Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
We have full spoilers for the May 2018 Ricky's NYC Cult Crushes beauty box! (Thanks for the heads up, Lisa!) This box is currently sold out but you can sign up for the waitlist to get the June box!
FYI - Starting June 1st, Ricky’s NYC Cult Crushes will be $14. You can read more about it here.
Ricky’s Cult Crushes subscription box gives you the chance to test our hottest brands and products – both classic and new – and learn how to optimize them through exclusive online tutorials lead by influences we love.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Thank god! I’ve searched online to check after getting my Ricky’s cult box home delivery. I would no be happy to get spoiler before getting that box. everything is okay and I’m excited.
Reply
Lisa
If you watch YouTube May unboxings every single one is a new subscriber. So they are neglecting their long time YouTubers too. Bad move.
Reply
Apricot
Maybe but, I’m a new subscriber who had been on the waitlist for a while and I haven’t received mine either. So who knows what happened with their fulfillment process.
Reply
Donna
People are complaining that soap shouldn’t be in a beauty box. That may be true, but according to their website, this is a BEAUTY & LIFESTYLE BOX.
I’ve been subscribed for 7 months, I love that they send unusual things in this box. I truly have way too much of the usual suspects. I will use everything in this box.
Reply
Jamie
So, not only am I getting a highly disappointing box, but I just got this email:
Hey Cult Crushers,
First off – we are so sorry for the delay in your delivery!
Here’s the deal! There was an unexpected delay in one shipment but the good news is that the shipment is expected to arrive today. As soon as it gets in, we’re packing the final item into your boxes and shipping it out to you as fast as we can.
Again, we apologize for this delay. We’re a small team here at Cult Crushes but we’re working hard to get everything to you as fast as we possibly can in the wake of this unfortunate shipping issue.
We promise to do better by you guys in the coming months. Thank you so much for your patience and sticking it out with us! We appreciate you guys so much and we cannot wait to continue growing with you!
Cult Crushes
#CametoCrush
Reply
Lisa
They sent an email saying a product they were waiting for came in and they would ship boxes today. Then I got this email that said at end of week. This is bull shart !!
Hello,
Thank you for shopping at Ricky’s NYC !!!
May boxes are still shipping, if you haven’t received an email confirmation with your tracking number as of yet, you will receive one by the end of this week.
We sincerely apologize for the delay.
Have a great day !
Reply
Jamie
That’s total bs on Ricky’s part! I didn’t get the email you just quoted or a shipping email either! Then again I didn’t get a shipping email last month before my box arrived. I already sent them a nasty email. They of course haven’t responded. I’m going to send another every dang day til they answer me lol.
Reply
Anne
Got my box today. Grape pawpaw which smells absolutely vile, like children’s cough medicine! I am hoping to swap it and the brushes, and maybe the highlighter. I have so many similar products but the white goddess color is a bit intriguing… I did get my $11 worth with the stain removing bar (a must have for wardrobe kits in theater!) and the micellar water. But after so many amazing months I’m a bit let down that this is my first.
Reply
Jamie
I was just on Instagram and saw that the box reveal post for May that Cult Crushes posted has had the comments disabled and all the previous comments deleted. They’ve also put up a new post abt the soap not being able to be used on brushes and that post has comments disabled as well.
Why would they do that? Cam anyone offer an explanation pls?
Reply
Mimi
When I first saw this as my first box, I immediately cancelled. I tried everything except the laundry bar and actually love the other items so far so I regret cancelling so soon. 😛 I spent too much on the FFF add-ons yesterday to sign up for the June box, but l will probably watch to see what the upcoming months look like and submit to CC again soon. 🙂
Reply
Anita
Still waiting on a tracking email…My account is still listed as processing & I’ve been charged.
I know they send them out in batches but some people have already received theirs & I still haven’t received notification mine has even shipped??
Reply
Lisa
Mine is also still processing. I am waiting til Tuesday to email them because that will be a week from date boxes were shipped. I am not super eager for any of the products anyway.
Reply
Jamie
I just got this email from Ricky’s. Apparently you CANNOT use the laundry soap for your brushes.
Hi Cult Crushers,
Please know that the Laundress Wash & Stain bar is only intended to be used for removing makeup stains from clothing. We advise you to only use the product for it’s intended use.
Some people have informed us that they use this product to clean their makeup brushes but this product contains borax which may cause irritation on eyes so please make sure to throughly wash out all product from brushes.
Thanks everyone!
Cult Crushes
Reply
Vicky H
So I got my box today…yay! Oh wait… I also got my box on Thursday.
Thankfully, I didn’t get charged twice but I still feel like I should let them know in the interest of exhibiting the same honesty I expect from companies and other people…ugh.
Side note – same highlighter color but different Paw Paw this time.
Reply
Jamie
You’re the 3rd person that I’ve heard from saying they got an extra box this month.
Reply
Vicky H
I wonder if that is why they have delayed shipping on some boxes… they ended up short on products because they gave out too many.
FYI – they said to keep it on them!
S
They send mail for me. and took money too. And they should send shipping information at last week. But they didn’t send mail. I started to worry about really i can get my box this month or not. (++;
Reply
Teri
Got my Ricky’s Cult box today. I am thrilled with my 1st box contents!! Very useful products 💥 I get plenty of makeup in my other Subs. Received the Desert Sand highlight shade and itis Gorgeous 💞…I do not like the look of tip of nose highlighting at all!! The Strawberry Paw is Great.. Any Flavor on that product. Truthfully I will use Every Item 😊
Reply
Michelle Bross
I got my for first Ricky’s box today. I’m not mad at it. I’ve never tried the Bioderma and I’ve heard good things. I usually use Jojoba oil to take off eye makeup so we’ll see. I’ve never tried the Paw Paw but I’m into the whole natural beauty thing. The highlight is a no go. I’m thirty-nine and too old for that trend. I just don’t understand why anyone wants to highlight the end of their nose. The Laundry soap if different. I doubt I’ll ever use it. I’ll add it to my “bug out” bag for nuclear war threat. The brushes seem nice. I don’t have a pointy crease brush so I’m stoked. All this being said I still cancelled. I’m on sub box overload and I blame MSA for that.
Reply
Lisa
I am 44 use highlighter every day on cheeks, nose, and eyes. That is only thing I am excited for as I never use make up water and I just reuse brushes I already own.
Reply
Jamie
These liquid highlighters are very different. They tend to be basically glitter suspended in some kind of gel like stuff with an oily feel to it. I saw a few YouTube reviews on it and it wasn’t popular. There were basically 2 opinions. If they got it in PR they loved it. If they bought it themselves or were just being honest they said it lifted their foundation and messed up their other makeup they were wearing, showed skin texture, pores, settled onto wrinkles, etc.
JuJu
Which specific brushes are in the set, btw? I didn’t see that information on the box and I don’t want to open it because I intend to swap it.
Reply
Rugby
I’m glad I cancelled. The items were getting pretty sad
Reply
Randi
I’m a new subscriber to Ricky’s. This is my first box, and I’m please with it. I have a use and purpose for everything. I’m surprised at how some people expect a pallet or high end products every month at this price point. Even with a $3 increase, you’re still getting a full size highlighter, micellar water, and soap (which I really thought was a smart and creative inclusion–The Laundress is a really nice brand for laundry products).
I think a lot of hate on this box is coming from everyone frustrated with the price increase.. but inflation does exist, and you can’t expect the same quality of products at the same price point forever. They are wanting to stay competitive at a still very affordable price point. I’ve had several beauty boxes, and the $10-11 boxes never have as many full-size products in one box and often have much smaller deluxe sample sizes that what is seen here.
Reply
vm
Yes I totally agree with you. Was my first box as well and I get a ton of subscription a month and for $11 or $14 it is still a good value. For them to keep the value of the boxes high they had to raise the price. People will be mad regardless. If you don’t like the box cancel that’s all.
Reply
Jamie
But this was never advertised as a sample box. If they said they were going to send samples I would cancel. The micellar water and soap are both small as is the paw paw. 3 ounces, 2 ounces and less than 1 ounce respectively fyi. This box sent us a simple packet last month and ppl lost their minds over it in a bad way yet they did it again in May with small sized products. Maybe newer subs are happy with it but veteran subs will be upset with both the quality and size of the items. Plus thw y said the box is valued at $40 on Instagram and that’s just not true. The highlight is $9, paw paw is $5, water is $7, soap is $6 and a full sized complete set of BH brushes like these is about $20 so these 3 mini brushes can’t be more than $4 – that’s $31. Way short of $40. Now they’re just lying? That bothers me more than anything.
Reply
JuJu
If they included one of the Drunk Elephant soaps, I would have been over the moon. But laundry soap? In a beauty box? No, thank you.
Reply
Mandy
I don’t know how anything could possibly smell worse that that Mrs. Meyers citrus something soap in the last PS box. My box smells so bad I can’t stand to open it.
Laundress is a very good brand for delicate care for lingerie. I use it all the time, AND no bad smells.
Ashley
Honestly I am subscribed to Ipsy, Ricky’s, Boxy, so Susan, Allure, Sephora, Glossy Box Yes Oh Yas, and Birch Box and not one box has absolutely “WOWED” me this month. I’m not complain though I have received products I haven’t before but nothing to write home about seems like Boxy was my makeup heavy one this month. Ipsy seems to be leaning on skin care. I don’t need anymore Primers, or highlighters!
Reply
Cyndi
I got my first box today and am very happy with it. I recently bought a few BH eyeshadow palettes, so it’s nice to be able to try out their brushes now. The Aura Glow came in White Goddess, very pretty and it smells nice, too. I got the pure paw paw in watermelon. I thought it was nice to get a product from The Laundress – love their products!
Reply
Vicky H
You got the same box as me! I am happy I got the white highlighter and the watermelon paw paw.
Reply
Mary
I signed up because of the past rave reviews and the waitlist lifted. Very underwhelmed , however I will give them another chance. They sent me two boxes and each had same color dark highlighter but one grape pawpaw ointment and one strawberry. I actually like the ointment, everything else, not so much. Let’s hope they get better with the price increase
Reply
Cindy
I did too and am very underwhelmed…probably will cancel as there is nothing in this box I need or have not tried and did not like and I just don’t need another highlighter and I don’t like petroleum skin care products. I should have known …my bad for signing up.
Reply
Jb
I know what you mean. I feel like a deserve this bad box because I fell for the hype.
Beccah
If anyone is looking for the Chi chi OMFG palette, mine is up for swap!
Reply
Jamie
I’m waitlisted on the MSA swap site lol. Have been for a while now.
Reply
Beccah
Really? I thought they opened it to everyone a couple weeks ago
Phyllis
Me too. 😢
Julie
My first box and last. I think I only signed up after seeing palettes, but I can use $14/month to save up for the palettes I want, and not end up with pasties and eyelashes I won’t use. I don’t think I’m in their target demographic but just succumbed to the FOMO.
Reply
JuJu
To me their best box ever was actually not any of the ones with the palettes (I have a million palettes already, and have become very difficult to please), but the one from last September with the mini hair iron and the Z palette with magnets. I remember it was just surreal to open that box, I didn’t even care what else was in it. 😄
Reply
Leslie Belt
Agreed! I about flipped out when I saw a flat iron in the box. It was stuffed full that month too.
Julie
Oh wow that sounds like it was an awesome box!
Jamie
Very true. Compare that box to this box and the difference is night and day!
Beccah
Now that they upped the price it isn’t worth it. I did like getting the palettes but pretty sure that won’t be happening. If they had grandfathered the long time subbers I might have stayed but I really won’t miss this box
Reply
MzBev
I am still disappointed that they didn’t grandfather the current members in at the $11 cost. So many other subscriptions, who have raised their price did it. It seems like they got so big, so fast, and really have no idea how to handle it. Giving a lower value box, the month they announce the cost increase was very poor marketing. They’re going to lose these newbies quickly. This month isn’t horrible, but there was no “hero” item, like we’ve had in previous months. I guess I’m just letdown by them and their actions, this month.
Grace J Mock
This is my first box after being on the wait list for 2 months. I am kind of disappointed. I had looked at all the past boxes and saw cool different items. I was not expecting a palette but hopefully more makeup and unique items when I got this sub. But the ointment looks like something you get from Avon for a kid and laundry soap???? I gt that yes you might get makeup on your clothes, but I really have no use for it. The brushes look ok but are small. I guess I can put them in a travel kit, but I rarely travel so this box was a bummer for me. It is still better than IPSY in my opinion but I hope next month is better. I am giving them a 3 month trial to see if I like next month’s box better. So far my favorite sub box by a landslide is BoxyCharm. I also love my Lola Beauty box. I also get IPSY which I may cancel soon, Macy’s, Allure, and Sephora which I only keep for the bonus points, although I did like my bag this month from them, I got the Becca, Porefessional, and Kat Von D Tattoo liner… all three spoilers which I was lucky, my Sephora boxes usually suck. I wil try out the liquid highligter from this box, I need practice at using liquids, I usually only use dry highlighters and my favorites are the Too Faced Diamond one, and the Wet n Wild Mermaid one. I do have 2 other Becca ones, the light chasers. I am hoping with the price increase that they up their game a little. I just think that they kind of rushed and put a bunch of junk together this month to get everyone off the wait list.
Reply
Resa
My first box arrived today – very happy! Always need micelular water and I’m leaving town for two weeks so perfect travel size. The laundry soap will also be perfect for vacation and smells ahhhhmazing! I am on highlighter overload BUT I am going to use this one with lotion on my legs for shimmer and not feel guilty like I’m “wasting it” by not using it on my face. Mini brushes will work great for my purse and I’m excited to try out the paw paw balm (I got watermelon). No regrets here!
Reply
sjshopsalot
I love the idea of mixing the highlighter with lotion for legs!! I have SO MANY little bottles and tubes from all my sub boxes. I will def be having shimmering legs from now on! Thanks!!
Reply
Rachael
Just got this email after asking where my tracking was….I was charged 2 or so days ago.
Hello,
Thank you for shopping at Ricky’s NYC !!!
We sincerely apologize for the delay with your box.
May boxes started shipping later than usual this month and we are working very hard to get boxes out as quickly as we can.
You will receive an email confirmation with your tracking number as soon as your box ships.
Thank you for your patience.
Have a great day
Reply
Elizabeth
I happen to like this months box….it has some useful items in it.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.