Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
Macy's Beauty Box is $15 a month. Each month you will receive five deluxe beauty samples, one bonus item, a collectible cosmetics bag and a $5 beauty coupon exclusively for Beauty Box subscribers, available for use online and in-store.
Each month you will receive five deluxe beauty samples, one bonus item, and other beauty-related products. You'll also receive a $5 off $20+ beauty coupon exclusively for Beauty Box subscribers, available for use online and in-store.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Full spoilers for may have been out on hello subscription as well as other sites for several days. They are also on Macy’s website check beauty box.
Reply
Amy S
My box just arrived and – yep, 2 black eyeliners. COME ON!!!!!
Reply
Amy S
I should add: Natasha Moor’s eyeliner is new to me (which is the point of beauty boxes, I daresay) and only comes in black but Clinique’s Quickliner Intense for Eye comes in numerous lovely, useful colors. Any other color would have been a good complement to the black Natasha Moor.
Reply
Carlee
I received my April bag yesterday! On the last day of March! This is NOT my type of box as I don’t wear much makeup nor scents and love skincare. That said, this is a really nice box. I don’t care for makeup bags but this one is unique and very nice.
Reply
Kim
Billed me on Friday, shipped today. Usually, they don’t bill until around the 5th of the month. Can’t say, that I’m very excited for this one, two eyeliners and a makeup eraser. Will use everything else though.
Reply
JoJoB
Same here about the billing/shipping. I was very surprised. Guess I don’t have to worry if I’m receiving this one or not! 😂
Reply
Tina Ames
I got billed for the April box on Friday, and it was shipped today.
Reply
sokobaby
Love that primer and makeup eraser! Bag is cute.
I could’ve done without two black eyeliners but will gift one to a friend.
Reply
Janet Paulson
If you’re going to give us an eye shadow brush, I want the shadow to go with it!
Reply
Kim
I love These mini makeup erasers more than the full size. I only Need 4 to 6 inches to fix an errant dab, not 12 inches. Glad to get an eye pencil. The markers have me reaching for the makeup erasers! Can’t wait to see the bag in person.
Reply
Dee
Just got billed for the April box today. They are really on top of it this month!
Reply
LizzyD
Mine just got sent out today! It’s not even April. Surprised and hope this is an indication they will be more consistent and better organized than they were when they started up again.
Reply
Julie
I don’t care about the 2 black eyeliners, that bag totally makes up for it!! <—child of the 80's lol. And I am so happy to see fragrance back.
Reply
Denise
I have only received two boxes, but have been very pleased with the quality and quantity of what comes in this box. My favorite!
Reply
Susan
I have been getting the Macy’s box ever since they started and have gotten a lot of nice surprises. A few boxes ago I even got a ceramic flat iron! The themes are excellent and cooling eye mask from the March box is wonderful and soft. My facemask from FFF is not soft enough to conform to my face and has a rough surface. Sometimes there are 7 items and the value has always been high. The Jo Malone Macy’s box was worth a whole lot and included a candle with a nice bag and I think 5 good sized products. Macy’s, Allure, and now Glossbox for me! (Along with Walmart quarterly which can be hit or miss but there is usually at least one truly excellent product, something with a generous size amount, or stuff I won’t use and give to my cousin. The price for the Walmart box is so low I don’t mind as much as when a $12-23 box stinks!)
Reply
MrsLittle
When I click the subscribe now link, I get an error. Same when I search beauty box on their site. Is anyone else able to get it to work?
Reply
Linda
Same here. Error Linda
Reply
Hallie
2 black eyeliners? Is this an april fools joke? Hehe
Reply
Angela DeSilva
How boring! Last month wasn’t any better but before they took that break where they weren’t sending out anything it was really pretty good.
Reply
Myk
Yeah, this definitely feels grab-baggy to me. I mean, I could just cancel, I guess, but when it comes to Macy’s boxes, it’s always a pain to try to get back on the list. The times I have canceled, I’ve missed out on the “good” boxes because I would be put back on the waitlist. So whenever I think I really wanna cancel, I’m always like, “But what if the next box is *really* good?”
And that’s how they’ve been keeping me hooked lol
Reply
sara
This is exactly my situation too!
Reply
JuJu
Besides, you’ll still get this box if you cancel right now.
Reply
Sherry
Meh, I feel like these are all the leftover GWPs they couldn’t get rid of. And the makeup eraser and jimmy choo is a rerun. I’m glad I canceled.
Reply
Linda
Never got the makeup eraser in the past. And I have been a subscriber for a while 🤔.
Reply
Sherry Tamai
I don’t remember which box but I’m pretty sure it was this one. I was subbed since inception.
JuJu
Couldn’t they at least do a lipstick instead of one of the black eyeliners?.. 🙄
And an eyeshadow brush in absence of any eyeshadow also feels weird.
But the bag is nice, and I would have liked to try that primer.
Reply
NYMK
I was thinking the same! 2 eyeliners… both in black?!..at least the pencil one should’ve had a pop of color! and an eyeshadow brush to use for what in the April box exactly? Lol! I was expecting something Spring-ish for April’s box!
Reply
sara
This is some weird curation. A primer. Two black eye pencils. An eye shadow brush. A makeup remover cloth.
Pre pandemic, Macy’s boxes had curation that felt pulled together. For example, a mascara instead of 1 of the 2 black pencils, a single eye shadow to go with the brush instead of a primer. I can’t help but feel like we’re getting samples randomly now.
I do like that we’re back to getting perfumes, as that was a staple every month previously.
I used to be really, solidly happy with Macy’s. Now it’s more like “Well, I’ll use it, so it’s okay….”
Reply
Carol
Macys sends free fragrance samples all of the time and I have enough eyeliner to last for an eternity lol. The YSL primer would be nice though! I also like that Macy’s sends real brands that it sells.
Reply
Jennie
I’ve been wanting to cancel this sub, but I keep reading that there’s been a waste list for months! I really don’t need two eyeliners…
Reply
Blue
I’ve been on the waitlist since they announced they were starting back up boxes. I’m STILL waitlisted. It’s honestly a bit ridiculous at this point.
Reply
Nat
I am surprised they released spoilers so early. Usually it’s last Friday of the month. I do use black eyeliner but I prefer ink liner. However, these will be used as well. I would prefer them in different color though. Not both black.
Reply
ffflora
How long do you wait from the waitlist to actually subscribe it? I don’t need any of the item in this box so I canceled it, and then realized there might be months of waiting :/
Reply
Zo
The YSL primer is amazing. A little goes a long way so even the trial size will last.
Reply
Amy S
Please tell me we’re not getting two black eyeliners. ONE black eyeliner is one too many.
Reply
Tina Ames
Not a fan of the April bag, so if they tell me they can not send it to me, I will not be sad.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.