POPSUGAR Must Have Winter 2019 Box Spoilers Round 2!

Looking at the photos of the dish, I thought it was plain silver! 🤦‍♀️ It looked like the white/black was reflection, my own fault! But, my body oil leaked out, the cap was not screwed on tight! I was planning on gifting this bc I don’t want to use a body oil with cinnamon! I’m not happy & will be canceling! Wish I would have gotten fff winter box instead!

Full spoilers are out on R e d d i t!

…and the Kevyn Aucoin blush just showed up at TJ Maxx’s website for $12.99. Same shade and everything. I’m really starting to regret my Popsugar boxes–I know subscription boxes inflate their values, but I can’t even pretend at this point. I ordered the Neiman’s box and it seems like a dud and now I’m not even looking forward to the winter box. Blah.

That HB brand looks like they are trying to be Henri Bendel so badly, kinda tacky. Loved last year’s winter box, this one is sad.

Sadly this will be my last box. Not into any of the items. I’ve been with PS since the beginning and loved their monthly boxes. The value has not been there with me for the quarterly. I’m a bit sad to see my PS time end. If they ever go back to monthly I will subscribed again in a second.

Im glad I cancelled as soon as I saw the silver trinket dish. Loved last years Fall box. Ended up purchasing 2 of tjem in fact. Really liked this past Fall box a lot too. Last years Winter box i received but have never really used anything from it at all. Thats when I initially canceled. Easy pass for me. Tho very cute I already have no less than 7 travel bags for makeup n beauty care. Dont need a silver trinket dish. I have much cuter ones from FFF. Ive got enough blush to last me a lifetime. N the jewelry is “ok” but nothing I’m crazy about. Enjoy ladies. Ill b back to check out the Spring box 😊

I just cancelled. I just don’t care for this one.

I’m underwhelmed so far. The only thing I see myself using is the makeup bag but I love the purse from fall so much that it even makes this box feel worth it somehow lol. I’m likely cancelling Before spring since it doesn’t look like they spoil early enough to keep me subscribed anyway.

This box isn’t as exciting as the Fall box, but it’s decent… and PSMH already charged me so…

I just canceled FFF and upgraded to PS because of this spoiler. Every time I wait the Popsugar sells out. The FOMO was too strong!!

Sad that the bag is so small IMO.

I have alllll the heart eyes for the round bag(s)!! I still use the round Clinique bags from 15 years ago as my travel bags (for travel sizes). I can’t bear to give them up! Somehow I’m able to cramp so much in them. Circle bags are great in my opinion. 😁What a classy looking upgrade! 👍

The blush looks pretty and I like the bag. Looks like it would hold what you need. I don’t mind plastic for carrying skincare and cosmetics. Easy to clean. Not sure why they call it vegan leather. To make it sound more expensive?

Their website says that the clear vinyl bag is “TSA friendly,” so I assume the size is designed to be compatible with a 1 qt clear case.

I was so burned by the customer service, I don’t think I can ever order from Pop Sugar again. My fall box got lost in transit, and Pop Sugar refused to do squat about it . They told me once the package leaves their warehouse, it’s no longer their responsibility & it was on me & FedEx to track it down. I’m going to start trying that with my mortgage. “Sorry! I mailed it. Too bad for you, bank. Figure it out.”

Perhaps not the most exciting items, but I can see myself using both and I prefer usable items over clutter. I also like how psmh is good quality, other boxes seem to put in cheaply made items with a name slapped on.

I wonder if it matters that there’s a beauty by pop sugar set of something for the lips maybe, along with the blush and some brushes? The oribe spray is pictured with brand as well. I know they said products are for display only, but psmh is sneaky like that sometimes. Just wondering.

Blush and a makeup bag. How original.

I’m actually reasonably happy with this!

I was very nervous because I purchased previously to get on the waitlist for fall, but unfortunately never got that box meaning I’m stuck with this one. While I still don’t think it is nearly as exciting as the fall box, everything seems very nice and usable. The case in particular is super useful for me.

My annual expired and I don’t plan to renew at this point. Unfortunately there’s nothing of interest to me in this box. The first 2 spoilers didn’t do it for me, so was hoping for more that I’d like…but I don’t use blush at all and the cosmetic bag is ho-hum, plus seems on the small side. I found a lot in the FFF add ons that I like, so will use my $$ there instead.

Whew glad I went with FFF. RZ and PSMH just don’t do it for me. They don’t seem curated at all.

I prefer leather, but since this is more of a makeup bag I’m fine to keep my stash there in the cupboard. Don’t really care for the blush, but it’s a good brand and nice colour.

I really like these two spoilers. The box is coming together nicely.

They always have cute stuff but man really not worth 75$. FFF is much more superior IMO

I’m with you. I just cancelled. I can’t see myself using or gifting any of these items. The fall box was so good though!