Facebook PixelFabFitFun Winter Editor's Box - Available Now + Full Spoilers! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

FabFitFun Winter Editor’s Box – Available Now + Full Spoilers!

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanDec 28, 2018 | 59 comments

FabFitFun
3.7 overall rating
1036 Ratings | 177 Reviews

The new FabFitFun Winter Editor’s Box is available now for new subscribers! (If you sign up for a subscription now, this will be your first box.)

FYI - if you are a current subscriber, you can buy this box in the Edit Sale.

Here are the full spoilers:

All new subscribers will be able to choose one of the following:

All new subscribers will be able to choose one of the following:

You can pick one of the following if you upgrade to an annual subscription (if you don't upgrade, FabFitFun will pick for you):

You can pick one of the following if you upgrade to an annual subscription (if you don't upgrade, FabFitFun will pick for you):

And everyone will receive:

Here is a closer look at wallet and scarf options that aren't pictured above:

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you haven't signed up for FabFitFun yet, use coupon code MSA10 to save $10 off of your first box!

Check out our FabFitFun reviews and FabFitFun Spoilers to see what you can expect from this subscription!

Starting at $54.99
Active Deal
20% off a seasonal box
Use Coupon Code MSA20
Subscribe Now

"FabFitFun is a seasonal lifestyle subscription that sends subscribers 6-8 items every season, worth up to $300 in value. Boxes include amazing products that are trend-savvy ranging from full-size skincare and beauty products, to wellness products, to accessories, to decor and more every season. ... read more.

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

59 comments

Steph

What? I just upgraded to annual so I could customize like this post claims and fabfitfun won’t let me do it! I chatted with customer service and everything. Awesome.

Reply ButtonReply

Cindy

If I (as an annual member) could get to make all the choices, I would buy this box. But since I already have most of this and do not want duplicates of that throw and the oils, I will not be buying the box. I really like the wallet and the scarf but not taking the chance that I will get what I do not want. Their loss!

Reply ButtonReply

Lynn

I also might have gotten the editors box if I could have customized. I don’t want another crappy throw. I would have been embarrassed to even gift it. I would have liked the scarf and more bubble masks and would have loved the pink wallet. I have loved the blaq eye masks from the winter box though and the thrive highlighter so if you’re thinking about the editors those two items are great. Hopefully that pink wallet will pop up in an add on sale or be up for trade.

Reply ButtonReply

Tracey

Love the black eye masks

Reply ButtonReply

TNTriathlete

If I am a new subscriber will I get the editor’s box and will I get to choose my items? I’m confused. Thanks for any help you can give!

Reply ButtonReply

TNTriathlete

Just an FYI for others. I pulled the trigger and I was allowed to customize two of the items, unfortunately not the one I wanted most which was the blush colored Aimee Kestenberg wallet. They must be out of the wallet or the scarf, probably the wallet. Bummer.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

It says if you upgrade to an annual you get to choose between the wallet and the throw.

JulieSR

Just got through looking at all if the sale items and this time around I just dont see anything very exciting 🙁 even the “sold out items” very just ehh… I usually have had to scale down on my order… removing things bc my cart was so full. (over doing it) This is my 3rd editors sale.

Did anyone else feel underwhelmed??? Just curious… Ty and Happy New Years to All.

Reply ButtonReply

Janice

yeah the only thing I liked was a hair mask I got that smells nice and the bubbling charcoal mask. Other than that .. not sure what to do with the rest of it and I NEVER seem to get what they show in the box. Think I’m going to cancel.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Yes, and I’m glad. They already have all my money 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Sissy

Yes oddly that was my feelings exactly

Reply ButtonReply

Marcie

I agree!

Reply ButtonReply

Deionna

I just have to give them a huge thumbs up because I think they have the BEST customer service out there. I did not receive my Ayesha Curry Mug in “Love You a Latte” I had ordered in my add ons but before I even sent an email about it they caught it themselves and not only did they send me a replacement “coming in hot” since they are out of the other,they also issued a refund and gave me $20 in add on credit! I will never cancel this box!

Reply ButtonReply

LB

I used to like their CS but it seems to be lacking for me lately. I ordered a volumizing hair dryer as an add on and it came without the attachment. I sent an email and pic in late November. It took them a week to respond and then asked for 2 weeks to send out replacement. After 3 weeks I emailed again and they claimed “inventory issue” but miraculously was able to send out the replacement that day. Coincidental. They are also offering the same hair dryer in the edit sale. It was supposed to be a Christmas gift but obviously that didn’t happen and didn’t really get an apology at all. Seems to be alot of chaos and errors lately…

Reply ButtonReply

Dawnn

I canceled at Winter, the first time in 2 years, but had to jump pretty happy with all the choices

Reply ButtonReply

Amber

That scarf is cute!

Reply ButtonReply

Krista

I did a live chat with customer service and was told that they will no longer be offering customization for any of the editors boxes for current subscribers. That sucks and isn’t a great way to reward your loyal subscribers! The only thing I really cared about is the pink flat wallet, and it’s not worth it to me to subscribe and hope that I get that choice. Especially when the other choice in that category is the same blanket that we literally just received. I was so ready to buy this box and now they just lost out on my money because of this!!

Reply ButtonReply

Alexa

What is the Donni Charm scarf made out of?

Reply ButtonReply

Caity

Its 100% acrylic.

Reply ButtonReply

LisaFalana

Pass. I don’t ever want to see another Mark & Graham throw again. That was the worst blanket type item Ive ever received in a sub. It snagged on the dog’s groomed nails, it snagged on the table, it snagged on my manicure, it snagged on my entire finger going through it, it snagged on a pen…ALL IN ONE WEEKEND! Nope. Never again.
(That scarf is cute though)

Reply ButtonReply

amanda

I really, really like the scarf. Don’t know if I can justify buying it just for that though.

Reply ButtonReply

Beth

Honestly this winter box would have been so much more of a hit for me if it had included that scarf (or even the wallet) instead of that icky blanket!

Reply ButtonReply

B

I thought the same at first… But then realized it was enough to justify getting the box for me because I have poor impulse control….

Reply ButtonReply

amanda

Yup, broke down and got it. Realized it was worth it for the scarf alone. It’s apparently a fair trade company, which is great.

LisaFalana

same

Reply ButtonReply

Brenda

If we are a current subscriber and buy this in the edit sale do we get choose items?

Reply ButtonReply

julie

Nope. If you click on the edit portion it tell you that you get no choice. It’s you get what you get. Better to start a new account, use a discount, choose what you want and cancel.

Reply ButtonReply

Dani

Last I checked it said there js no customization when buying from the edit sale

Reply ButtonReply

Sevvy

I would totally purchase this if I could choose the exfolikate without going annual. This looks better than the winter box for sure.

Reply ButtonReply

SHT

Much better than the winter box. I unsubscribed because that box was just not appealing to me.

Reply ButtonReply

Jem

I was mailed a second winter box a few weeks after receiving my regular winter box. I double checked my card statements and invoice and I was not charged, nor did i order a second box. Has this happened to anyone else?

Reply ButtonReply

Marcie

It happened to me last year.

Reply ButtonReply

Chantel

It’s haooened to me with the foreo box! I got one with all wrong options, called and was told they didn’t send my box yet?! It happened with my starter box too! I got two of them. They told me to keep them both.

After a week I received my actuak box with the right options. I’ve read of at least 10 people this has happened to. It’s a very costly mistake to make!

Reply ButtonReply

Redhed36

So current subscriber’s don’t get to customize but new subs do… No thanks. I was interested but it’s too much of a risk to receive the items I don’t want.

Reply ButtonReply

Tara

I just opened a live chat before resubscribing, and told the CS rep I was disappointed in the winter box and asked if it would be possible to resubscribe with the editor’s box. She said I could resubscribe and she could change it manually. I’m supposed to get a confirmation email by the end of the day, so fingers crossed!

Reply ButtonReply

Tara

I hope this doesn’t double post:

Update: I’m now scheduled to receive the editor’s box, according to my profile!

Reply ButtonReply

Cindy

Were you able to choose what you want from the choices above also?

LisaFalana

Good for you! Thanks for the update.

Tara

Update: within half an hour, my home page now says my editor’s box is getting ready to ship! Yay!

Reply ButtonReply

TNTriathlete

I can’t find any way to make the links work or through my FFF account. The only way for me to get a box is through the edit sale where the items will be random. I am confused. As Usual.

Reply ButtonReply

PudgeKat

So the editors box is only for new members . If you canceled your membership and reactivated it hoping for the editors box you will get the winter box instead. Wish this was clear as now I have to try to get a refund.

Reply ButtonReply

LB

Thanks for posting this. My annual is up and was considering actually re-subbing with my old email address for a new annual to choose everything but it sounds like I’d just get another winter box which I do not want. I’ve already been debating if I even want to get another annual and was gonna wait until spring spoilers so I’ll likely just do that. You saved me hassle and aggravation.

Reply ButtonReply

Redhed36

The editor’s box is available in the edit sale but is not customizable.

Reply ButtonReply

TNTriathlete

I am an annual member but when I signed up only the fall box was available. Can l get this one since l missed out on the winter box? Also there is an editor’s box in the edit sale. This would be better because you get to choose your items, correct?

Reply ButtonReply

ngeon

Liz, do you know whether I’d receive the Editor’s Box or the Winter Box if I were to reactivate a membership now? I think I’d use every single thing in this box regardless of the variations. I like it so much more than the winter box!

Reply ButtonReply

Dani

Someone above said they chatted with CS and were able to resubscribe with the editors box they just had to manually change it on the back end

Reply ButtonReply

Laura

I just did a live chat and she didn’t think she could do it and if she could she said I probably wouldn’t get my credit for resubscribing ( like my email offered). Then she left the chat without answering my last question. Basically “hanging up” on me. ??

Liz Cadman

I’ll reach out and ask.

Reply ButtonReply

PudgeKat

The winter box. This post is misleading- I reactivated my account to find out I was charged $53 for the winter box and can’t get the editor box as it’s only for new subs. Trying to get a refund

Reply ButtonReply

tam

Thanks for sharing this. I don’t want the winter box.

PudgeKat

I actually like the items in this one.

Reply ButtonReply

Preetam Singareddy

This box is probably the least exciting from them in a long time. So many of the products are repeats from previous boxes/sales.

Kate Somerville Exfolikate again? :/

Reply ButtonReply

tam

I actually like this box better than the last box and since I’m not a long term subscriber to FFF this one would work for me. However, I’m not reactivating my subscription if I’ll get the winter box instead of this one.

Reply ButtonReply

Trish63

tam, if you reactivate, you will get the winter box. I learned this by reactivating myself and am highly disappointed.

EmilyK

It is for NEW members so it will feature past favorites.

Reply ButtonReply

Jill m

The “Editors box” is supposed to have repeats in it. They pick the most loved products and curate the box with them. Exfolikate is a huge favorite for many subscribers so that’s probably why they put it in this box.

Reply ButtonReply