Facebook PixelSubscriber Survey: What Do You Want to See in Fall Boxes? | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Subscriber Survey: What Do You Want to See in Fall Boxes?

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanJun 24, 2018 | 114 comments

Subscriber Survey time! Even though we've just officially started summer this past week, I'm already thinking about fall boxes!

What item(s) would you love to see in a Fall box?

I may be in the minority on this one, but I'm always happy to see a new scarf for fall in a subscription box. (I don't buy scarves anymore, so my entire collection comes from subscription boxes!)

P.S. If you have an idea for a future Subscriber Survey question, let me know in the comments!

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

114 comments

Lana

I’d like a nice candle, the dryer balls FFF put in a survey recently got me excited, a travel sized high end hand cream, maybe a nice notebook or a reed defuser (for gifts)… a lux blanket would be nice, earrings, fuzzy socks, bath bombs, beauty stuff is always good, a good stationery or card set, high quality loose leaf tea.

no more scarves and definitely no hats or any kind of on-the-go drink ware >_<
oh, and no planners/calendars.

Reply ButtonReply

Shannon

I’d love a macrame wall hanging!

Reply ButtonReply

Deborah

Could Use Some very Good full Mask face mask almost running out of them have been using them a lot more lately

Reply ButtonReply

Marian

This has made me think what is is that I like about the boxes. I like the curation that they’ve found something that I wouldn’t find myself. And I like seasonal things and things that play to the senses. Candles with a nice fragrance. Fuzzy socks. High fragrance bubble bath. I think a cushion for the bathtub would be different and great. I like practical things for my facial routine. I’m using some high end dental floss from a box right now that I really like. A really nice eye makeup remover would be good. No more cups or makeup. I also like holidays. Seasonal dishtowel or coasters. I haven’t seen trivets. Nice olive wood spoon for cooking. Though I’m tired of cups, I’d love one or a pair of nice glasses for soda. If they can handle sizes, sleep shirts or t shirts would be nice. A vest might be good. No more scarves for me. Bookends. Beautiful glass paperweight. Seasonal pillow cover.

Reply ButtonReply

Kiwi

Boot socks or tights. I love umbrellas because I live in the PNW. It is always raining here in the Fall. Any lip color that is not a bright pink or bright red.
For quarterly boxes, I agree a Kindle would be awesome and I would buy more books (hint hint Amazon).

No more scarves, coffee mugs or trinket boxes, please!

Reply ButtonReply

Deborah

I Would like to get Tatcha skin Products, a warm long Knit scarf, Anything Pumpkin my flavor for Fall , fuzzy Earmuffs, Earplugs to help me sleep, cozy socks, Crystal Light to drink trying to lose weight trying not to hard , Victoria Secret Anything

Reply ButtonReply

Alex

Mugs made anywhere but China, Keep-Cups, throws and pillows, satin pillow cases, cotton robe, cinnamon apple or candy apple scented: liquid hand soaps, candles, lip balm, bar soap, lotion, body wash etc. Cutting board/cheese board, flavored teas, kitchen ware: hand towels, pot holders, trivets, dishwashing gloves, aprons. Bathroom goods: towels, bath mats, shower curtain. I would love bedding, bedding accessories, throw pillows. Vase, candle holders….

Reply ButtonReply

Julie Moore

Thermal cup, no candles, have cats, no scarfs, black eyeliner and mascara, only shampoo and conditioner for hair care. Adjustable watch for skinny wrists, large wallet.

Reply ButtonReply

Amy

2019 Desire Map Planner from Danielle LaPorte. A mini bread maker, like a mini loaf-size (does that exist? I want that.) Long sleeve sleep Tee. Cinnamon anything. Moisturizing anything-foot cream, luxe conditioner (and shampoo!), body oil, bath oil (This Works please!!). No scarves or blankets….I have more than I’ll use in my lifetime from sub boxes! I also think one of those how-to instruction books/workbooks for hand lettering. So fun!

Reply ButtonReply

Janae

Useable kitchen products. Bathroom organizer for countertop. Cute scarf in dark jewel tones. Yummy black or green teas. Pore minimizing & non-pore clogging primer/foundation/powder. Tarte products.

Reply ButtonReply

Dez

Give me color! I want colorful shadows, colorful liners, holo nail polish, more sparkly or multi colored brushes like I’ve gotten in Ipsy, colorful highlighters, blue lipstick, I want stuff out of the usual copper eye nude lip.

Reply ButtonReply

Laura Rose

Pumpkin spice candle
fairy lights
hat/thick headband to cover my ears/hat with pony tail opening
scarf/poncho/blanket
gloves
Car air freshener
Small tea pot
Hot chocolate/mug
Anything Korres
pumpkin decor stuff

Reply ButtonReply

Amy

Some of the things on my Subscription Box wish list:
Gourmet Chocolate Bar Assortment with fun flavors
Air plant terrarium kit
Adjustable, stackable ring set
Seasonal Cookbook
Crystal Rearview Mirror car charm (the ones that make rainbows)
Luxury Body Wash
Fruity, loose tea
Vitamin C face serum
Calligraphy pen set with instruction book
Catch all tray for desk

Reply ButtonReply

sheila

I love fake fur headwraps, comfy loungewear, silk pillowcase, a great hairbrush, a shower cap(to wear to bed with hair masks), a cozy throw, reusable straws and Starbucks gift cards.

Reply ButtonReply

Kimberly Miller

I love Aerin products! I think her Tangier Vanille scent would be perfect for fall.

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

I would love a milk frothier for tea or coffee, makeup products that are pure and natural, a fall cookbook, large wooden bowl for table, or to make a salad….throw pillow, coupon for massage or movie. Fall nail polish, a coupon to use at Kendra Scott for our own choice of jewelry. Fall hand soap that smells like fall but for sensitive skin too. New leather wallet

Reply ButtonReply

Misti

Anything storage
I love the Kindle idea those are great.
royal blue,dark purple,gold,silver,deep blue/green,and emerald green nail polish and eyeliners.
anything for facial dry skin

Reply ButtonReply

KW

• Home decor/kitchen accessories that are useful 1st and decorative 2nd (e.g., Swedish dish cloths)
• Chai tea, chocolate matcha tea, spiced “cafe de olla” coffee
• Wooden foot massager/roller and luxe footcare cream/moisturizer
• Retractable lip brush and touch-up mirror set
• Purse-sized (mini) emergency kit (nail file, bandages, hair elastics, stain remover wipes, etc.)
• Stainless steel aromatherapy bracelet or pendant with multi-colored reusable refill pads
• Slipper socks (option to select size and possibly color)

Reply ButtonReply

missann

Jewel toned anything and everything. I’m bored with the usual fall stuff.

Reply ButtonReply

lspinny

One of the first subscription boxes I got, can’t remember which one, had a tube of Orogold hand cream (not the body cream) that I LOVED the formula and especially the scent. Would like more of that for fall/winter as it worked fantastic for me. I also like lip balms and would like more moisturising shower gels. I am pretty happy with most items, but would like to see more reds and berry colors for lipsticks and nail polishes for fall and winter. Also some browns in nail polish. I’m older and don’t need acne treatments. Would also like to have a choice on at least one item per month. That is all.

Reply ButtonReply

Bonnie

What I don’t want is spicy scents. I know I’m in the minority, but I’m allergic to cinnamon so all the cinnamon or other spicy scented things don’t get used by me. Otherwise, I’m pretty much just a beauty and jewelry subscriber so I welcome all the new stuff!

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

For the fall box(es):
* DIY Christmas ornament kit? Nothing too crazy but something cool.
* Pet product (for pet owners)
* wind chime
* GOOD candy or a snack from an up and coming WOMAN owned brand.
*Slippers
* robe or some type of PJ or nightgown
* I’d forgo nearly everything in a sub box for a nice leisure set.

Reply ButtonReply

kathleen everett

NO MORE BLACK EYELINER!!!!!!!! Would like to have green, bronze, etc.

Reply ButtonReply

Kathy

I would like a wool hat for fall.

Reply ButtonReply

Alexa

I only subscribe to RZ BOS, so if I could curate a box for Rachel, it would include:
-Peter Thomas Roth Pumpkin Enzyme Mask (Yeah, I’m basic. Give me ALL the pumpkin beauty products!)
-Cashmere socks (ridiculous, but that’s what boxes are for, things you wouldn’t get yourself)
-Hourglass lip oil
-Ear cuff from The Last Line in choice of metal (hero item)
-another useful styling product like she used to include

Her boxes used to feel luxe, it’s time to get back to that.

Reply ButtonReply