niece. She’s 16 and aspires to be a makeup artist. We’re going to put her to work this summer and let her get her feet wet, with supervision of course. I think one of her responsibilities should be brush washes. You gotta crawl before you can walk! 😋 That and I really just hate to wash my brushes.

The only thing I was meh about was the Ofra palette but that’s because I have a ton of z palettes already and I didn’t need another. But I can see where others would enjoy it. I let my niece pick the pans that she wanted and filled it up for her. She’s happy about it and I’m glad it’s being used.

I like the beautyfix box better. The products are mostly great skincare that are truly good for skin, without perfume, alcohol and ingredient that are bad for skin. I usually only like half of the stuff in boxycharm. I hardly ever like stuff in glossybox somehow.

This was my 1st month skipping beautyfix but beautyfix & boxy are my favorites oh and I’m really enjoying allure. I’ve received 3 boxes so far & i canceled ipsy and Sephora back in dec. if I do another one, I’d chose Sephora

I was rather pleased with Glossybox this month. I haven’t yet received my Boxycharm but if I get that OFRA contraption rather than the Naked palette, I think I’m done. I’d like to have the lip buffer over the lip plumper but that’s not a deal breaker. The OFRA palette is doody despite the retail value.

Boxycharm!!!!!! 😁