Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Galentine’s POPSUGAR Must Have Mystery Boxes FULL SPOILERS!
The Products: A cozy night in with your besties can be the perfect cure for the cold-weather blues. Luxuriate in self-care at home with our Girls' Night In Box, which features previous products from recent and past Must Have boxes.
Full Spoilers:
Jack + Lucy Pillow and Blanket Set - Value $49.99 (October 2017 Box)
The Products: The Girls' Night Out box is the kit you need to sparkle from head to toe. It features previous favorites from recent and past Must Have and Limited Edition boxes, so you can look your best all night long.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Hi everyone! Looking to trade items from the girls night in box for the bracelet and/or le metier lippie in girls night out #2. rachelnanny at hotmail. I tried to swap, but I’m having trouble setting up my swapping profile. Thanks!
Reply
Joanna
I’d be interested in swapping both the AB cuff and Métier lippie joannanyc at gmail.
Reply
Heather K
Can anyone tell me what their GNO #2 weighed? Mine was delivered today but I won’t be home until the 14th. I hate waiting! Haha!
Reply
Liz
Mine was 4.5 lbs and I got GNO #2 but I was also missing the Smith and Cult eye pallet. I really wanted that necklace and poncho in GNO #1. Anyone want to trade? The AB cuff is up for grabs (and anything else) email me at ElizabethAnneFey at gmail dot com.
Reply
Esther
4.5 lbs, but it was missing the Smith and Cult pallet
Reply
Jacki
Received GNO today. Promptly wrote popsugar how angry I am that they recycled their unsellable LE box for $95. And yay, if I want to collect my final prepaid box, I have to send them more $$$. Which they’ve never bothered to disclose to me.
Looking forward to GNI. The glasses and bath products make that worthwhile. I have lost count of the number of pehr runners I have, but they definitely outnumber my swans!
Reply
Kelli
I received my boxes today and want to compile a box from the two if anyone is interested please let me know? I also have a lot of other things.
kelli2703 at gmail dot com
Reply
Gigi
My GNI box has been stuck in Sparks, NV since Sunday. Anyone else’s box stuck in a fedex facility somewhere?
Reply
Lacy
Hi! I received my GNO box yesterday and got the first version. I already have the necklace and was really hoping for the cuff from the second variation. If anybody wants to swap the necklace I have for the cuff, please let me know!
Reply
Nancy
Mine is also 5.1 lbs. Fingers crossed for GNO 2.
If it’s 1, I am open to selling some things in it.
Reply
Nancy
Well, I wanted version 2 of GNO but got version 1. I already have both the necklace and the poncho.
Reply
Nancy
Well, I wanted version 2 of GNO but got version 1. I already have both the necklace and the poncho. I’m certainly open to trade.
Reply
Kristin
I got GNO 2, but it weighed 4.5 lbs. I am missing the smith and cult pallet though.
Reply
Judy
Me too :(. They always forget to include a thing or 2 in mine. Sigh.
Esther
Mine was missing the pallet as well 😞….I emailed, hope to hear something from then this week
Jacki
Definitely email them so they can send you one.
Val
My GNO 1 was 5.3 lbs so you should have variation 2. 🙂
Reply
Jacki
That would make me so happy! I think I’ll have to wait until Monday to know for sure. Hopefully more people will post information while I wait and wait
Val
Just got my GNI & GNO boxes! ❤️ I was hoping for GNO 1 and got it. Haven’t subscribed to PS before so the items are all new for me, no dupes. 😍
Reply
Kelli
Hi Val,
Can you please tell me what your GNO box weighed?
Reply
Val
5.3 lbs
sher_w
If anyone does not want their Girl’s Night In box, I will buy it and pay shipping (darn it but work gets in the way sometimes). I’m at swasilow at gmail dot com. Thank you!
Reply
Taylor
I really like my GNI box, but because I’m a college student living in a tiny apartment, I doubt I’ll use a lot of it. If anyone wants it for the $45 and cost of shipping it to you, let me know.
tayb76 at gmail dot com
Reply
Ann
Yeah, mine’s going up for sale for the price I paid(tax included) and shipping.
Reply
Irsah
Hey, Ann, l’m also interested in the box, let me know if you still have it.
Melissa
still available, Ann?
email me melissaanddanny at gmail dot com
My tracking came through too and maybe the placemats and runner are pushing the gni theme, but I’m glad there is no Faris book and no candles.
Reply
Nicole
Just got tracking for GNI box! Coming from CA and 9.2 lbs. Way to be on top of it popsugar!
Reply
Val
Just got my tracking info too! Yay! That was quick. 😊
Reply
AmyM
Hmmmm…I think they took some liberties on the theme with the GNI with the placemats, table runner and notepad, but overall it’s a good box and I’m not sorry I went for it. The GNO boxes look pretty great; especially for people who weren’t regular subscribers the last few years.
Reply
Janet
I use those placemats and white pencils to draw – randomly each month. Then at the end of the year, it may (or may not) be fun to look back at the events of my year and the drawings that I did… Kinda like monthly black and white mandalas. I put a new one on my frig each month, with magnets to hold them in place. Call me crazy!!!
Reply
Murky
I had the items in my cart but based on past boxes history, I decided I’d better not. I am so glad I backed out at the last minute, I have multiples of so many of these items already.
Reply
AnninVA
Nothing says girls night in to me like a table runner. The bubble bath is nearing the end of its shelf life since it came in a box in December 2015.
Reply
Kristin
And 2016 make up?
Reply
Nicole
Lmao and chalkboard placemats! Lots of body products but was expecting a face mask or something for a GNI.
Reply
Val
Hoping for GNO variation 1. If I get 2 and you want to swap 1 for 2 let me know. Valerieodonnell22 at gmail 🙂
Reply
Kelli
Mine weighs 5.1 pounds…..so I am guessing I am getting box number 2
Reply
Jacki
Did you see somewhere what the 2 versions weigh? Please share! I really want version 2 because I have the necklace and poncho already. I don’t need another, in fact my poncho is up for swaps. I must have that bracelet ❤️
Jacki
I really want 2. Love the cuff. Already have the necklace and poncho.
Reply
Lisa
No fomo here… nice enough boxes, though
Reply
Kelli
I think these are great boxes….I got both. I don’t know which version of the GNO yet but I will be willing to take items from both boxes that I don’t need and sell?
If anyone is interested….kelli2703 at gmail dot com
Reply
Nicole
Was kinda hoping for some of the more recent items in the GNI but definitely worth the money either way!
Reply
Kc
It makes me think they’ll have a close out sale or another mystery box in the future 🙂
Reply
Julie
I’m hoping for the same. I mean they have to run out of runners someday right?!
Nicole
I hope I don’t miss it this time! That was an amazing sale last time!
Val
Wow! Great boxes! I’ve never subscribed to PS before. I got both GNI and GNO. Hoping for GNO 1 but ❤️ them both. 😍
Reply
Heather
I’m hoping I receive variation 1 of GNO. I’ve been trying to swap for that poncho.
Reply
sam
i love the poncho! i bought the box when it went on sale via Gilt and the poncho made the box worth it. i would only buy GNO if i was guaranteed the first variation.
Reply
Yadira
GNO 😍
Reply
AH
Not that it personally matters to me, as I couldn’t afford either at the time, but is it confirmed that these are the only variations of the two mystery boxes? If I remember right, when they have a theme, like “Girls night in”, they tend to have no variations or minimal versus when it is just a mystery box. I think I remember 8 or 9 variations of a $25 box.
Reply
Liz Cadman
Confirmed – these are the only variations. Hope that helps!
Reply
MinnePuffin
I’m so glad I got both! I’m in love with the GNI box and so glad I get the glasses and smartphone wallet in either version of the GNO!
Reply
Nan_A
I am happy with the girls night in.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.