Look, I’ve worn a lot of T-shirts in my life. But when you’re actually working in a T-shirt—not just wearing it to hang out—you start noticing the little things. The way a shirt moves with you (or doesn’t), how it handles sweat, and whether it keeps its shape or ends up sagging halfway through the day.
So when I got my hands on True Classic’s Active Crew 6-Pack and Carhartt’s Loose-Fit Heavyweight Short-Sleeve Pocket T-Shirt, I decided to put them to the real-life test. Not just “try them on in front of a mirror” test. I mean wear them out, work in them, throw them in the wash, and see which one earns a spot in my drawer.
Here’s what I found.
If you want a flattering fit that makes moves with you… True Classic
When you’re working, a bad-fitting T-shirt just gets in the way—too tight, and it’s restrictive; too loose, and it’s constantly shifting or snagging on things.
True Classic nails the balance. It’s fitted in the right places but relaxed where it matters, so whether you’re lifting, bending, or reaching, it moves with you instead of against you. And when the workday’s over? It looks good enough to wear straight to dinner.
Plus, no itchy tags, and the fabric holds its shape wash after wash—no stretching, no shrinking.
Carhartt, on the other hand, runs roomy—maybe too roomy. It’s durable but bulky, and the chest pocket adds to the workwear look, making it not as easy to dress up.
If you want comfort that lasts all day (and then some)... True Classic
True Classic nailed the comfort game using high-performance fabric that wicks sweat, dries fast, and even fights odor. I wore it on a long, nonstop workday and it stayed comfortable the entire time. The fabric is so soft and lightweight that it almost feels like you’re wearing pajamas—but in the best way possible. Plus, the UPF 30 protection is a nice touch for those sunny days.
Carhartt is built tough. The heavyweight fabric feels durable and reliable, but that comes with a trade-off: it’s thick and not nearly as breathable. It’s a no-frills, classic cotton tee—great for those who prefer a sturdy, traditional feel without the added performance features.
If you want a ton of color options... Carhartt
True Classic’s 6-pack comes with six staple colors—Black, Carbon, Light Heather Gray, Military Green, White, and Navy—giving you an easy, versatile set right out of the box.
But if you’re looking for a specific shade, they also offer 19 individual color options, including subtle neutrals like Heather Charcoal and Dark Heather Tempest, as well as earthy tones like Military Green.
Carhartt, however, still takes the win for sheer variety, offering 23 colors with brighter options like Bright Lime and Cobalt Blue alongside their classic earth tones. So if you want a pop of color or just slightly more selection, Carhartt edges ahead.
If you want to stay fresh all day... True Classic
Nothing’s worse than a T-shirt that traps sweat and stinks by noon—especially if you’re working outside or constantly on the move. True Classic’s fabric is lightweight, breathable, and designed to wick away sweat, so you’re not stuck in a damp, heavy shirt halfway through the day. Even after hours in the sun, it stays dry and doesn’t hold onto odors.
Carhartt, on the other hand, is thick and durable but not nearly as breathable. The heavyweight cotton absorbs sweat instead of pulling it away, and once it’s damp, it stays that way. I’ve made the mistake of wearing it on hot days, and after a few hours, it felt heavy, clingy, and straight-up uncomfortable.
If you want the best bang for your buck… True Classic
I like getting the most for my money, and True Classic’s 6-Pack at $119.99 (about $20 per shirt) just makes sense. You get a full set of high-quality T-shirts, and you’re set for the whole week.
Plus, they offer a 20% discount for first responders, medical professionals, teachers, students, and military personnel—so if you qualify, it’s an even better deal.
Carhartt’s tees are sold individually for $24.99 each. They’re tough and long-lasting, but you’re not getting any of the performance perks like moisture-wicking or odor control.
So which one do I actually wear the most?
I still have both in my closet. But when I reach for a T-shirt, 9 times out of 10, it’s a True Classic. It fits better. It’s more comfortable. It works for more occasions. And honestly? It just feels better to wear.
For work, hot days, or anything active, the Active Crew is my go-to—it’s lightweight, breathable, and doesn’t trap sweat or stink. But True Classic also has a non-active line that’s a bit heavier, while still being breathable.
Thinking about upgrading your T-shirt drawer? Check out the True Classic Active Crew 6-Pack and see why I’m never going back to stiff, heavy tees.
