Facebook PixelAn Introvert’s Thanksgiving: Jessica’s Non-Traditional Holiday Meal | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

An Introvert’s Thanksgiving: Jessica’s Non-Traditional Holiday Meal

Jessica Hapak
ByJessica HapakNov 29, 2021 | 9 comments

Thanksgiving is unfortunately over, and I am dreading going back to work this morning (honestly, I actually think I started getting the Sunday scaries on Friday afternoon?). Thankfully, at least, I feel rested and ready to push through until Christmas, where I'll get a week off from work and be able to spend it with my boyfriend, who has been away with the military for the past two months. How did I do that? I spent my Thanksgiving holiday how I wanted, not how others expected.

cat in cat shaped cat bed

I love Thanksgiving, and any holiday really that involves good food and football. This is a holiday that puts Jessica in her happy place. When I went to law school, I learned that Thanksgiving, as I used to know and celebrate it, was a thing of the past since law school finals always started the week after. Sure, I'm not in law school anymore, but I already have gotten out of the habit of a somewhat more traditional Thanksgiving, thanks to studying for toxic torts with a plate of green bean casserole in front of me. I love my family, and my dad's side of the family is huge, so I always have family I could spend it with. But none of them live in Louisiana, and no matter who I went to spend the holiday with, half of the time would have been spent traveling... and that isn't how I wanted to spend this reprieve from work, which has been super stressful lately. Instead, I spent it alone with my cat, Goose. Truly, it was awesome;  I wore the same comfy sweatshirt every day and no one was there to care, and I didn't have any set schedule to follow or expectations to live up to.  I did a sheet mask every day, spent too much money shopping deals, and drank wine. It was me, Goose, and all of the professional and college football I could handle. It was heaven.

plate of thanksgiving food

Of course, that doesn't mean I didn't eat traditional Thanksgiving foods. I love to cook, and have no issue cooking a Thanksgiving meal just for me because I find it fun. I knew I would go way overboard if I went to the grocery store though, s0 I didn't even bother. Instead, I signed up for the Blue Apron Thanksgiving meal kit and had everything I needed (except wine, but they do offer wine pairings) delivered to my door on Tuesday afternoon. No crowded grocery stores? No super insane grocery bill due to me taking on too much? I loved it. And the food was fantastic; those brown butter fontina mashed potatoes were some of the best mashed potatoes I have ever had, and since I still have some leftover I'm probably going to heat some up when I am done typing this. Doing it this way meant I didn't have stuffing with maple sausage or green bean casserole with extra fried onions on top, but those are things I can always make for Christmas or another time. And really, my Blue Apron box was designed to feed 6-8 people- I didn't need to make more sides to go with it. I will be 100% honest and tell you I am super proud of this Thanksgiving meal I made all by myself. Sure, the Blue Apron instructions made it easy- I am still accepting praise in the comments below.

cookie cake

Spending Thanksgiving hidden away in my lair also allowed me to do something pretty different for Thanksgiving dessert. The Blue Apron kit came with the ingredients for an apple pie, but I actually have never liked apple pie. Even the pies I do like, like pumpkin or pecan, are good but aren't my favorite dessert. And if I'm allowed extra dessert calories because of the holiday, I decided to use them on one of my favorite treats: a cookie cake from the Great American Cookies company. This thing was huge - I definitely am bringing a bunch to work tomorrow to share. It was also incredibly delicious. The color scheme is a little off, but that's what happens when I am given the ability to control the colors of icing during checkout and don't like chocolate frosting. This was an absolute treat, and I am definitely team cookie cake for next Thanksgiving too.

breakfast quiche

Thanks to my cookie cake choice, I had an extra pie crust laying around. I could have put it in the freezer to use at a later date, but instead I chose to make a breakfast quiche using random ingredients in my fridge and some of the potatoes in the Blue Apron box - I definitely didn't need all of them to go into the mashed potatoes. This was my first time making a quiche but it won't be my last, because this thing was delicious.

suggestions for thanksgiving leftovers

I d0 have a ton of leftovers. When I was growing up, the day after Thanksgiving my mom would always make turkey tacos for everyone to eat while watching college football. I think the record of most tacos eaten by a family member was 13 by a cousin, and I love those memories. I have all of the ingredients to follow that family tradition at some point, but that hasn't actually happened yet because I have embraced the laziness that is spending a holiday weekend alone. I did appreciate how the Blue Apron information sheets came with ideas for how to use leftovers - I don't like apple pie but I still want to try an apple pie milkshake.

 

This was my nontraditional Thanksgiving: I was able to be lazy, relax, and eat cookie cake, and I genuinely have no complaints other than the fact that the past few days feel like they have gone so fast. I could see how it can be hard to spend this holiday alone if you're used to spending it with loved ones, and I definitely empathize. If you're ever in a position where you're unable to celebrate a holiday with people you love, take a page out of my book and focus on doing some of your favorite things. Maybe you don't like football the way I do- watch binge-watch your favorite tv show. Get your favorite dessert, whether it's pie or cookie cake or something else altogether (my vote is cookie cake though).


Did you celebrate Thanksgiving in a nontraditional way? Let us know what you did in the comments below.

Jessica Hapak
Jessica Hapak
I am a staunch believer that pineapple doesn’t belong on pizza and when I’m not working as a family law attorney I enjoy hiking the Louisiana trails (alligator sightings are a favorite!) or relaxing with Duchess, my cat. I’m a sucker for anything labeled a mystery box and I’ve never met a bath bomb I didn’t like.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

9 comments

April

Jessica, a woman after my own heart!

After years of thinking I was an extrovert, I realized how much I enjoy taking time out to just be by myself (and my pup). That quiche looks INSANE. The cookie-cake also reminds me of the Mrs. Fields one I used to lust after at the local mall as a teenager.

I’m so glad you got to celebrate the holiday the way you wanted 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Snow

Good golly it’s me again. Just wanted to apologize for asking if you were a divorce lawyer… I know that’s not the best term to use as you are way more than that. Ugh foot in mouth.

Reply ButtonReply

Carrie

I greatly enjoyed your non-traditional Thanksgiving story.
I work every major holiday (the joys of being in healthcare) so haven’t truly cooked a Thanksgiving meal in years. We usually do a meal for four from Whole Foods but I also worked the Friday and weekend following Thanksgiving this year, so we didn’t even do that much. It was turkey TV dinners for my father and I, and we didn’t care in the least. As pitiful as it may sound to nuke two Hungry Man meals for Thanksgiving, it was actually totally stress-free; no running to the store the day before to pick up the food, no timing issues trying to figure out what to heat first, no mounds of dishes to wash afterward, and cheap. We don’t plan on making it a tradition, but it worked for us with zero regrets.

Reply ButtonReply

Jessica Hapak

I love this for you, Carrie! Like you I don’t think this will become a permanent tradition of mine (except maybe the cookie cake), but the fact that it was stress-free was such a delight

Reply ButtonReply

Snow

I really appreciated this, Jessica! As someone who has very little family (and the family I do have there always seems to be issues/complications), holidays can be incredibly bittersweet. Maybe it’s the frame of mind? Someone who has options (aka family), but chooses to spend the holiday alone versus someone who has nobody and is forced to spend it alone. I know I am a bit of a Scrooge when it comes to holidays. Instead of spotlighting everything good, I see everything and everyone that I lost (and not just through death). I know this wasn’t supposed to be a depressing article, but spending holidays alone is a real thing and not always by choice. I’m glad, Jessica, you were able to take advantage of your alone time and make it fun. Definitely better and healthier than wallowing in self pity with a big box of tissues which is probably what I would have done (and have done 😣).

Reply ButtonReply

Jessica Hapak

Hey Snow!
I definitely know what you mean about lonely holidays. My dad died when I was 17 and before that he was in the ICU for two months from December-February. It definitely made the holidays after feel really lonely, even if I was with other family members. It’s not always easy to look at something with a positive frame of mind when the reality of your circumstances is different than what you wished it were. For me, I think I was able to look at it so positively because work has been insanely, insanely stressful for the past few months, and I was ecstatic for any kind of break from it. I focused on that, rather than the things I was missing out on. I hope you have a lovely month of December, and I’m always here if you want to talk more- I check my content for comments almost obsessively 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Snow

You are definitely on top of your game, Jessica! (I can tell 😉). Divorce lawyer, right? I totally could have used you several years ago…I had the biggest dufus as a lawyer and ended up firing him 😬. Family court, argh!!
And I am incredibly sorry about your dad! Didn’t mean to make this all depressing, but I do appreciate you sharing about your life.
Thanks for picking me up! Sometimes just having someone care (even over the internet) is enough. ☺️

Mary Zubritsky

Awww, Snow! <3

Reply ButtonReply

Snow

Just needed to unleash a little I’ll be fine ☺️