Facebook PixelCAKES vs. Amazon Nipple Covers: I Tested Both So You Don’t Have To – And The Results Were Shocking | My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction

CAKES vs. Amazon Nipple Covers: I Tested Both So You Don’t Have To – And The Results Were Shocking

Madeline Kopp
ByMadeline KoppJan 31, 2025Sponsored

I have vacation planned and I am ready to ditch my bra. Tank tops, dresses, and backless shirts are calling my name. That said, I don't want to deal with the age-old issue of my girls poking through. That's when I decided it was time for find some trustworthy nipple covers.

I saw CAKES on TikTok, and people in the comments were raging about their longevity and no-stick grip. Honestly, I found it hard to believe nipple covers could be worth $30, so I decided to compare them to the generic, cheaper alternatives from Amazon. The results were pretty shocking... here's what I learned:

If you want nipple covers with no irritating adhesive... CAKES!

As someone with sensitive skin, finding nipple covers that wouldn’t cause redness, itchiness, or discomfort was a top priority. Unlike some of the cheaper options that use harsh adhesives, CAKES OG Nipple Covers are grippy, NOT sticky. 

How? These bad boys grip skin using natural body heat! They’re made with 100% medical grade silicone and go through extensive skin safety and toxicity testing to ensure they’re as gentle as possible. That means no irritation—just comfortable, seamless coverage that lasted all day long.

If you want nipple covers that don't show through...CAKES!

I assumed all nipple covers were seamless, and I was mistaken. The generic ones I got created weird bulges (the sizing was way off) and showed through my white t-shirt, making it obvious that I had flower petals on my nipples—sigh 🌸.

*Super obvious* flower petals...
CAKES: you can't even tell! ☝️

CAKES, on the other hand, are super seamless. They have a wide range of size options, so whether you’re a part of the itty bitty titty committee, or in the DD+ range, you’ll be covered (literally). Their smooth, tapered edge is invisible, and they were originally designed as a sports bra/bathing suit cup alternative, so they’re perfect for putting under any kind of fabric. Even really thin ones.

They truly provide a no-show coverage that blends effortlessly under all types of clothes… white T-shirts included.

If you want nipple covers that will actually last you ($$$)… CAKES

While generic nipple covers from the drugstore might save you a few bucks upfront, you'll end up spending more in the long run because you’ll have to keep replacing them. 

CAKES are designed to last for hundreds of uses. Just wash them with gentle soap and warm water after each wear, and they'll be good as new.

While I wasn't sure about the $30 investment in CAKES at first – I'm blown away. Trust me, you'll never have to make the purchase again.

If you want nipple covers that stay put for one night... Tie

There's nothing worse than nipple covers that slip, slide, and end up stuck to your stomach halfway through the night. And as someone who has a lot of weddings to attend this summer, I need to make sure I don’t accidentally steal attention away from the bride.

I tested each set of covers by jumping, dancing, stretching, and distorting my body in ways that are just unnatural… I really wanted to make sure they’d stay put. The options I got from Target and Amazon were alright – honestly, they did the trick for the night. That said, I wouldn't trust them for more than one or two uses.

CAKES OG Nipple Covers felt so natural I forgot I had them on, and even after taking them off and putting them back on over and over again, I'm confident they will last me hundreds of wears.

I can't live without CAKES OG Nipple Covers

When it comes down to it, althought I was skeptical about the price, CAKES OG Nipple Covers are the clear winner. From their innovative grippy-not-sticky design to their invisible coverage, these nipple covers have everything I'm looking for. 

Plus, they’re a women-owned business that donates $1 from every purchase to breast cancer research. Not only do I get to avoid embarrassing nip slips, I get to participate in an important cause. Win-win!