Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I love mine, I got the Manny Mua! I actually had a great base and premium boxes this month, I need to mark it on the calendar because that never happens!
Anyone disappointed by not getting the Farmacy product, it’s one of my least favorite products by them. I think I chunked mine over half full. Now some ppl may love it, but it’s a must miss for me!
Reply
Jamey
Mine is 2.65 pounds……anybody else have that weight and get the manny mua pallette?!?!
That’s ALL I am hoping for out of base and premium….lol …mine isnt supposed to show up for a couple more days.
Reply
Devo
I did not receive my choice item!
This April boxycharm premium box I set my choice as the coverFX cloud primer and it was confirmed on my account, and when I got an email that my box has shipped there was a link with the products I was going to receive with the cloud primer included. But the box I received in the mail did not have the cloud primer or 2 other things that said would be in it! I was so sad! One of the items was supposed to be the Natasha denona blush! I contacted them but waiting for a reply. Has this happened to anyone before?
Reply
Jamey
I have never got an email telling me what’s in it. They have sent emails showing items that COULD be in there that month.
I’m sure they have a super small group packing this month so I’m sure a lit of mistakes will happen. If anything send them the screenshot of the email you got that confirmed your choice and they MIGHT send your choice, but you never know about boxycharm help centre. Lol.
Goodluck and I hope you and your lived ones are healthy and doing well during these crazy times. I hope everyone is doing good !
And I’m glad boxy and ipsy are sending boxes because some are not.
Reply
Maggie
Oh, BTW! I read choice for REGULAR box next month will be on Monday 4/13 for boxyluxe subscribers and waitlisters, and full access choice will be on the 14th… so apparently we will get only leftover choices for regular box as you know the cream of the crop will be all sold out when the normal subscription boxers finally get to make their choice…
I’m guessing that last luxe box was so horrible they want to give them an advantage every regular box month just to keep people subbing to it (luxebox). I was happier with my regular box I got that luxe month, even though I didn’t get to make a choice because I downgraded from luxe since the luxe looked so bad, after regular box choice had already happened. Good luck with choice wars, I hope you all get to choose what you want before it’s gone!
Reply
Maggie
I was surprised my box had the Farmacy item I wanted! That was a shock, especially since my profile is for make-up heavy boxes lol. So what i got is:
Farmacy: Honey Potion (yay me!)
Kopari: Coconut face cream (that was my choice)
Lavido: age away replenishing cream (uhm… okay… more skin care…. <.<)
IGK: Good Behavior (Ugh on that… I put I like brushes, not hairsprays. My hair is thin and flat, going in my gifting box I guess (where other unusable for me items go lol))
Wander Beauty: Mile high club (omg! It's make-up! Even though I don't like getting mascara cause I have too much still)
NudeStix: Magnetic lip plush paints (and one last make-up item yay. Still, this was very very skincare heavy… did you look at my profile boxy? xD )
Box was 2.2lbs btw!
Reply
Lori
I got this exact box but it didn’t have the mascara. Was super bummed as I can’t use any of it. I prefer makeup heavy boxes, too. Glad you got the Farmacy!
Reply
Maggie
I prefer make-up heavy usually too. Only reason I wanted the Farmacy this month instead of just a palette is I got a palette as choice for basebox and I like farmacy items. Though tbh, I really had my fingers crossed for either smashbox or the farmacy, so if I had gotten smashbox I wouldn’t have hated it it lol.
My base box though was the biggest bust of my boxycharm life. Palette came as the caramel melange and those colors do not work on me, they are ugly to me. I like blues, greens, adventurist. They had 10 palettes to get it right and they got it sooooo wrong. Then they filled the rest in with tools! I got the sponges, the brushes, and the eraser! Wth, gimme my make-up! ;_; I just couldn’t believe they would put all those three in the same box. Like just sponges and brushes alone being in the same box is messed up to me, unless it is luxe where there would still be room for actual make-up… I may cancel next time they send me that type of set up. When I didn’t like last luxe months spoilers look, I actually took my $25 I saved by lowering my sub back to base box and bought a palette off Sephora with it. So boxy, don’t make me take my mula elsewhere! xD Next time let us pick the palette colors at the least!
Misha
TY for putting weight in!!
Super stoked as mine is 2.2lbs
Fingers crossed box is same as yours.
😍
Reply
Maggie
I am glad you like this variation then!! Always great to get the one you actually wanted!
Amy Bowman
Oh dear, that is the same weight of my box. I picked kopari too and thought for sure I would get the ND because surely they wouldn’t send two face creams in one box, ugh. The only thing I really want is the ND blush.
Reply
Maggie
Yeah, I thought it was weird they gave me the face cream instead of the blush too, just because Kopari was a face cream. I don’t like/wear blush though and I had blush as one of my receive rarely items and I thought that’s why they didn’t put the blush in there for me. I hope you still get the blush somehow, or at least are able to find someone you might be able to do a trade with. The anti-aging cream I will just throw my moms way and see if she likes it.
Julie B
Just got mine. Variation 57 (2.6 lb). Overall happy!
Lunar Beauty Life’s a Drag palette (was hoping for Smashbox but this looks fun)
Peach & Lily toner (my choice)
Lavido cream ($69 really? Hope it does something good)
Opulent beauty brushes (eh, will throw into my pile)
TooFaced lip gloss (probably give to someone)
Wander Beauty mile high mascara (tried this before and wasn’t impressed but so many people love it so I’ll give it another go)
Reply
Desi Sutter
That was my box too!
Reply
Marion
Just got my first Premium box & I LOVE it! I got Variation 51:
– Smashbox Palette + Eyeliner (currently have SO MANY palettes; will probably swap this so it can get the love it deserves from someone else)
– Peach & Lily Toner (hoped for this!)
– Lavido cream
– IGK good behavior spray (DESPERATELY hoped for this!)
– Nudestix lip paint in Waikiki Rose (wouldn’t buy from this brand but the color looks nice so I’m not mad about it)
– M. Greengrass dry oil spray (I actually followed this item on the MSA swap site, so I’m stoked to get it in my box)
Reply
Nicki
Marion,
What was the weight of your box ?
Reply
Marion
3.1 lbs!
Sheryl
I’ll swap you my spray if you want it for an eyeshadow palette
Reply
Lori
I would totally swap for that palette!
Reply
Marion
Aaaaand Mom has already claimed the Lavido lol
Reply
Lori
I got mine today and I am SO disappointed. I would have been happy with almost any of the palettes and most of the DOC lippies, but I got all 3 of the skincare products for dry skin (Farmacy, Lavido and Kopari), while my skin is oily and acne prone. I wanted a heavy makeup box, but the only cosmetic I got is the Nudestix lip paint in a shade that washes me out. The last item was the R+Co protein spray, but my hair is fine and flat, so that’s also a bust. I’d feel better if we could swap, but man, what a bummer after finally getting off the waitlist after several months.
Reply
Nicki
Lori,
What was the weight of your box ?
Reply
Lori
2.3 lbs, but was the same as others with 2.2 lbs (even though I had one less item??).
SpoiledRN
I’d love to trade my Smashbox palette for your Honey Potion!
Reply
Sheryl
I agree I don’t care for the fact that they even send hair care products. Like hair care is too exacting. I don’t mind hair care tools just not the hair care products
Reply
Amy Bowman
I agree. I don’t use a blow dryer so all these “heat activated” hair products are useless to me.
Amy Bowman
I wonder if they have a smaller staff due to the quarantine and are just kind of throwing things in boxes. It seems odd they would put so much skincare in one box if you didn’t want it. Ugh. I’m not looking forward to mine.
Reply
Lori
That’s exactly what I was thinking–that even if I got one skincare item, I’d still get other types of products not THREE if the same type.I’m sure this is someone’s idea of a great box. 🤷♀️
Lori
Sorry I was confusing the boxes–I would have been happy with ANY of the palettes and basically everything except for what I got. 🙁
Reply
Alice
I feel like the spoilers for base has been better lately. How come base get Elemis while premium gets everything else? And those brushes for premium don’t look any better, they acutally look cheap to me comparing to the set that base is getting. I really feel like actually value wise, base and premium have not been too different and I keep questioning myself if it is worth $10 to get the upgrade…
Reply
Chelsea
I agree. I was so excited to get off the premium waitlist and I’ve been disappointed since. But at least I have a nice stash going to give as donations or Christmas presents.
Reply
Tammy
I’m with just about everyone else on this one, the first choice had 3 pallettes and 1 skincare item and I received the skincare, 2 haircare products, which I am not into at all! I did get the Natasha Denona blush duo but the color is probably not going to work for me! I am getting the Nude Lip paints, which I am happy about the nudes, not sure about the paint part lol, I’m not big on matte lipsticks, I glosses to be honest as my lips are always on the dry side, I exfoliate and use moisturizing lip masks morning and night and all throughout the day but my lips are just dry and do not tend to do well with lipsticks, so we’ll have to see about that one, I am excited to try a new product though! And of course another face spray! This box is extremely boring for me, my last base box I received an entire box of skincare, not one makeup product in a makeup beauty box, I complained ,but I got the same reply I always get, we strive to give our members a unique variety of both makeup and skincare, our boxes vary from month to month, blah blah blah! April’s base box looks sooooo much more promising than the premium box, how is that? With a $10 difference and I am more excited about the cheaper box, Boxycharm needs to step up their game, they are getting boring as F#&$ fast!
tammy g.
does anyone know when boxycharm will be shipping out this month…usually I have mine by now..not even a email for shipping yet?
Reply
Lori
I got an email yesterday with delivery date for today. FedEx says delivery scheduled for today, but it’s almost 5pm and apparently hasn’t left the FedEx warehouse yet, so..?
Reply
Meso
I picked peach and Lily so I won’t get the Fatmacy. Booo.
Reply
Alice
You might! Farmacy was not a choice item. It’s a variant to the palettes.
Reply
Amy Bowman
I am super psyched about the ND blush. I wanted that bloom palette so bad when premium started. It does seem like now that I’m off the waitlist there are way more variations which I can’t stand. I still can’t believe they didn’t let us choose one of the palettes.
Reply
Angela DeSilva
I hope to get the Farmacy and either the Barbie eyeshadow palette or the Manny MUA palette, ND blush and the Hair spray. When Choice was up I only had the Becca Blush (I have them all) and the Stila glitter and glow (have a ton) were available so I chose one of each for each box I have two premium subscriptions. I don’t remember what the choice for base box was now?! I have three base box subscriptions. I should cut down since I also do Ipsy and Ipsy plus but its the only thing making me happy right now with all this crap going on in this world besides the fact that everyone I love is healthy.
Reply
tammy g.
I just joined boxy premium yesterday…hope I get a great box..
Reply
Deb
I’m sooo sorry. Sending love and light your way. I have lost a few fur babies myself and I know how difficult it is.
Reply
Jacki
I like most of the items so this looks like a good box
Reply
Svetlana7e
I actually like all the items. Looking forward for this box!
Reply
Jamie-Lynn
I’m so annoyed bc I’m STILL WAITING on my Boxyluxe. I cancelled basebox and now wish I’d cancelled this as well.
Reply
Maria
You have to have basebox to get boxyluxe, because it’s an upgrade from base for that luxe month. They literally say this on the website, when you sign up, and it’s in the FAQ. Since you said you wish you also cancelled luxe, congrats cause it looks like you did since you cancelled base.
Reply
Hallie
I believe you have to have the base box to get luxe box unless you get premium box and cancel base box. This is how I understand it to work. I hope you get this worked out and get the box/boxes you are hoping for.
Reply
JL
I’m so very sorry friend. Sending you a big socially distanced hug
Reply
Megan
The brushes are from a company called Dynasty Group USA LLC. They look really cheap on their website.
Reply
JL
Great. I was just think they look cheap af
Reply
Ashley Marie
I am NOT FEELING these spoilers. I already have like 3 of those Wander Mile High Club mascaras. It’s always in sub boxes and doesn’t fit into the “premium” theme, IMO. Those brushes look like they came from Claire’s. It’s a no for me 🐶. If I get the ND brush palette and the Manny palette, I’ll be happy.
Reply
Jamey
That is the combo I am hoping for as well!!! I dont really want anything else here, and those brushes look cheap and the mascara I already have from allure and cant wear because it makes my eyes water.
Reply
Alice
When we can mail things again, I would be thrilled to take those mascaras off your hands.
Reply
Debbie
What do you mean when we can mail things again? I mail every day. The post office is still open. Besides the grocery store and Walmart, the post office is the one thing that is still open.
Ashley Marie
*blush
Reply
Jennifer
Time to take a break from premium😞 it started so strong but now regular boxy looks better..
Reply
JCN
Now that i see the natasha denona blish idk if i chose the right item, becca blush 🙁
Reply
Rebecca
The Becca blushes are really nice quality though. I have three of them Tigerlily, Flowerchild, and Camellia, I love all three. Hopefully once you receive it and try it out you’ll be glad you chose it 🤞
Reply
JL
Right!!!! Everything for these new April premium spoilers is a real stinker.
Reply
Dani
I wish I’d picked the Becca blush. I think it looks much higher quality than the ND. I normally lust after her products but I tried a blush/highlighter combo last year that was not impressive at all. I’m talking Wet ‘n Wild quality. And although this duo is not the exact same compact it’s not rated very highly. People complained about the lack of pigment and having to go over and over it which was exactly what I experienced. Unfortunately I picked the toner and then regretted it after reading tons of reviews. They were mostly positive but there were many people that said it was quite harsh. So it may not work for my super sensitive skin. I almost chose the blush because it looks so pigmented and I usually like Becca products but I have so many blushes already I thought I should pick something else. Had I known the ND blush would be a variant I definitely would’ve picked the blush. So don’t sweat it. You probably will be much happier with the Becca.
If you get it and still feel like you’d prefer the ND just post a comment and if I get a ND Blush duo I’d be happy to trade you.
Reply
Grace J Mock
I missed the choice, hoping for the ND blush, will be super bummed if I don’t it. I love all her products and some of them you do need to build up, her whole thing is she goes fro natural radiance, lit from within glow, so while it might not be super pigmented at first you can build it up to where you want, also I love that you can mix where you put stuff. You can use some of her cream blushes as lipsticks or even glossy eyes, you can add her duo chromes to the lips, everything is made to be multi functional, watch some of the videos she has on Sephora and you will see what i am talking about. i also wanted that toner too, so this box will be a complete surprise for me, would also love Manny MUA’s palette as well, just pleas not the PUR Barbie Palette. Ugh
Victoria schotter
I chose the becca blush for my box . I would love to trade with you if you get the natasha denona.
JCN
That makes sense, I’ve never been disappointed with Becca product yet. I guess the regret was from all of the hype about ND eyeshadows.
Toni Marie
I quit the base box and the boxyluxe sub because of the repeat sol de janeiro tiny bum bum creams were not fuul sized. I complained to boxycharm.andnthey claimed they were full-size. It’s crazy because the customer service has gotten so bad. All of those filler items were a mess..I’m thinking about getting rid of this subscription as well, depending on what my box looks like. I cashed in all of my charms except for $31 but I was cash those in soon.
I hope everyone is doing well in these hard times. Stay safe, happy and healthy during these hard times.
Reply
stephanie sierra
Super confused othe rthen the choice item I thought premium was the same for eveeryone
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.