Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
The Products: $100 +Value. "5 or more mini and full-sized makeup and skincare products. All items are mixed with new and former packaging. Items in box may vary based on availability."
Are you going to grab a mystery box? Want to see it reviewed?
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Retrograde highlighter (amazing, star of the box)
Steely gray ‘foil’ eyeshadow (almost a dupe for another Ofra eyeshadow I have and I don’t do smokey eyes)
Bohemiam eyeshadow godet pan (almost a dupe for a different brand eyeshadow I have, but I like the rich brown shade and it can go in my other z-palette)
Day cream (highest rv item in the box but it had some giant airbubbles that meant about a fifth of the product was missing. It’s heavy, more like a night cream. Sits on the skin a bit and not as hydrating as I hoped it would be.)
Lip wipes (They barely work. I had to scrub my lipstain and mascara off and there still was obvious makeup left before cleansing again.)
Lip gloss in “Love”
They recently had a deal for a little kit you could get with a $10 purchase. I bought $12 in mystery lipglosses, figuring I could give them as gifts if I hated the shades.
*EVERY* single one was in the Love shade. A bit disappointing. The kit was nice, though. It had a large banana powder godet, more of the useless wipes, a mini rodeo drive highlighter, a mini cosmo blush, and a mini liquid lip in Tuscany.
Reply
Punkykiki
I never received mine!!! I am so upset….I was really looking forward to this. I sent OFRA a note, but I doubt that anything can be done about it. I was just going through my email that I use for shopping and it caught my eye. USPS says it was delivered on the 15th. I’ve never had anything taken before….most things fit inside my huge mailbox. We have security cameras but I doubt I could ever see anything if someone just walked up and took it off my porch. Sounds like you all got some lovely things!!!
Reply
Punkykiki
Guys, OFRA Customer Service is BOMB!!!! They have already contacted me and told me it looked like USPS lost my package and they would get one in the mail shipped to me today. I truly never expected this. They just got one very happy customer for life!!!
Reply
Bellafamiglia
SOLD OUT! ARRGHšToo bad as I had the $10 OFF Coupon code. š Oh well, I signed up for the restock notice. Hoping I get in on one. Never tried theirs, so I’m excited as it sounds like everyone got amazing goodies! š¤
Reply
Shanrell
I received a liquid lipstick I will give to my sister, a single eyeshadow refill, Madison Miller sweet stuff blush, Retrograde highlighter, a small squeezy tube lipgloss, and makeup wipes. Iām pleased for $15! There are a couple of items I would like to swap namely the highlighter and the blush. Iām trying to list them on the swap site but the Ofra Mystery Box isnāt on the site yet- hopefully it gets on there soon! I did send MSA an email. In the meantime, if anyone wants the highlighter or blush let me know!š
Reply
Michelle
I received my mystery box today and am so happy! I received the following
RCK BOdy Glow in Sunkissed $39
Goal Glow highlighter $35
Retrograde highlighter $35
Banana Powder godet $12
Liquid lipstick Monaco $20
Lipliner in Savage Red $13
Lip wipes 15 ct $7
Total value was $161
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
This is my 3rd time getting an Ofra mystery box and this time around was a helluva deal. The mask alone was worth 4x the price of the box. I was hoping for a blush and a liquid lip because the formulas are some of my favorites, but I am happy to try out some new stuff! I wish I had bought the 3 I originally had in my cart but I was worried they might be repeats. I see that boxes are wildly varied so I think it wouldn’t have been an issue.
I got:
Retrograde highlighter (freaking gorgeous) $29
Peptide Brightening mask $59
Bossy eyes liquid shadow in Five Star- gold metallic (discontinued) $20
Millennium White eyeshadow $12
A foundation/concealer brush from a brush set estimated value $5
Pack of wipes $7
Cherry Mocha lipgloss in older packaging $15
Total RV $140
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
Correction $147 RV. Forgot to add the wipes to the total
Reply
Dea
I received:
Full-size long-lasting liquid lipstick in Bordeaux (Halloween purple! Argh!)
Full-size Madison Miller blush in Sweet Stuff
Godet refill pan in Millennium White
Full-size highlighter in Retrograde (pretty!)
15-count lip wipes
Brush (no markings)
Sample-size long-lasting liquid lipstick in Americano (pretty!)
Reply
Kim
Mine arrived yesterday, and I got:
Box 1:
15pc Cleanse It Off Lip Wipes
Highlighter in Retrograde
California Dream Triangle refill
Godet Eyeshadow Refill in Foil
Signature Wet and Dry Foundation Palette
0.47 oz Lipgloss in shade Love (sample size?)
Box 2:
15 pc Cleanse It Off Lip Wipes
Highlighter in Retrograde
California Dream Triangle refill
Liquid Lipstick in Fifth Avenue
Eyeshadow brush
Blush in shade Bellini
0.47 oz lipgloss in shade Mocha (couldn’t find on web site, maybe it’s a sample?)
Overall I’m happy with the value of the boxes and what I received. I wish I didn’t get two of the highlighters and two of the bronzers, but even with repeats I think it was a great deal for $15
Reply
Jacki
Mine arrived also!
Highlighter in RetroGrade
Highlighter Niki Tutorials dual shade
Eyeshadow single
Makeup wipes
Long lasting liquid lipstick in Charmed
Long lasting liquid lipstick in Oh My Ry Ry
Iām very happy to have more of their highlighters. The lipstick seems to work for me with balm on top- I need the extra moisture. It was a great purchase for $20 shipped
Reply
Mika
I’m so glad people are putting what they received
Here’s mine:
An eyeshadow brush
Liquid eyeshadow in five star
Liquid lipstick in wonderland
Blush in sweet stuff
California triangle dream
Highlight in retrograde and
Makeup wipes
I think it’s a good deal for seven full size products even though many of the items may not be suitable colors for me. I can easily pass them on.
Reply
Alice R
Got the same products in mine. It arrived today.
Reply
Vi
I received two highlighters one in retrograde the other a Nikki tutorials colab. I also got an eyeshadow single in Auburn, make up removing wipes, eyebrow gel in dark brown and a liquid lipstick in charmed. Why on earth would they send me two full-size highlighters? I guess they will make great Christmas gifts because I donāt wear highlighter and neither does my daughter. I knew there was a chance of getting one but two š¤Ø really!
Reply
Kenley
Received mine today. I got:
Highlighter in Retrograde (full size)
Ofra Makeup Remover Pads (15 count)
Ofra x Madison Miller blush in Sweet Stuff
Ofra Single Eyeshadow in Gold Rush
Ofra Long Lasting Lipstick in Charmed
Ofra Long Lasting Lipstick in Fifth Ave
Iām pretty happy with my first Ofra Mystery Box. The only think I wonāt use is the Fifth Ave lipstick.
Reply
Linda
I got Retrograde highlighter
California Dream Triangle in Godot
Madison Miller blush in Sweet stuff
Makeup remover wipes
Eye makeup brush no writing on this so not sure of value
Fro-zay peel off mask
Liquid lipstick in Malibu
I think this is a good value for 15.00 only thing I have is the blush in a palette from Ipsy, so I will gift that. Most excited for the highlighter.
Reply
Ashley
Were the highlighter and California Dream Triangle both full size?
Kenley
I thought mine was good until I saw yours lol. I would of much rather gotten this box!
Rachel
This was awful my cheek plt was open and the rest was true jun
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
What all did you get? Your junk might be a treasure for me! If you are interested in a swap let me know…(depending on what you got)
Reply
Jacki
š¤¢
Reply
Christina Osborne
I just purchased this, so it’s still available and the freeship code is still working in case anyone still wants one
Reply
Carolyn
I wasnt going to do it bc I didnt want to pay shipping, but the freeship code worked and I cant wait to see what I get!
Reply
Tammy Huys
I just ordered 2 of these! I’m so excited but nervous as well! I’ve never ordered anything from Ofra before and I’m afraid of getting small cheap samples! Lol even though I know nothing from Ofra is cheap lol the freeship code didn’t work for me but I’m wondering if its because I’m in Canada!
Reply
Tawanda
Thank you for the code. It worked for me also so I couldn’t resist getting this. I will gift won’t doesn’t work for me.
Reply
sherry
Thanks for the code “freeship”…It worked for me!
Reply
Heather
Thank you for the heads up on this! I bought 3 and used after pay! Added the free gift AM PM hand band! Going to make for great Christmas gifts!
Reply
Nan
Tempting, but with my luck I would get 5 highlighters and I’ve already got too many.
Reply
Ashley
Praying I get a highlighter. I like the Pillow Talk one, but I think it was in a past box so it probably wonāt be in this one.
Reply
Ami
lordie!! I am stressed out and the last thing I needed to do was read about some attractive deals on MSA. But that’s what I’ve been doing.
I really, really didn’t need this. But I couldn’t reeeeesist. I went through the check-out and for you ladies who hate to pay shipping, the code freeship works. No joke, I had no expectation of this working, I just thought, why not give it a shot, and at just 15 bucks, this is a very good deal. Now, buyers remorse is setting in, but good luck to ya!
Reply
Tawanda
Thank you for the code. It worked for me also so I couldn’t resist getting this.
Shai
Got one. Love the highlighters and lilies so if I get one of each Iām happy
Reply
Marina
please review it
Reply
Your Friends @MSA
Noted, Marina!
Reply
Kenley
I got one. This will be my first OFRA mystery box, so Iām hoping I get some good stuff!!!
Reply
Ami
I stress bought this. And I put in for code freeship, not expecting it to work, but it did! So I got it š
Reply
Dea
Ami, thank you for the code! It was the push I needed (wanted?) to make this purchase.
Please Lord no matte lip stuff no matte lip stuff no matte lip stuff, and this pale girl has already received more highlighters than any one person should have. Thank you.
MGG
Thank you for the code! Iām in for one with free shipping. For $15, itās worth the gamble for me.
Maria
Thank you so much for the brilliant idea! It works for me too.
Alice R
Thank you! It worked for me.
Brit
Thank you!! The code worked for me
Kenley
Oh man! I wish I had that code earlier!
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.