Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
Nina is an award-winning author, "Project Runway" judge, and the Creative Director of [Marie Claire]. She sends her favorite fashion finds, plus other cultural gems.
Shipping is free to the US. (Canada +$30; rest of world +$40)
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Yikes I’d be embarrassed to wear that out in the pasture where nothing buts cows and horses could see me!
Sorry Nina…you’re out.
Reply
h
Does the Box come with bail money to get me out of jail for indecent exposure of my lady bumps?
Reply
Amy
One word…. “Ballin'”
Reply
Helen Whaley
OMG, yes! I couldn’t unsubscribe fast enough when that Ballin’ hat came out. I think now they’re just having a laugh.
“Let’s see how many suckers fall for this one.”
Reply
Julie B.
I like how it says WHITE is an exclusive color! Actually if it were a mermaid-ish ombre color it would be nice.
Reply
Christina
Man, I’m gonna look hot when I go out wearing this and my gorgeous Muito cool hat and fringed fish clutch from a couple of years back. That’s my summer/fall look. For the winter I’ll pair it with the ballin cap and fringe crossbody.
Reply
anita
i don’t sub to this box, but my first thought when i clicked to see the spoiler was “what am I looking at here?”
Reply
Luna
Haha… I thought the same thing! I was thinking, “there’s no way they’re saying to wear this as a top.” (I didn’t bother reading the description until comments started to post). Due to my lack of fashion sense, I figured I had to be mis-interpreting the drawing, so I thought I’d wait to see how others commented on the spoiler in case I was missing something. ha!
Reply
TK
This has got to be the worst spoiler I’ve ever seen but the most hilarious comments I’ve ever read!
Reply
WendyM
I’ll only wear this if the white fabric is light enough to also see through. 😱
Reply
Wendy
😂😂😂!!!
Reply
L
Girl, sit down.
I mean, I could never pull it off like that sketch can.
Reply
Hillary
This is super disappointing. Nina is always all about dresses where a woman can comfortably wear a bra in project runway. I’ve never been that tempted by this sub due to the price, but now it’s a hard pass for sure.
Reply
Julie
Oh boy! After having three kids there is no way I could pull this off. It would give my sisters a good laugh if I tried.😂😂 There is no way I could leave my house like that.
Reply
Amy
What are the chances this “versatile wrap top” is the same as the “extended wrap tie” that comes with this shirt?
Sorry, but my first reaction after following the link… straight jacket!
I guess I’m not fashion forward enough. It doesn’t look comfortable either.
Reply
Stefanie
Omg its totally a straight jacket!!!! People wear that, like purposely!?! Lol im dying here! I must be so unfashionable and behind the fashion times too….😱
Amy
First thought upon seeing the email: LOL
Second thought: a TOP slash BELT slash SCARF LOLOL
Third thought: OMG I can’t read to read the comments on MSA
Only 18 left?! Good news, ladies! Now there are 19.
Reply
Chris
20 now 😁
Reply
Jae
I don’t get it, this ships Aug and they just sent this spoiler now on the 22nd? And they couldn’t even provide an actual photo of the spoiled item? Sigh.
Reply
Julie
It looks like something Cher would have worn in the old Sonny and Cher days (yes, I’m that old)
Reply
robyn
This is how I used to wrap my maternity photography clients. You know for “boudoir” type shots. That they only hung in their bedrooms. I can’t even. I am all out of evens.
Reply
Sharon in SE TX
I think I saw it in a Huey Lewis and the News video. I’m old too.
Reply
Marion
I like the idea/theme of the box… but that doesn’t seem like a good choice for the first spoiler.
Reply
Tanya
You know… had they modelled this item as a scarf or a wrap they may have found a lot more love from potential subscribers. Giving us a design of the lady version of a banana hammock makes me wanna run for the hills
Reply
Amy
I agree 100% that this would’ve been better received had they presented it as a scarf or belt, but I think they almost had to call it a top to make it seem like the value is there. It’s ridiculous as a top for obvious reasons, and it’s ridiculous as a scarf or belt because it’s a $225 strip of fabric.
For crying out loud.
Reply
Jess
OMG YES!!! The front view reminds me of those ta ta towels!
Reply
Dawn S
Holy moly I just learned there is such a thing as a Ta-Ta Towel!!! I am laughing so hard. Between this “shirt” (which if you look at Tomes site they seem to have a very conservative style unlike this sad attempt) and the Ta-Ta Towel I am dying.
WendyM
lol that’s what I thought! And just why isn’t the Ta-ta towel in any subscription box? A coveted swap item for sure 😂
whitpick
Is this the April Fool’s Box?
Reply
Jillian
We need groceries, you say? Sure, let me just put on my transparent white boob sling on my 34 DDD boobs and pop out to get what we need. That won’t be inappropriate at all. I’m sure my boobs won’t fall accidentally fall out. At 37 years old and a size 10-12 I’m totally comfortable letting it all hang out to get milk. 😒🤦🏻♀️
Reply
Amy
This!
Reply
Ragan
I am a 34B and a size 0-2 and I wouldn’t wear it either…
Reply
Charlie
Lol all these great comments
Reply
Rachel
I literally could not unsubscribe fast enough!!!! Iv jut had a baby…. lol… no one needs to see me in a flimsy wrap top 😂
Reply
Heather
I. Can’t. Even.
Reply
Betty
A very out of touch with normal people pick. Not many people can wear a boulder holder.
Reply
Amyr
This would not be a good look for most women. It might look OK as part of a dance outfit. I am sticking with Rachel Zoe. She keeps it classy.
Reply
Amyr
I was considering this box but that top is not attractive. It loo Aks vulgar…and white? Rachel Zoe keeps it classy. I can’t believe a box would offer something like this!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.