Facebook PixelJust Food for Dogs vs. Zesty Paws vs. Pet Honesty: Which Probiotic is Expert-Approved? | My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction

Just Food for Dogs vs. Zesty Paws vs. Pet Honesty: Which Probiotic is Expert-Approved?

Danielle Harter, MS, PA-C
ByDanielle Harter, MS, PA-CApr 8, 2025Sponsored

Probiotics are a powerful way to support your dog’s digestive health, immune system, and overall well-being. My Frenchie, Christian Louboutin, was gassy and had loose stools, so I knew he needed probiotics. I just had no idea where to begin, and some of the differences I found completely shocked me.

Just Food for Dogs, Zesty Paws, and Pet Honesty are some of the most popular brands, but which one is truly the best? I took a closer look at their offerings to help you make the best decision for your furry friend. Here’s what I found.

The one that's vet-formulated and really works… Just Food for Dogs

I couldn’t believe that when I looked into the details of these three brands, Just Food for Dogs is the only one that offers a veterinarian formulated supplement.

What!? Not only that, they’re the first human-grade pet chews on the market. 

Their Probiotic Live Chews contain 3 billion CFUs (colony-forming units) per chew and are made with natural, whole-food ingredients to support gut health beyond just probiotics.

What really sets Just Food for Dogs apart is their use of strains like Lactobacillus acidophilus and Bifidobacterium animalis, which are backed by research and chosen specifically for their digestive benefits in dogs. And the results speak for themselves – my dog's digestion is smoother, his stools are more consistent, and he’s had less tummy trouble overall. It’s amazing how much of a difference the right probiotics can make!

Zesty Paws and Pet Honesty offer solid options, but they lack the same clinical precision that Just Food for Dogs provides. I don’t know about you, but I wouldn't trust my dog’s gut health with anyone but the experts.

The one with whole ingredients my dog actually likes… Just Food for Dogs

If ingredient quality is a top priority for you, Just Food for Dogs it is. Their chews use whole foods like broccoli, blueberries, and coconut oil, easy to pronounce ingredients with tangible benefits. They also use natural preservatives like sea salt and white vinegar, no synthetic additives.

And the best part? My dog actually loves eating them. No more hiding probiotics in treats or mixing them into meals—he eagerly chews these up like they’re a reward. It’s a win-win: he gets the digestive and immune support he needs, and I get the peace of mind knowing he’s enjoying every bite.

Zesty Paws lists ingredients like garbanzo flour, pea flour, and citric acid, aka…fillers. Pet Honesty’s right there too with oat flour and vegetable glycerin. Both of these brands use more processed fillers, some of which counteract the purpose of the probiotic.

The cheapest probiotic option… Zesty Paws

When it comes to price, Zesty Paws is often the most budget-friendly choice at $25.97 for 90 chews. Pet Honesty offers $26.99 for 90 chews, but at a higher potency.

Just Food for Dogs costs $29.99 for 45 soft chews, which is certainly more of an investment, but you’re paying for premium quality and vet-formulated, human-grade ingredients that are third-party tested. To me, those details are non-negotiable and worth every penny.

The one with nutrition plans customized for YOUR dog… Just Food for Dogs

Just Food for Dogs takes a personalized approach that sets it apart from the others. Instead of a one-size-fits-all supplement, JFFD offers customized nutrition plans tailored specifically to Christian Louboutin’s unique needs—and your dog’s, too.

Whether your pup requires support for digestion, immunity, or skin health, their supplements are designed to work in tandem with a vet-recommended diet. This holistic approach ensures that your dog gets exactly what they need. For pet parents who view their dog as a family member (which is all of us, RIGHT?), Just Food for Dogs provides a thoughtful, individualized solution.

Just Food for Dogs does probiotics best

If you’re like me, you know not all supplements are created equally. Luckily, I’ve done the research so you don’t have to! Just Food for Dogs is the only human-grade probiotic chew for pets that’s vet-formulated, clean, and crafted with your dog’s overall health in mind.

With natural, whole-food ingredients and the expertise of veterinary professionals, this is the top choice for your pup’s digestive health. Ready to give your dog the same high-quality care you’d want for yourself? I can’t recommend Just Food for Dogs Probiotic Live Chews enough—Christian Louboutin and I are definitely fans!

Posted in Uncategorized