Armoire vs. Nuuly: Which Clothing Rental Service Is Queen?

I’m always on the lookout for ways to simplify my wardrobe while still looking polished for everything from Zoom meetings to casual weekend outings. 

With clothing rental services booming, two that had my attention were Armoire and Nuuly. Both offer something unique, but I wanted to be certain the service I chose fit my lifestyle and had the most perks. (Who doesn’t love perks?) I decided to give both a try to find out which rental service really reigns supreme when it comes to convenience, style versatility, and overall value.

The more affordable one… Armoire

Clothing rental is always going to save you money, but ongoing cost is still a factor. Nuuly is priced at $98 per month with no stylist to help you find the best pieces for you. Armoire starts at $89 per month with the help of a stylist who’s invested in understanding your preferences and knows their inventory. 

That’s a way better value for money, especially since the pieces are more versatile and suited for both work and leisure. Plus, Armoire offers flexible plans, and the quality of clothing means fewer swaps, which is a huge time-saver. 

When it comes to convenience… Armoire

I need a service that makes my life easier, not more complicated. Armoire delivers on that with a super intuitive app, fast shipping, and free returns. With Armoire’s unlimited plan, you can swap out your items as often as you like (or otherwise once per month), making it perfect for those who need fresh outfits frequently, whether you’re dressing your best for in-office meetings or casual Fridays.

Nuuly, while straightforward in its rental process, isn’t as flexible. It’s more catered to those looking for trendy pieces for special occasions, and I found it time-consuming to sift through their inventory and curate versatile outfits for both work and play. 

The more trendy one… Nuuly

More on that: if you’re all about keeping up with the latest wild trends, Nuuly’s on it. Their selection is bold, fashion-forward, and full of unique statement pieces that are fun to experiment with. Think neon crop tops and boho festival dresses.

But as a professional woman who needs my clothes to be functional and versatile while still feeling current, I found Armoire’s selection more practical for my everyday life. Armoire focuses on high-quality, timeless pieces that easily transition from a business meeting to brunch. They carry brands both familiar and new-to-me, and all are women-owned.

The one with a stylist to help you achieve your best outfits… Armoire

One of the things that sets Armoire apart is their personal stylist service. As someone who doesn’t have hours to spend scrolling through endless outfits, having a stylist recommend pieces based on my preferences is amazing. She helps me curate looks that not only fit my style but also work perfectly for it all, from Zoom meetings and office days to brunch with the girls.

Nuuly doesn’t offer the same level of personalized service, and while I can see how some might find it fun to browse through their trendy pieces, I just got a headache. I know who I am and what I like, and so I don’t need my shopping feed to include items Gen Zers would wear. 

Armoire checks all the boxes

At the end of the day, Armoire wins out for me as the best clothing rental service out there. Its focus on versatility, convenience, and personalized styling makes it the ideal choice for women who need to look polished without spending hours shopping or stressing about what to wear. While Nuuly offers an exciting selection for those looking to experiment with fashion, Armoire checks all the boxes for a busy professional like me.

If you’re looking for a service that can simplify your wardrobe, help you feel confident in your outfits, and save you time, give Armoire a try.