If you're anything like me, enjoying dinner at home is the most exciting part of your day. But if you’re also like me, nothing deflates your excitement faster than low quality ingredients—especially meat, the true star of the meal. ⭐️
Luckily, I found two great ways to source high-quality, mouth-watering meats and seafood, all without having to get dressed and leave my house: Good Chop and ButcherBox. Both have their pros (psst...free wings!) and cons, but there’s definitely a clear winner.
Here’s how these online butchers compare:
If you want to choose your own meats WITHOUT an added fee... Good Chop
Unlike ButcherBox, all Good Chop boxes -- even the lowest cost options -- are totally customizable, and I’m able to choose whichever six cuts I want for my next shipment, every time. There’s also a quality guarantee, so they’ll refund you 100% if you aren’t impressed.
ButcherBox technically offers customizable boxes, too, but only at a higher price point. When it comes to beef offering, Good Chop comes on top as it offers both 100% grass-fed as well as grain-finished options, while ButcherBox does only the former.
So while both ButcherBox and Good Chop offer an outstanding variety of delicious meats—from grass-fed beef, to free-range chicken, vegetarian-fed pork, and even wild-caught seafood—only Good Chop fully commits to putting the reins in all of their customer’s hands.
For a lower price point and added perks (free wings anyone?)… Good Chop
There's no question who the winner is for value. Good Chop is currently offering $100 off across your first three boxes and free wings for life.
If you sign up now, you get free wings with every order for the life of your membership AND $100 off across your first 3 boxes. With this deal, Good Chop's lowest-priced box starts at $99 -- compare that to ButcherBox's lowest-priced box at $146.
Plus with Good Chop, you get to choose both your own cuts and selection of seafood at this price point, whereas the ButcherBox selection at this tier is curated only and does not include seafood.
If you're a more cost-conscious customer or simply looking to get the most bang for your buck, I'd go with Good Chop.
If you prefer to let someone else do the choosing… ButcherBox
If you’re the type of person who’s happy to sit back, relax, and let your subscription services take the wheel, ButcherBox is a good choice. After you pick your protein of choice, their curated plan chooses your cuts for you. I personally like choosing my own meats so I can plan my recipes around my box, so Good Chop was a better option for me.
It's also worth noting that seafood isn’t part of the ButcherBox curated plan, so if you’re looking for fish, you might want to consider an alternative.
For meats sourced exclusively from domestic farms and fisheries… Good Chop
When it comes to sustainability and responsible sourcing, both Good Chop and ButcherBox impress me. However, Good Chop is a clear winner when it comes to supporting local economies and maintaining high-quality standards.
Good Chop sources their beef, pork, chicken, and seafood from American family farms and independent ranchers. On the other hand, ButcherBox's beef mainly comes from Australia and it's unclear where their chicken and pork come from.
Good Chop's commitment to quality and sustainability ensures none of their products have artificial ingredients, added hormones, growth promotants, antibiotics, or preservatives. The commitment pays off; I was truly impressed with how tender and juicy my steaks were.
For an option that delivers on price, quality, and convenience… Good Chop!
I must say, Good Chop really impressed me. With a service like this, I can’t see myself ever leaving my house to buy meat again.
Good Chop sends me high-quality American meat and seafood in an extensive variety of cuts, sourced ethically, and priced affordably. It definitely checks all my boxes, and that’s without considering taste (which is amazing, by the way).
So, if you're looking for the best way to savor tender, high-quality cuts of meat and seafood without having to put on shoes, you need to take a look at Good Chop. And you get free wings for life - I mean, who wouldn't want that?
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. It's our goal to help our readers discover exciting products and services that deliver the best version of their lives. Because of this, we participate in sponsored affiliate and paid social whitelisting programs to introduce our readers to new products. However, the articles hosted on My Subscription Addiction continue to accurately reflect the experiences of the author.
