When my French Bulldog, Christian Louboutin, started showing signs of digestive discomfort—occasional loose stools, a little extra gas (sorry, Christian)—I started researching probiotics for dogs. The internet is flooded with options, and like any concerned dog mom, I wasn’t about to give him just anything.
I narrowed it down to three top-rated picks:
➡️ Zesty Paws Probiotic Bites
➡️ Pet Honesty Digestive Probiotics
They all claimed to support gut health, balance the microbiome, and promote healthy stools—but only one brand actually backed that up with clean ingredients, visible results, and a formula I felt good about giving Christian every day.
Here’s how they stack up across five key areas that matter most when it comes to your dog’s digestive health:
The one with quality, human-grade ingredients… JFFD
Let’s start with the most important piece: what’s actually in these chews?
When I opened the JustFoodForDogs container, I was genuinely surprised. These chews looked like tiny superfood energy bites—dense, dark, and packed with visible ingredients like carrots, broccoli, and blueberries. And they smelled like real food.
Here’s what the JFFD formula includes:
- Whole-food, human-grade ingredients like sweet potatoes, coconut oil, and oats
- Plant-based fibers to support digestion
- Natural preservatives like sea salt and vinegar
- Zero artificial flavorings or fillers
Now compare that to Zesty Paws and Pet Honesty:
- Zesty Paws: Garbanzo flour, pea flour, powdered cellulose, palm fruit oil, “natural chicken flavor,” and citric acid.
- Pet Honesty: Oat flour, vegetable glycerin, sunflower lecithin, and the vague “natural flavors” (a red flag for hidden preservatives).
Zesty Paws and Pet Honesty look and smell like processed treats. JFFD? It looks like something I’d eat after yoga.
The one that actually helped my dog’s digestion… JFFD
All three supplements promised the same thing: better digestion, healthier stools, and balanced gut flora. I gave each one a solid two-week trial and here’s what I noticed:
- Zesty Paws: Minimal improvement. Stools were inconsistent.
- Pet Honesty: Slightly better stool quality, but Christian seemed gassy and bloated.
- JustFoodForDogs: By week two, his poop was (finally!) consistent, firmer, and he seemed visibly more energetic.
I know each dog is different—but for us, JFFD worked faster and more consistently.
The one Christian actually wanted to eat… JFFD
Christian is picky. He once turned down a piece of grilled salmon. So flavor matters.
With Zesty Paws, he sniffed and walked away. I had to crush the chew and hide it in his food. Pet Honesty got a similar reaction—he’d chew it eventually, but never excitedly.
But the JustFoodForDogs chew? Gone in under 10 seconds. No bribery needed. And from what I’ve read, he’s not alone—their reviews are full of picky eaters who love these.
The cheaper option… Tie
Okay, here’s where I’ll give credit where it’s due.
- Pet Honesty gives you 90 chews per jar and tends to be the most budget-friendly per serving $29.
- Zesty Paws gives 90 chews as well, but costs slightly more ($29).
- JustFoodForDogs gives you 45 chews per container, and it is a premium product Right now, you can get it for 50% off ($15)!
But this is where I asked myself: Do I want more of a product with artificial flavors and fillers? Or the right amount of something made with better ingredients?
Final Verdict: I’m Sticking With JustFoodForDogs
Let’s be real: all three probiotic chews will technically give your dog some gut support. But only one brand did it with integrity, transparency, and real, whole food ingredients I recognized and trusted.
JustFoodForDogs is the first human-grade supplement for dogs, and you can see the difference in every single cube. It’s clean, backed by science, made with ingredients I’d eat myself, and most importantly—Christian loves it.
When it comes to gut health, I’m not settling. And thanks to JustFoodForDogs, I don’t have to.
